Category Archives: People

Wine review — Curly Flat, Williams Crossing, Grant Burge, Heartland Wines and Angoves

Curly Flat Williams Crossing Pinot Noir 2008 $24–$27
Curly Flat vineyard, Macedon Ranges, Victoria
Williams Crossing sometimes outscores its more expensive cellar mate at the annual Macedon wine show. As a judge there on several occasions I’ve consistently marked both at the top of the pack, for the simple reason that they deliver the magic of this beautiful variety. Owners Phillip and Jeni Moraghan make every batch of pinot as a candidate for the flagship blend. And the Williams Crossing components fall out only “as a result of a structured barrel classification tasting – 27 per cent of 2008 pinot noir were declassified”, writes Phillip. The declassified barrels comprise this medium bodied pinot of modest alcohol and what can best be described as true “pinosity”.

Curly Flat Pinot Noir 2008 $48–$54
Curly Flat Vineyard, Macedon Ranges, Victoria
This is a great success in a hot, dry vintage. Phillip Moraghan says the mean January temperature, at 22 degrees, exceeded the long-term average by five degrees. The heat continued in February and March, when the temperature exceeded 35 degrees for eight days. The wine bears the vintage thumbprint but not in the most obvious way – as the alcohol’s just 12.6 per cent. The fruit flavour, however, sits more in the dark-berry and than red-berry spectrum. And the firm tannins holding the fruit in check also reflect the warm growing conditions. So, rather than a big, hot wine, we have a fragrant, complex, savoury, elegant pinot with delicious fruit under the taut structure.

Grant Burge The Holy Trinity
Grenache Shiraz Mourvedre 2008 $28.49–$36

Barossa Valley, South Australia
Grant Burge’s original Holy Trinity, from the 1995 vintage, good as it was, wouldn’t bear comparison to the 2008, despite similar fruit sourcing. It’s a classic Barossa blend, brought to life by the so-called “Rhone rangers” in the 1980s. Restless to improve his, Burge and winemaker Craig Stansborough visited France’s Rhone Valley in 1996. Upon return, they introduced longer maceration on skins, altering the flavour and softening the tannins, and wound back the oak influence – opting for maturation, rather than oak flavour, in older 2,200 litre vessels. In the hot 2008 this means a robust, deeply fruity, supple red with aromatic grenache high notes, shiraz plumpness and savoury, firm mourvedre tannins.

Heartland Wines Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 $17–$20
Langhorne Creek and Limestone Coast, South Australia
Heartland Wines, owned by a consortium of long-term wine industry people, has been a major exporter, with access to the partners’ 210-hectare Langhorne Creek vineyard and 160-hectare Limestone Coast vineyard. Winemaker Ben Glaetzer has wine in his blood, too, with his father, Colin, and father’s twin brother, John (former Wolf Blass maker), both winemakers. Heartland 2009 shows the fruity aromatics of the vintage – quite pure and mulberry-like, in an unmistakably cabernet way, with a sweet kiss of oak. The bright fruit carries to the generous, lively palate, cut by fine tannins. It’s mainly about juicy, drink-now appeal, but has the depth to hold for four or five years.

Heartland Wines Dolcetto Lagrein 2009 $18.95–$22
Langhorne Creek and Limestone Coast, South Australia
Good fruit and very clever winemaking here from Ben Glaetzer, produces unique flavours and enjoyable drinking. It’s a 50:50 blend of the northern Italian varieties dolcetto and lagrein – the former noted for its aromatics and brilliant colour, the latter for its sometimes-intimidating tannins. Glaetzer tames the lagrein tannins, to some degree, by ageing the wine in oak barrels. The dolcetto he keeps in stainless steel to retain its wonderful perfume. The blend is highly perfumed and fruity on the nose; spritely, tart and fresh on the jube-like fruity palate; and finishes with a farewell bite of tannin.

Angoves Vineyard Select Chardonnay 2009 $15–$20
Limestone Coast, South Australia
The older vintage suggests lagging sales, attributable, perhaps, to the sauvignon blanc phenomenon. The press release says (hopefully) “it’s a great example of modern Australian chardonnay from the best region for this variety in South Australia”. In truth, however, it’s in older style that many people love, from a decent, but not cutting edge, chardonnay region. Sourced from vineyards at Padthaway and Cape Jaffa, it offers rich-to-fat melon and peach flavours with an obvious layer of oak. It’s not in the bright, fine and lively modern style at all, but will appeal to the many people who enjoy full-on, plump chardonnays.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Farewell Jim Murphy — Canberra’s tenacious retailer

How did Jim Murphy thrive in Canberra’s competitive liquor retail environment over all those decades? He set up shop in the late seventies, just as the Trade Practices Act (aided in Canberra by liberalised licensing laws) precipitated a complete restructuring of wine production, distribution and retailing Australia wide.

Yet Jim successfully stepped from the genteel world of wine selling at the Australian National University into the then brutal world of Canberra liquor retailing. Retail competitors at the time gave him little hope of survival.

I met Jim just before the transition. I was already a retail competitor and remained one for the next 28 years. Today’s article therefore presents the subjective view of a former commercial adversary.

