Monthly Archives: March 2012

Canberra 2012 – vintage of a lifetime, or a washout?

As I write in the opening days of autumn, a potentially great Canberra vintage hangs in the balance – threatened by a massive band of rain moving across southeastern Australia. If it hangs around too long, mildew and botrytis could threaten the crop; if too much rain falls, berries might split, increasing disease risks and reducing yields. Should mild, clear weather follow the big wet, however, the district may yet produce some of its best wines ever, say several producers. By the time you read this, we’ll have some idea of the outcome.

Never short of enthusiasm, Murrumbateman’s Ken Helm sees beyond the steady rain and drenched vineyards. “It’s a once in a lifetime season”, he declares, “and we still have a chance. I’ve seen nothing like in 40 years. We’ve had only four days over 30 degrees”.

Mild conditions leading up to the rain favoured flavour development at low sugar levels, report growers across the district. Helm says, “riesling in particular is outstanding. Even at nine Baume [a measure of sugar content] it tasted ripe. Normally your face would be like a chook’s bum. There’s a green tinge about riesling berries, like they have in Germany, and no sign of sunburn.”

Helm’s other specialty, cabernet sauvignon, still appears disease free and set for a normal crop. Helm says because it buds late, cabernet missed the poor weather that disrupted flowering in many shiraz vineyards around Murrumbateman.

Fellow Murrumbateman vigneron, Greg Gallagher, said rain and windstorms around flowering time resulted in “loose” shiraz benches ­– meaning less grapes to the bunch and lower yields overall. Perversely, laughs Gallagher, those loose bunches make the weather-hardy shiraz even more disease resistant.

A couple of days before the rain, Gallagher’s chardonnay, destined for sparkling wine, looked in beautiful condition. But he now waits anxiously for the rain to end. He says pinot noir for bubbly, harvested from Pankhurst vineyard, Hall, before the rain was spectacular.

At Long Rail Gully, Murrumbateman, Garry Parker, described a wait-and-see, edgy situation. Until the rain, everything appeared perfect, with good yields expected for all varieties – except shiraz, because of its small bunches. “Richard [Garry’s son and winemaker] said pinot gris and riesling will be the first we pick. He looked at them in fear and trepidation, but so far they’re unaffected by the rain”, says Garry.

With both white varieties close to ripening, a seven-day withholding period means no more spraying, even if disease appears, says Parker

At Jeir Creek, Murrumbateman, Rob Howell reports a savage hailstorm two weeks before the rain arrived ripping through several vineyards. It wiped out a quarter of Jeir Creek’s grapes and damaged the neighbouring Ravensworth (Bryan and Jocelyn Martin), Dark Horse (Carpenter family, Lark Hill) and Nanima (Wayne and Jennie Fischer) vineyards.

After the hail, Howell “went into drying-out damaged berry mode. But the rain’s not helping now”, says Howell. He expects to harvest chardonnay and pinot noir for sparkling wine immediately after the rain and says overall fruit quality appears very high. “Viogner looks superb, shiraz is down and cabernet’s looking good, because of its thick skin”, Howell says.

Winemaker Alex McKay (Collector and Bourke Street brands), owns no vineyards but sources grapes from growers across the district. He’s distinctly upbeat about the vintage, despite some similarities with last year’s cool, wet conditions.

He recalls lots of nervousness about the outcome this time last year. But despite some disease-related crop losses, Canberra enjoyed a fantastic vintage. McKay reports, “better disease control this year, with very little botrytis [botrytis cinerea, a destructive fungus] and vineyards still looking very clean”. He attributes lower expected yields across the district in 2012 to the lasting effect of last year’s wet conditions.

To date he sees, “Excellent vine health and berry size, very good flavour building, still natural acids and attractive tannins developing in the reds”. He expects to harvest Rhone Valley white varieties (the viognier looking very good) late in the first week of March and shiraz from mid March. He says Nick O’Leary’s began picking very good riesling in mid to late February.

McKay believes the healthy vines should resist disease pressures from the present rain. He believes mildew presents a greater risk earlier in the season as new foliage emerges and that botrytis outbreaks are more likely.

Heavy rain followed by warm weather also presents a risk of berry split as vines suck up water and grapes swell. But McKay believes the risk to be lower this year thanks to previously well-watered vines.