Towards the end of 1976 Jim agreed to cater for my wedding at the ANU staff centre early the next year. A poor student, taking a vacation job at Farmer Bros Wine and Spirit Merchants, I suggested bringing my own wine. The brothers were cheaper than him, I explained.

After that diplomatic start, we haggled, and Jim agreed (very generously, in retrospect) on BYO bubbly, provided the staff centre supplied the rest. The wedding proceeded smoothly, the vacation job became a career and our paths crossed every now and then until Jim’s death on 26 May.

Richard and David Farmer had opened Farmer Bros at Manuka in June 1975. The store became a sensation, offering discounted wine of all types, from casks to Grange.

David Farmer recalls how the new store attracted Jim’s clients from the university, eventually prompting Jim to check out the usurper. Farmer recalls, “Jim was Canberra’s wine authority then and I don’t think Manuka went down too well”.

In the ensuing years Canberra drinkers raked in the wine bargains as the competition heated up. Farmer Bros led the charge, quickly developing a national following through a press-ad-driven mail order business. Liquor licences spread into grocery stores, putting wine in every suburban shopping centre. And two vigorous independents – Peter and Mary Tyson’s The Grog Shop and John and Roby Brown’s Candamber – took on Farmer Bros in the discount wine stakes.

But Jim Murphy avoided the discount scrum, quietly opening at what we competitors regarded as a second-tier, weekend-only site opposite, Fyshwick fruit and vegetable markets. How wrong we were.

Throughout the eighties and until 1994 Farmer Bros retained its dominance in the Canberra wine market – and became a major force nationally, with an Australia-wide mail order business and stores in Sydney and Melbourne. The Grog Shop survived only a few years but Candamber and Jim Murphy prospered.

Like Farmer Bros, Candamber relied heavily on a mailing list to drive traffic to its stores. But Jim Murphy stuck to one outlet at this time, steadily building a personal following – never letting competitors set his agenda.

Long-time customer Jac Cousin runs off a list of attributes behind Murphy’s success and customer loyalty: being at the shop front to meet and greet, his knowledge, carrying a good selection, having stuff (especially old wines) others didn’t have, giving reasonable advice on buying for particular situations, making sure things ran as he wanted and “being a great bloke to deal with”.

Cousin particularly liked Jim’s lunches where “people could relax and get in a mood to buy more than they should” – and learn about wine from guest winemakers.

By the late eighties the independent trade controlled the bottled wine market across Australia. The major retail chains had moved into liquor, but their move into fine was half a decade off.

During this time Canberra experienced a particularly sharp burst of competition after the brothers Farmer split up. After a short, sharp bidding war, David and Josephine Farmer – with the support of partners including Shane and Nada Sinclair, myself, Jill Shanahan and David Harding – took complete control of Farmer Bros. Richard Farmer promptly set up his own liquor retailing business in competition and all hell broke loose – to the great joy (and confusion) of Canberra wine drinkers.

I was there in the thick of it, watching Farmer Bros sales grow, even as Richard Farmer’s sales took off. This had to be at the expense of competitors, including Murphy. But Murphy quietly sidestepped hostilities and ultimately outlasted both brothers.

Farmer Bros survived Richard Farmer by several years. But the collapse of Farmer Bros, towards the end of 1994, probably benefited Murphy and Canberra’s other independent retailers. The collapse also coincided with a decision by Coles’ liquor head office in Sydney to move into the fine wine market.

Canberra and Murphy didn’t feel any impact at first. But the scene was now set for a massive liquor market grab by Coles and, later, Woolworths. The competition Murphy faced between the late seventies and mid nineties would turn out to be nothing compared to what followed.

It started slowly, then built. As independents filled the gap left by Farmer Bros’ demise, Liquorland Australia Pty Ltd (the liquor arm of Coles) acquired Farmer Bros’ stores – only to find that only one of the five in Canberra, Manuka, worked without the mailing list and wine club newsletters. Cellarmaster Wines, one of the world’s great direct marketers, had already acquired these.

The Liquorland acquisition of Farmer Bros, then, didn’t initially put any pressure on Canberra’s independents. But in October 1994 Liquorland opened its first Vintage Cellars outlet at Mosman Junction, Sydney. “That’s when we got serious about wine”, recalls former Managing Director, Craig Watkins.

A national rollout of the Vintage Cellars brand proceeded rapidly, and included re-badging the original Farmer Bros store at Manuka and opening a second outlet at Woden Plaza. Shane Sinclair and I had joined Coles liquor following the demise of Farmer Bros and played key roles in the Vintage Cellars roll out. By the end of the nineties, Coles, through these outlets, had taken a significant slice of the Canberra fine wine market – giving Jim Murphy and other retailers a dose of competition – and glimpse of where the supermarkets were headed.

By the turn of the century Coles dominated the liquor and fine wine market in Australia. But in the opening years of the new century Coles liquor lost the plot, allowing Woolworths to gain the upper hand. A liquor juggernaut called Dan Murphy was about to sweep the country, Canberra included.

Belatedly, Coles launched its own “big box” brand, First Choice, to counter Dan Murphy’s growing might. Today, tiny Canberra has three Dan Murphy and three First Choice outlets – a massive presence for such a small population. Yet Jim Murphy not only survived their rollout, but opened a second store, at the airport, run by his son Adrien (AJ).

Tony Leon, former partner of the late Dan Murphy, managed the brand’s Australia wide rollout for Woolworths. He later left Woolworths and now drives the expansion of Coles-owned First Choice.

Leon says, “I’ve always believed a successful independent can survive against the likes of First Choice and Dan Murphy”. He says he never met Jim Murphy, but knew his business and regarded him as very good retailer.

Leon adds, “I’ve tried to buy him from both sides – but he said no. He must’ve been confident about his business to do that”.

Former Coles Liquor boss, Craig Watkins, knew Jim and often visited Market Cellars, impressed by Murphy’s success at an out of the way site. “He was always successful – a fantastic negotiator, a great relationship builder, respected by suppliers and a street fighter. He was always going to succeed, even when Dan Murphy and First Choice came to town. He saw very early not to put too much emphasis on beer and spirits and that wine is sexy. The politically powerful and big business were Jim’s customers”.

Long-term friend, winemaker and supplier, David O’Leary, says, “Jim knew a hell of a lot about the consumer and what the consumer wanted”. He recalls weekend visits to Market Cellars every year since the mid eighties, working the floor, talking to tasters, talking at the Sunday lunch – “and going home Monday totally shagged”.

O’Leary’s friendship with Murphy began around 1985 or 1986. As a 25 year old O’Leary been sent to Hardy’s Tintara Winery, to sort out the red wines – bringing fruit and body back to wines that’d gone off track in recent years.

He says, “Jim was a great friend of the Hardy family, especially Bill and Tom and often came across to Hardys”. O’Leary promoted Hardy’s wines during his first trips to Market Cellars. But when O’Leary moved to Annie’s Lane and later set up O’Leary Walker with Nick Walker, Jim offered support. “Jim became a terrific sling shot for us”, says O’Leary.

Former competitor David Farmer believes Jim Murphy was probably one of the last of the old-time wine merchants, in the traditional English sense – the sort that “you need one in your life to guide and teach, and it has to be about good times and friends”, says Farmer.

With Coles and Woolworths now holding around 79 per cent of the bottled wine market, winemakers and consumers alike need strong independents like Jim Murphy. Fortunately for Canberra, the Murphy family remains committed to the business. Family spokesman, Michael says Jim’s younger son, AJ, will oversee both stores. “He’s a chip off the old block”, says Phelps.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Show judges too cool-climate orientated says Grant Burge

Visiting Canberra two weeks back, Barossa vigneron Grant Burge rated 2010 his “best white vintage in 10 years”.  Then came the highs and lows of a wet 2011 season, “throwing up all the diseases in one year”, devastating crops in many vineyards, and driving up spraying and vineyard costs across the board.

In his own vineyards – about 400 hectares, mainly in the southern Barossa – Burge sprayed against disease 12 to 16 times, instead of the usual four. And when late-season rain spurred outbreaks of botrytis cinerea, vineyard workers cut out infected berries by hand.

Faced by unrelenting disease pressures, says Burge, “some growers stopped spraying, because they felt uncertain about the final result”. Better to cut their losses early, they reasoned, than to spend more on spraying when there might be no grapes to sell in any event. Some lost their entire crops.

As a winemaker needing every berry, Burge persisted and in the end reaped a good harvest from his own vineyards. In the final ripening period, he says, mild to cool weather settled on the Barossa, bringing healthy fruit to flavour ripeness at unusually low sugar levels. Reds at Burge’s elevated Corryton Park Vineyard, for example, came in at around 12.5 to 13.4 Baume (a measure of sugar), instead of the usual 14 plus.

The low temperatures at ripening produced intense flavours and high natural acidity in the whites, says Burge, and now believes they’ll be even better than the 2010s.

He rates Barossa Valley ahead of the adjoining, cooler Eden Valley in 2011, particularly for cabernet sauvignon. Burge’s Corryton Park vineyard – normally much cooler than the Barossa floor, and more akin to Coonawarra – usually produces his best cabernet.

But in 2011, says Burge, “cabernet sauvignon off the valley floor is the best in 25 years. If fact, I’ve never seen the quality before. I’ve never seen the purple colour on the floor, like at Corryton, but it’s black-purple”.

Overall, says Burge, 2011 wines seem generally leaner, very pure in their fruit expression, less alcoholic and needing time to mature – comments closely paralleling the Canberra 2011 experience.

Burge visited Canberra to promote his flagship Barossa shiraz, Meshach ($155), released, like Grange, at five years. But Burge operates on a large scale for a private Australian producer – and the styles he makes extend far beyond the more expensive reds behind his reputation.

Burge’s 400-plus hectares of vines supply only 60 per cent of company needs. The other 40 per cent comes from about 20 long-term growers, says Burge.

He now makes more white wine than red, largely through the success of his $30-a-bottle sparkling wines, sourced from the cool Adelaide Hills (immediately to the south of Eden Valley on the Mount Lofty Ranges).

But Burge’s most intense passion clearly lies in his beloved Barossa reds.  On this trip he’s showing us Meshach 2006 (straight shiraz, mainly from the Filsell vineyard) and Holy Trinity 2008 ($36), a blend of grenache, shiraz and mourvedre.