Jennie Mooney, an owner of Capital Wines and its Kyeema Vineyard, Murrumbateman also sees berry split as less likely this year. She says, “In 2010 we came out of drought into a massive downpour, followed by hot sun. The vines transpired heavily, took up water and the berries split”.

But as insurance this year, says Mooney, husband Mark encouraged weed growth under the vines. When the rain stops they expect the weeds to compete with the vines, limiting water uptake and risk of berry split.

Mooney says, “The fruit’s a bit like 2011 – flavours arriving at low Baumes [sugar content] with high acidity. Merlot’s the best Mark’s ever tasted. Merlot likes having its feet wet”.

Despite the rain and risk it poses, Mooney remains, “Nervously hopeful”. She says it’s a difficult year and in the end success will get down to good vineyard management. At Kyeema, she says, “we’ve done lots of canopy work, with disease management ongoing, all season”.

At Brindabella Hills, Hall (Canberra’s lowest vineyards), winemaker Brian Sinclair reports normal crops, even of shiraz, and “incredibly good” quality across the varieties. He says, “I haven’t seen sauvignon blanc or riesling looking as good as it is. It’s ideal. The riesling has no disease, a terrific canopy and no sunburn”. Sinclair believes, “things should progress well” despite the rain.

Up on the northern slopes of Mount Majura, Frank van de Loo reports 9.5 tonnes of a projected 52-tonne harvest safely in tanks. Mainly chardonnay and pinot noir for sparkling, van de Loo describes it as, “the best yet after five years’ experience [with sparkling material]”.

He says the cool season is producing light crops with exciting flavours and aromatics, arriving at low sugar levels. He rated one batch of chardonnay, pickable at a low 10.5–11 Baume – very rare in Canberra’s climate – and ripe-tasting riesling at 10 Baume. The red varieties, however, remain some weeks off.

Van de Loo rates berry split as the main risk, saying, “I’m worried about the duration rather the quantity [of rain]. If the vines are too wet for too long the berries could split”.

Jim Lumbers of Lerida Estate, Lake George, said “It was picture perfect until today”, “and now it looks like a re-run of 2011 – a ground hog day vintage”. Nevertheless, expects the early varieties to be fine – pinot noir for rose, pinot gris and chardonnay, despite “massive acids”.

He still sees the possibility of the vintage turning out really well. But even if disease takes it toll, Lerida has sorting tables. This allows us to take the hit of lower quantity while keeping our quality”.

Vineyard high up on the Lake George escarpment, opposite Bungendore, live in a different climate than most of Canberra’s other vineyards – some 300 metres higher than Hall, 200 metres higher than Murrumbateman, and more than 100 metres above Mount Majura and Lake George.

At Lark Hill vintage is still six weeks away, with the whites just through veraison [where the berries begin to soften] and the only red, pinot noir, just half way through.

Winemaker Chris Carpenter says 2012 may end up as the coolest on record at Lark Hill, having dipped below 1989, the previous coldest – though unlikely to match 1989’s 1000mm rainfall for the growing season.

He foresees a late vintage with intense fruit flavours and high acidity across the district. He wonders aloud what makers will do with high levels of malic acid in chardonnay – as fashion, in recent years, moved away from the secondary fermentation (malo-lactic) that reduced it, to more austere, high-acid styles.

At present, he says, Lark Hill remains disease free with good crop levels. The Carpenter’s recently acquire Dark Horse vineyard at Murrumbateman, however, lost half its crop to the recent hailstorm.

It smashed fruit on the vine and defoliated one side, impairing their ability to ripen the remaining fruit”, says Carpenter. To encourage new leaves, the Carpenters have added nutrition and intend to bunch-thin if necessary. Bunch thinning matches the fruit load to the ripening ability of the foliage.

Carpenter says Lark Hill began trialling biological control of botrytis this year – spraying vines with bacteria that compete with the fungus. In theory, supported by producer trials, says Carpenter, the bacteria become established, providing long-term protection.

While that offers hope for the future, Canberra vignerons keep an anxious eye on the weather and remain hopeful of healthy crops in the weeks ahead.