They’re beautiful examples of their styles – Meshach made since 1988 and Holy Trinity from 1995. While we might call them “traditional” robust, warm-climate styles, they’re both thoroughly modern wines, expressing regional fruit flavours first and foremost, and benefiting from careful fine-tuning over the years.

While the market still loves them, Burge laments a shift away from the style in wine shows. He says the judges are now “all cool-climate orientated. I went to a few shows last year with Craig [winemaker Craig Stansborough] and warm climate wines like McLaren Vale and Barossa couldn’t get a look in. Anything showing American oak got kicked out. But some of the cool shirazes were tried were just green. I understand they need to show a lead for the industry, but they shouldn’t get too far from the public. The judges now have a narrow focus”.

He sees it as a worrying trend that wine judges today tend to award a narrower range of styles now than an older generation did in the past.

Burge offers interesting insights into international markets, too. He exports to 32 countries, sees opportunities for strong brands despite our dollar’s strength. Describing China as “the wild, wild east”, he’s built export volumes of high quality wine there through “individuals all over the place” and expects ultimately to have a central distributor.

He’s neve done much in the United States but plans to attack the market in the near future and sees huge potential there for good wine. Research, however, revealed a widespread perception in America that Australia doesn’t make good quality wine – a stereotype, he believes, created by the success of cheap, fruity wines like Yellowtail.

He’ll therefore emphasise Barossa Valley, not Australia, as Grant Burge wines roll out across America.

Oh, and the wines? See Grant Burge Meshach 2006 and Thorn Vineyard Eden Valley Riesling 2010  in today’s reviews and Holy Trinity 2008 next week.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Wine review — Pepper Tree, Grant Burge, Vasse Felix, Chrismont and Rutherglen Estate

Pepper Tree Limited Release Chardonnay 2010 $22
Wrattonbully, South Australia
Yes, this is the third Jim Chatto-made chardonnay reviewed here in as many weeks – expressing yet another facet of the variety. First we saw the thrilling acid spine and intense nectarine-like flavour of Orange chardonnay; then the generous, round, softness and delicacy of the Lower Hunter version. Now we finish with what Chatto calls a Burgundian style, made with the French “Bernard” clones grown at Wrattonbully, near Coonawarra. The underlying varietal flavour seems more melon- and fig-like, but it’s bound up in a tight, fine structure. The barrel and lees influences are subtle indeed, but the overall impact is of restrained power with elegance. All three Peppertree chardonnays deliver rare quality at their prices.

Grant Burge Thorn Riesling 2010 $15–$17
Thorn Vineyard, Eden Valley, South Australia
Grant Burge first bought fruit from the Thorn family’s Eden Valley vineyard in 1988. Now 30 years old, the vines produced magic in 2010 – a peculiar vintage, says Burge, ending with a very cool ripening period, ideal for white varieties. In Thorn this translates to a beautifully aromatic riesling, featuring floral and lime-like varietal character. The intense, zesty, lime character carries through on a pure, delicate, shimmering, dry palate. Provides exciting drinking at the price.

Grant Burge Meshach 2006 $104.50–$155
Filsell Vineyard, Southern Barossa Valley, South Australia
Today’s two five-star reds (Burge and Vasse Felix) couldn’t be more different. They’re chalk and cheese – but brilliant, highly polished examples of long-established regional styles. Grant Burge’s Meshach tells the traditional Barossa Valley shiraz story. Sourced from old vines, mainly at the southern end of the valley, it’s partially barrel fermented and all matured for 22 months in American (85 per cent) and French oak, 70 per cent of it new. While that makes a dark and potent wine initially, at five years Meshach is blossoming with its wonderfully complex aromas, deep, sweet fruited palate and layers of soft tannins. It’s big, for sure, but harmonious and, over time, it’ll become increasingly refined and elegant.

Vasse Felix Heytesbury
Cabernet Sauvignon Petit Verdot Malbec 2008 $75–$88

Vasse Felix Vineyard, Margaret River, Western Australia
We watch in wonder as China’s billionaires drive up prices of Bordeaux’s top reds. Nick’s wine merchants, for example, offers Chateau Lafite Rothschild 2009 at $1,999 a bottle pre-arrival in Australia. Is any wine worth that much? It’s great business for the French. But if we’re more interested in the wine in front of us than the label, several Australian cabernet blends, including the sublime Heytesbury 2008, easily bear comparison with their far more expensive Bordeaux counterparts. It’s a blend of cabernet sauvignon, petit verdot and malbec grown at Vasse Felix (owned by the Holmes a Court family) and made by Virginia Willcock. The three varieties combine harmoniously with French oak, delivering a fragrant, complex, powerful-but-elegant, world-class red.

Chrismont La Zona Barbera 2010 $26
King Valley, Victoria
La Zona Barbera 2010 and Rutherglen Estate Durif 2008 are just two of more than 120 wines on tasting at Taste of Two Regions (King Valley and Rutherglen) at Rydges Lakeside on Sunday, 3 July, 10am to 5pm. Entry fee for the tasting of regional produce and wine is $25. Chrismont, owned by Arnie and Jo Pizzini, represents the King Valley’s Italian heritage with this delicious, medium-bodied barbera. It’s purple rimmed with summer-berry fruit flavours as vivid as the colour. Typical for barbera, the structure relies as much on high acidity as it does on tannin, differentiating it from mainstream varieties.

Rutherglen Estate Durif 2008 $21.95
Rutherglen, Victoria
Although durif emerged in southern France in the nineteenth century, it took well to Rutherglen “as it is a late ripening variety, requiring a warm climate and an extended ripening period to develop its full flavour and structural potential”. It became Rutherglen’s idiosyncratic signature red variety, noted for its dense colour, formidable tannins and ability to age for decades. Rutherglen Estate’s version turns down the volume slightly, avoiding the variety’s sometimes port-like alcohol and impenetrable colour. However, it’s still recognisably durif with its ripe, full palate and firm tannins.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Majella of Coonawarra — from sheep farming to winemaking

At Chateau Shanahan we’ve experienced cellaring joy and disappointments over the years. But consistent pleasure in older bottles of Majella Coonawarra cabernet sauvignon and The Malleea cabernet shiraz, reminded us of this marvellous winery’s interesting transition from farming to grape growing to winemaking.

When brothers Brian and Anthony Lynn made the first Majella wine in 1991, they’d been growing grapes in Coonawarra for twenty-three years. They’d lived all their lives in the area. They’d grown fat lambs and wool long before vines took root on the family farm in 1968. Yet their first step into winemaking was, perhaps, even more tentative than their first step into grape growing had been two decades earlier.

Then, at least, there was a pre-arranged buyer for the grapes. Eric Brand, a good mate of George Lynn (Brian’s and Anthony’s late father), encouraged the planting of six acres of shiraz and agreed to buy the grapes to help satisfy a winemaking contract with Hardys.

The first Majella wine, a 1991 Coonawarra Shiraz, however, had no guaranteed buyers. If you’d asked Brian or Anthony where the business was headed when the wine was released in 1993, they’d not have foreseen Majella’s complete transition from contract grape grower to leading wine estate in just ten years.

People ask, were we visionary?” says Brian ‘Prof’ Lynn. “And I say, not really”. But Majella’s huge success wasn’t just blind luck either. It’s a success that grew from strong, deep roots in the Coonawarra landscape and community, fertilised by experience, skill, imagination, good management and – during it’s first decade of winemaking at least – by impeccable timing.

The release of Majella’s 1991 shiraz in 1993 came at the beginning of the unprecedented global red-wine boom. The wine was, and still is, a brilliant drop, beautifully packaged (designed by Barbara Harkness) and realistically priced.

I recall my first taste of it on a wine-buying trip to Coonawarra with David Farmer in September, 1993. At a little cook-your-own steakhouse, Nibs – owned at the time by Bill Brand and ‘Prof’ Lynn – the new Majella label caught our eye amongst all the familiar names on display. Who the hell was this we wondered? Nice label.

Nice wine, too – a classy drop, packed with Coonawarra’s unique ripe-berry flavour. Whether it was our huge grins or the label that prompted Patricia Lynn (Prof’s and Anthony’s mum) to approach us, I’ll never know, because we never met again. She died a few years after our visit.

But this former mayor of Penola (the little town at Coonawarra’s southern tip) turned on the warmth and charm for her Canberra visitors with tales of wartime Canberra. “I was the minutes secretary to the Minister’s secretary’, she told us of her job with the Minister for Supply. She knew ‘Chif’ and Nugget Coombs and that “after the bombing of Leeds, that Lithgow was the only remaining .303 manufacturing plant in the allied group”.

And she told us of Majella. In the post war years she met and married George Lynn, moved to the Coonawarra area where they produced wool on a property just to the south of Penola. One night Patricia told George she wanted to name the property ‘Majellan’ – after St Gerard Majellan, the catholic patron saint of mothers. She’d lost her first child and wanted another.

George’s response was pragmatic. ‘Majellan’ was too long to stamp on a wool bale. End of conversation – although a memorable night in other ways, recalled Patricia. Next morning, George offered a solution. Drop the “n”. And so Majella was born as a wool farm. In 1960 it became a fat lamb farm, too, when George bought his uncle Frank’s block in the heart of Coonawarra. In 1968 Majella became a vineyard. And in 1991, a wine name.

The Lynn family’s move into grape growing, recalls Prof, followed a high school geography project on Coonawarra viticulture. With luminaries such as Bill and Jock Redman, Eric Brand and Phil Laffer advising him, the young Prof’s interest shifted from the theoretical to the practical.

With advice and encouragement from Eric Brand of Laira vineyards, Prof and his dad planted six acres of shiraz in 1968. The propagated the vines from cuttings taken, on Bill Redman’s advice, from Arthur Hoffman’s ‘North Block’ (now Redmans). Prof remembers Bill Redman saying, “I’ll take you to Hoffman’s, because they’re the best shiraz in Coonawarra”.

Similarly, when the Lynns decided to add cabernet sauvignon to the mix old Jock Redman of Wynns advised them to take cuttings from vines he’d marked with white paint. These, he said, produced the best wine.