It seemed like forty days and nights, but after almost a week the deluge finally ceased on Sunday 4 March. On Monday 5 March, Canberra vignerons woke to a mild, mainly sunny day.

At Four Winds Vineyard, Murrumbateman, John Collingwood harvested riesling, anxious to beat an outbreak of botrytis. “It was just starting”, he said. But in the end he cut out only about five per cent, delivering 18 healthy tonnes (a normal-sized harvest) to winemaking brother-in-law, Bill Crowe.

Crowe says the riesling’s looking pretty good, with high acidity and even lower sugar than last year’s fruit.

While the rain slowed grape development down, Collingwood remains hopeful of a good red harvest in three to four weeks. He says there’s a little botrytis in the denser bunches, so success depends on the weather. Warm, dry weather should contain the fungus; but it could get running if it rains.

Sangiovese shows a little more fruit split than shiraz, says Collingwood. But the loose, open shiraz bunches are proving resilient. Tough-skinned cabernet looks in good condition, he says, and merlot’s travelling well.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 14 March 2012 in The Canberra Times and The Sydney Morning Herald

Wine review — Best’s, Stonier, Stefano Lubiana, Pizzini, Battle of Bosworth and Grant Burge

Best’s Thomson Family Shiraz 2010 – wine of the week $180
Concongella Vineyard, Great Western, Grampians, Victoria

In 1867 Henry Best planted the Concongella vineyard, Great Western. The Thomson family bought the vineyard in 1920 – and today those same shiraz vines, tended by Viv Thomson and family, supply the grapes for this extraordinary red. Much has been written of vine age and wine quality. In this instance we drink the glory of venerable old vines – completely at home in their environment – delivering an elegant wine of enormous, sweet-fruited flavour concentration. Thomson makes only about 300 dozen and only in exceptional years. It’s a great and unique shiraz, capable of long-term cellaring.

Stonier Pinot Noir 2010 $21.80–$28
Mornington Peninsula, Victoria

After a long, difficult struggle from 1978, Brian Stonier eventually made outstanding pinot noir from the early 1990s. Petaluma later took over the business but was itself acquired by brewer, Lion Nathan – now part of Japan’s Kirin Brewery. However, the style and quality of the wines powered through the ownership changes. The latest pinot, sourced from 15 vineyards – all the fruit hand harvested ¬– displays the delicate, refined Stonier style: pale to medium colour; aroma and flavour show red-berry fruit with a savoury pinot seam, backed by fine, silky tannins.

Stefano Lubiana Vintage Brut 2004 $53–$58
Lubiana Vineyard, Granton, Derwent Valley, Tasmania

Lubiana, along with Arras (made by Ed Carr), demonstrate why cool Tasmania became Australia’s bubbly hot spot. It starts with the intense but delicate flavours of the purpose-grown fruit. After that Steve Lubiana’s winemaking and blending skills come into play – capturing the fruit flavour then, through clever blending (55 per cent chardonnay, 45 per cent pinot noir) and almost six years’ maturation in bottle on yeast lees. Like France’s great Champagnes, it’s rich and textured beyond the fruit – because of the winemaking and maturation. But delicate fruit remains at the centre. Indeed, without these the winemaking inputs would add up to nothing.

Pizzini Prosecco 2011 $19
King Valley, Victoria

What an enormous contrast between Pizzini Prosecco and Lubiana 2004, the two sparkling wines reviewed today – the latter a wine of gravitas, to savour and wonder at; the former for happy quaffing. Winemaking simply captures the prosecco grape’s freshness and light, spicy, green-apple tartness. The lightness and tartness make it enjoyable on its own or with pretty well any food – a pleasant backdrop that refreshes the mouth, allowing the food to star.

Battle of Bosworth Shiraz 2010 $19.50–$25
Edgehill Vineyard, McLaren Vale, South Australia

The Bosworth family planted grapes in McLaren Vale in the 1840s. Today Joch Bosworth, with partner Louise Hemsley-Smith, operates the organically certified Edgehill Vineyard, established by Peter and Anthea Bosworth in the 1970s. The vineyard supplies the grapes for their Battle of Bosworth label. Their 2010 shows a savoury, medium bodied side of the regional shiraz style. The colour’s deep, but not opaque; and the aroma presents fruit, spice and savouriness – reflected in the flavours of a rich, savoury, well-structured palate.