With a steady contract to supply grapes to Eric Brand, the Lynns were happy with those early grape-growing years. But in 1974 George became ill. By the time he died in 1976, the Brand contract had ended and nobody wanted Coonawarra shiraz – only cabernet, which made up only one third of the Majella plantings.

If we didn’t have wool, we would’ve gone broke”, says Prof. Business improved in the early eighties when Majella began selling grapes to Wynns – an arrangement that lasted until vintage 2001. And it was grapes that saved the Lynns in the wool crash of the late eighties and early nineties. “We would’ve gone broke without grapes, then”, laughs Prof.

So, by the time Majella made its first wine in 1991, it had served a long, tough apprenticeship learning how to grow high-quality wine grapes good enough to sell even in tough times.

Mature red vines on a good Coonawarra plot, and the ability to produce top grapes, says Prof, is the family’s biggest asset – entrusted, in the early days, to his old mates, the Brands and their talented winemaker, Bruce Gregory.

Then in 1999 Gregory joined the Lynn family full time at Majella’s new winery, next to the cellar door, opened in 1996.

Following its complete transition to winemaking a decade ago, Majella cemented its reputation as one of the region’s great winemakers. The wines all bear the regional style stamp.

Not surprisingly cabernet sauvignon ($33), Coonawarra’s great specialty, now sparks more interest than the shiraz ($30) that blazed the way for the label from the 1991 vintage. And the $75 long-lived flagship, The Malleea, a cabernet shiraz blend, hits profound heights. The same blend, in the $18 The Musician label , provides drink-now pleasure without diminishing the Coonawarra signature.

As the world’s wealthiest people pay ever greater prices for Bordeaux’s cabernet-based reds, we can get on quietly drinking estate-made Majella, and other Coonawarra and Margaret River reds, of comparable quality, at a fraction of the price.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Brewer adds “terroir” to the beer dictionary

At www.beerandbrewer.com winemaker-turned-brewer, Brad Rogers, introduces the French wine concept of “terroir” into the beer dictionary.

Rogers, a partner at Stone and Wood Brewery, Byron Bay, writes of the pale ale style and “how we’re making it our own”.

He describes how pale ales, across a wide range of styles, can’t be beaten at revealing the complex world of hops. He mentions uber hoppy American pale ale, the highly aromatic Little Creatures from Australia and English and Indian versions.

He introduces wine’s “terroir” concept, writing, “with hops different conditions do translate to different flavours. The Cascade hops grown in the Pacific Northwest and the Cascade hops grown in Tasmania’s Bushy Park… display different attributes”.

The growing numbers of hop-season beers released are a practical revelation of hop varieties and hop “terroirs”.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Tasting John’s Blend 1990 to 2006

In 1967 Wolf Blass winemaker, John Glaetzer, received a load of “beautiful, concentrated” cabernet sauvignon from Bill Potts’ vineyard, Langhorne Creek. Glaetzer turned those grapes into the first Wolf Blass Grey Label Cabernet Sauvignon.

Seven years later, inspired by those beautiful grapes, Glaetzer (still working for Blass) made John’s Blend No. 1 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon, using fruit from Bill Potts’ vineyard.

Glaetzer’s small-production wine developed a loyal following, its reputation spread mainly by word-of-mouth. And in Canberra, the word spread mainly through wine merchant Jim Murphy, a long-term supporter of Wolf Blass and John Glaetzer.

A couple of weeks back, a disparate group of 11 Canberra followers – led by Charlotte Galloway, an ANU lecturer in Art History and Curatorship – raided their cellars to hold a John’s Blend vertical tasting: all the vintages, bar 1992, from 1990 to 2006.

No, not a sniff and spit tasting, but a leisurely stroll through the sequence over lunch on a crisp, sunny autumn day – hosted by Warwick McKibbin and fiancée, Renee Fry, and attended by Galloway, Jac and Kathy Cousin, Jenny and Peter Gibson, James Horne, Heather Smith, Martin Parkinson and yours truly.

A confession here: Chateau Shanahan contributed the 2002 and 2003 vintages, but John Glaetzer had given these to us some years back – we’d seldom tasted John’s Blend, so entered the tasting with few preconceptions.

We tasted the wines in pairs from oldest to youngest, therefore starting with the 1990 and 1991 and finishing at 2006. It’s an effective tasting method as there’s no rush, no palate overload and a natural pairing of wine with food.

We found wonderful consistency of style across the vintages – the thread linking all of the wines being a distinctive mint-eucalypt note associated with cabernet sauvignon from Langhorne Creek.

The wines go through an interesting transition from oakiness to fruitiness as they age. In the fully mature wines, oak seems barely detectable; and in the young vintages it’s an oak-fruit arm wrestle – a style that’s not in vogue today.

In this regard, the wines reminded me of a tasting, with Wolf Blass and John Glaetzer, of all the Wolf Blass Black Label wines a few years back. The veteran tasters, remembering the dark, oaky young Black Labels of the mid seventies, wondered where the oak had gone. All we could taste now were supple, mellow old wines with fruit to the fore.

Similarly, John’s Blend reminds us that it’s all a matter of balance – powerful fruit’s capable of gobbling up lots of oak over time, and the symbiotic combination produces complex long-lived wines.

John Glaetzer says there’s been no significant change to his winemaking technique or oak-maturation regime over the years. He ferments the wine a little cooler than industry standard, to preserve vibrant fruit flavours. He believes warm temperatures “boil off the fruit”.

And in a technique picked up from Wolf Blass (in turn learned by Blass from Grange creator, Max Schubert) Glaetzer finishes the ferments off in oak barrels.

Glaetzer continues to source fruit from Bill Potts’ Langhorne Creek Vineyard. However, in 1992 and 1993 he and Potts established the 32-hectare Pasquin vineyard nearby. In recent years, says Glaetzer, John’s Blend comes about 50:50 from the two vineyards. He makes only 1,000 cases of John’s Blend each year – but made none in 2011 for lack of suitable fruit.

Langhorne Creek, near Lake Alexandrina (south east of McLaren Vale), is one of Australia’s largest premium wine grape regions. A massive expansion there in the late nineties saw most of its fruit blended anonymously into multi-region blends. Blass reputedly called the region, “Australia’s middle palate”.

The Potts family pioneered the area from 1850 and remain in control today of Bleasdale Winery and vineyards. Bill Potts, one of the family, supplies Glaetzer from his own vineyard.

One of the most enduring reds from the area is Stonyfell Metala Shiraz Cabernet. It was made from 1932 by Jack Kilgour, and marketed originally as Stonyfell Private Bin Claret. Kilgour’s successor, Bryan Dolan, put the vineyard name, Metala, on the label. Dolan won the inaugural Jimmy Watson Trophy in 1962 with the 1961 Metala, the first vintage to bear the new label.

Langhorne Creek triumphed again in 1974, 1975 and 1976 with Wolf Blass’s historic Jimmy Watson trophy hat trick. But Blass’s powerful branding of his Black Label overshadowed the regional credentials.

In John’s Blend, Langhorne Creek cabernet sauvignon reveals its idiosyncratic charm consistently across the decades, with little peaks and troughs driven by vintage variations. With so much focus now on regional specialties, Glaetzer’s 37-year-old brand (like Kilgour’s 1932 Stonyfell Private Bin Claret) reminds us that this is not a new idea at all, but the perennial wine theme.

The current-release 2007 vintage John’s Blend (not in the tasting) is available at Jim Murphy’s for $29.95 and Kemeny’s of Sydney offer the 2006 at $29.99. Few wines at this price offers such a pedigree and proven long-term cellaring potential.

John’s Blend No 17 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1990
A perfect start to the tasting with this mature but still lively, sweet-fruited vintage with distinctive Langhorne Creek minty-eucalypt cabernet sauvignon to the fore. Has years ahead of it.

John’s Blend No 18 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1991
Looked, smelled and tasted older than the vibrant 1990 to its left, but nevertheless an appealing, if fading, old wine.

John’s Blend No 20 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1993
Tasted at the end of the lunch when our host, Warwick McKibbin, generously retrieved a magnum from the cellar. 1993 was a wet, disease-ridden vintage, comparable to 2011. But the wine defied the vintage stereotype, with its complex aroma and lean, taut palate still revealing mint-eucalyptus varietal flavour. Drying out a bit but still thoroughly enjoyable.

John’s Blend No 21 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1994
One of the standout vintages, seventeen years old but still red rather than brown with vibrant mint-eucalypt cabernet aroma and a juicy, elegant palate, finely-sculpted palate. Many years left.

John’s Blend No 22 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1995
One of the most talked about wines, championed by Charlotte Galloway and notable for its strident, chunky style, flanked on either side by the elegant 1994 and 1996 vintages. The mint-eucalypt character seemed particularly strong in this wine, matched by a firmer tannin structure.

John’s Blend No 23 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1996
My favourite drinking wine on the day, a particularly elegant, ethereal expression of its style – all sweet fruit, grace and suppleness. Long and delicious finish, many years of life ahead, but right now showing both youth and maturity.

John’s Blend No 24 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1997
A lesser vintage but in terrific condition, its lively palate notably leaner than the 1996 before it, but still sweet and supple.

John’s Blend No 25 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1998
Generally considered a great vintage but our first bottle seriously cork tainted and the second bottle showing a strange vegetal character and hollow palate. John Glaetzer reckons we struck two dud corks. He regards it as one of the greats. Down with cork.

John’s Blend No 26 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 1999
A beautiful wine with a limpid, youthful colour, seductive ripe blackcurrant aroma pushing through the by now familiar mint-eucalypt. Despite the generous nose, the fruit on the palate comes teasingly wrapped in firm tannins – a delicious and elegant combination, suggesting heaps more drinking pleasure in the years to come.

John’s Blend No 27 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2000
Looks, smells and tastes older than the exceptional 1999. Aged, autumn-leaf aromas join the mint-eucalypt notes and the palate seems old and tiring – a lesser vintage, remarkable that it’s still going after 11 years.

John’s Blend No 28 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2001
A bit of a closed shop this one, some chocolate joining the mint-eucalypt theme on a full but tight, tannic palate ­– though there’s fruit peeking through and probably a long life ahead of it. Seems to be neither young nor mature, so best left for a few more years.