Grant Burge Daly Road Shiraz Mourvedre 201o $15.90–$20
Burge Daly Road vineyard, Lyndoch, Barossa Valley, South Australia

If you like full, juicy Barossa wines, you’ll fall in love with Grant Burge’s vibrant, purple-rimmed shiraz mourvedre blend. This is big and ripe but gentle Barossa – capturing the tender, slurpy fruitiness of shiraz, tempered by the savour, spice and firm tannins of mourvedre. The blend is 60 per cent shiraz; 40 per cent mourvedre, all from Burge’s Daly Road vineyard, located near Lyndoch, at the southern end of the Barossa Valley.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 14 March 2012 in The Canberra Times

Wine review — Mount Trio, Smith & Hooper and Cumulus

Mount Trio Great Southern Riesling 2010 $19
Gavin and Gill Graham own vineyards at Porongurup, a small, elevated sub-region of Western Australia’s large Great Southern area. The area excels with riesling and shiraz, but you’ll find all the usual Australian varieties as you drive around. Mount Trio offers a pretty good example of the local riesling style – at two years, the acidity’s softening off but still gives a brisk tingle and backbone to the lemony varietal flavour. At a recent office tasting it attracted more “likes” than a Wrattonbully semillon sauvignon blanc and a Hunter Valley unwooded chardonnay.

Smith and Hooper Wrattonbully Sauvignon Blanc Semillon 2011 $16–$22
If we have to drink sauvignon blanc, let’s bolster it with semillon, in the dry Bordeaux style. In this example from Robert Hill-Smith’s Yalumba group, the winemakers fermented one fifth of the blend in old oak, leaving this component on the spent yeast cells (lees), and stirring the lees every two weeks. The process builds a rich texture and subtle flavours that, together with the semillon, contribute so much to the drinking pleasure. But sauvignon blanc still exerts its pungent, herbal flavour and zesty acidity.

Cumulus Wines Climbing Orange Pinot Gris 2011 $18–$22
In the difficult, wet and cool 2011 vintage some white varieties, including pinot gris, seem to have fared particularly well – for example, in last year’s local wine show, Mount Majura Vineyard won a gold medal for its 2011; and at the recent Tasmanian show, the extraordinary Bay of Fires 2011 won the special chairman’s trophy. And over in even cooler Orange, Cumulus wines harvested this scrumptious, bronze-tinted drop. Winemaker Debbie Lauritz really captures the character of this often-lacklustre variety – fresh and intense, with pear-like flavour and rich, slightly viscous texture.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 11 March 2012 in The Canberra Times

Wine review — Greywacke, Cumulus, Helm, Shaw Vineyard Estate, Kirrihill and Chapel Hill

Greywacke Sauvignon Blanc 2011 $23–$28
Brancott Valley and Wairau Plains, Marlborough, New Zealand

Greywacke’s Kevin Judd and sauvignon blanc go back to 1983. As winemaker at Selaks, Auckland, Judd made some of the first New Zealand sauvignon blancs to be promoted in Australia, starting here in Canberra under the Selaks and 1984 Farmer Brothers labels. Judd then joined David Hohnen at Cloudy Bay, the brand that sold the sizzle of Marlborough sauvignon blanc to the world. After 25 vintages at Cloudy Bay, Judd left and launched his own wines – including this brilliant example of the variety. It offers pure, in-your-face varietal aroma, a fleshy, juicy mid palate and mouth-watering vitality.

Cumulus Chardonnay 2010 $30
Blocks 14B and 15, Cumulus Vineyard, Orange, New South Wales

Orange covers an even wider range of altitudes than Canberra. To be included in the region, vineyards need to be at least 600 metres above sea level – and some sit above the 1,000-metre mark. Because of its extent (508-hectares) and variations in altitude, Cumulus vineyard rolls in and out of Orange. The higher sections contributed to this delicious chardonnay, made by Debbie Lauritz. Oak-fermentation and maturation added texture and spicy oak character to the intense grapefruit and white peach varietal flavour. Looks very young and fresh now and should age well for five or so years.

Helm Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 $35
Murrumbateman, Canberra District, New South Wales

In the shadow of shiraz, Ken Helm maintains a faith in Canberra cabernet, working tirelessly with neighbouring grape grower Al Lustenburger to bring out the best in the variety. In the outstanding 2009 vintage, Helm’s is an elegantly structured wine, built on pure, just-ripe, delicate, cabernet flavours. Helm’s inclusion of French oak, along with his previously favoured American oak, sits more sympathetically with the elegant fruit – lending a pleasant cedary note. However, the oak slightly outweighs the fruit at this stage (though the two may integrate with time).

Shaw Vineyard Estate Premium Riesling 2011 $22
Shaw Vineyard, Murrumbateman, Canberra District, New South Wales
In the tough 2011 vintage, Graeme Shaw produced just 300 cases of Premium riesling – a bronze medal winner at the 2011 Canberra Regional Wine Show. The wine displays the marginal ripeness and high acidity of the cold vintage. This pleasant tartness, and a low alcohol content (11.5 per cent), make it a good aperitif, especially with cold, savoury food.

Kirrihill Single Vineyard Tullymore Vineyard Shiraz 2009 $16.15–$19
Tullymore Vineyard, Clare Valley, South Australia

Kirrihill is a large operation, sourcing grapes from over 1,300 hectares of vineyards, located 350–550 metres above sea level in the Clare Valley. Winemaker Donna Stephens sourced grapes for this wine from the Tullymore Vineyard, to the east of Clare township. It’s a generous, ripe, plummy, juicy red with a touch of Clare’s distinctive mint character. A load of soft tannins adds richness and structure to this attractive, drink-now, traditional Australian shiraz.

Chapel Hill Shiraz 2009 $28.49–$30
McLaren Vale, South Australia

Chapel Hill delivers an especially vibrant, satisfying drinking experience, capturing the earthy richness of McLaren Vale shiraz without going over the top on tannin or oak. The lovely, perfumed varietal aroma and lively, fruity palate suggests winemakers Michael Fragros and Bryn Richards harvested at the peak of ripeness. A long post-ferment maceration on skins, gentle basket pressing and 20-months maturation in a combination of new and old oak integrated the firm but smooth tannins completely with the fruit. The result is a generous, savoury regional shiraz of a very high order.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 7 March 2012 in The Canberra Times

Wine review — Cumulus, Lerida Estate and Anderson

Cumulus Orange Shiraz 2009 $30
Unlike Canberra where shiraz and riesling have become our signature varieties, the even higher, cooler Orange district seems to make a bit of everything, with no clear regional hero emerging – though chardonnay is, perhaps, the strongest contender to date. I’ve seen some decent shirazes, too, including Cumulus, sourced from two blocks on the company’s 508-hectare estate. It’s a medium-bodied, fine-boned, savoury style, built on ripe, black cherry and black pepper varietal flavours. A seam of fine but firm tannins emphasises the wine’s savoury character. Made by Debbie Lauritz.

Lerida Estate Lake George Pinot Rose 2011 $18
Lerida distinguishes itself from most other dry roses by its high acidity – a blessing of the exceptionally wet, cool 2011 season. Where others opt for the mouth-filling roundness that accompanies low acidity, Lerida harnesses the brisk acidity to accentuate the delicate, bright, strawberry-like pinot varietal flavour. The acidity also provides a clean, fresh finish, much as it does in a white wine. But despite the wine’s very light colour, the pleasant bite of tannin ensures we’ll see it more as a pale red than a tinted white. It’s made to enjoy right now.

Anderson Rutherglen Basket Press Durif 2007 $24
Rutherglen’s idiosyncratic red specialty, once impenetrably black and thunder-in-the-brain tannic, now comes in a toned down version. Several wineries, including Anderson, make an approachable, early-drinking style durif, without losing the variety’s ink-deep colour and rich tannins. In this version father and daughter Howard and Christobelle Anderson keep the alcohol comparatively low at 12.3 per cent yet retain attractive, ripe aromas and flavours. On the supple palate, smooth, round tannins mesh pleasantly with those ripe, juicy fruit flavours. It’s a generous, soft, fruity wine and ready to put a smile on your face now.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 4 March 2012 in The Canberra Times