John’s Blend No 29 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2002
First bottle cork tainted. Second bottle in good condition and just a baby – the first wine to show obvious oak aroma and flavour (the older wines had simply gobbled up all the oak, leaving fruit to star). A lovely aroma combining mint-eucalypt with cedary oak – these characters come through, too, on the tightly-bound palate. One of the greats but best left to mature for a few more years.

John’s Blend No 30 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2003
We’re now squarely among the young, oaky wines. Ripe mint-eucalypt-chocolate-blackcurrant fruit joins the oak but there’s not the length of flavour. It needs more time but probably won’t rate among the best.

John’s Blend No 31 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2004
Well, yum yum, this one’s saturated with fruit – and oak, too, after three years in new French and American barrels. But as the old wines demonstrate, the oak will fade over time as the wine becomes finer and the fruit steps to the front. A very good vintage.

John’s Blend No 32 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2005
A big, ripe, crimson-rimmed wine: juicy, vibrant summer-berry flavours mingle with the regional mint-eucalypt. Big and chocolate-rich on the palate in an oak-fruit arm wrestle – but we know the winner in the long run, don’t we.

John’s Blend No 33 Langhorne Creek Cabernet Sauvignon 2006
A magnificent, deeply coloured, crimson-rimmed wine to finish. Enough oak to build a weekender, but in a complex matrix with deep, ripe varietal fruit (yes, tinted with mint-eucalypt). There’s great depth to the supple fruit and despite the wine’s youth and power, the structure’s poised and elegant. One of the greats.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Wine review — Shingleback, Geoff Merrill, Peppertree, Tyrrell’s and Pio Cesare

The Gate by Shingleback Shiraz 2006 $30–$35
McLaren Vale, South Australia
The bling-laden label raises expectations – four gold and five silver medals from wine shows around the world. Pull the cork, thankfully no cork taint, pour the wine and instant joy. This is beautiful McLaren Vale shiraz, grown on the Davey family’s Shingleback vineyard, made in small, open fermenters and matured in a mix of new and one-year-old American and French oak hogsheads. It’s full bodied and at five years combines layers of vibrant varietal berry flavours with fine tannin, the unique “winey” character of bottle age and a deep, satisfying savouriness. Was the first bottle emptied at a recent tasting – the ultimate review.

Geoff Merrill Cilento Sangiovese 2005 $27
McLaren Vale, South Australia
Generally it’s only the big-ticket wines released with bottle age. But here we have a modestly priced, very attractive six-year-old from veteran McLaren Vale winemaker, Geoff Merrill. Geoff writes that the wine spent three years in three and four year old American oak puncheons – it’s therefore had another three years mellowing in bottle. It’s Australian in style – meaning there’s more upfront sweet fruit than you see in its Italian sangiovese counterparts. But there’s a deep savouriness, tart acidity and tight tannic structure setting it apart from other varieties. It’s named after Merrill’s Italian great grandfather, Joseph Cilento.

Peppertree Venus Block Reserve Chardonnay 2010 $30
Orange, New South Wales
Canberra-raised winemaker Jim Chatto rates 2010 “the best yet” from Peppertree’s Venus block vineyard at Orange. This is what good modern chardonnay is all about – grown in a climate cool enough to produce intense nectarine- and fig-like varietal flavour and high acidity. The intense, fine fruit and acidity drive the wine, easily carrying the flavours and textures woven in during oak fermentation and maturation on spent yeast cells. That combination of bright fruit flavours and barrel complexity, held together by a tingly spine of acidity, gives Peppertree 2010 tremendous appeal. Chardonnay doubters should try this for real drinking excitement.

Tyrrell’s Wine Single Vineyard Shiraz 2008 $27–$38.50
Murrumbateman, Canberra District, New South Wales
During the Hunter’s disastrous 2008 vintage, Tyrrell’s bought eight tonnes of shiraz from Barton Estate, Murrumbateman. They trucked the grapes to the Hunter, made the wine and matured it in new 2,800-litre French oak casks. The wine turned out beautifully, winning a gold medal and trophy at last year’s National Wine Show, Canberra. In a recent masked tasting the Tyrrell’s wine and two other Canberra shirazes, Collector Reserve 2009 and Clonakilla O’Riada 2009, showed their class. The 2009s topped my scoresheet, but the Tyrrell’s rated highly, too, with its vibrant fruit, and tight, spicy elegant palate.

Pio Cesare Il Nebbio 2009 $33–$44
Langhe, Piedmont, Italy
Pio Cesare, based in Alba, Piedmont, owns about 50 hectares of vines in key appellations, including Barolo and Barbaresco, source of perhaps Italy’s greatest red wines, made from the nebbiolo variety. But the Pio Cesare family also offers a fresh, fruity (and less expensive) face of nebbiolo in Il Nebbio. Early picking, carbonic maceration, low-temperature fermentation in stainless steel and bottling after only few months in the steel tanks, captures the variety’s vitality. The alluring, fruity aromatics are matched by a juicy, jube-like fruity palate – for a brief and lovely second before nebbiolo’s legendary firm tannins move in. These rule out Il Nebbio as a drink-alone wine. But with food the tannins vanish and the delicious fruit rules.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Kendell’s estate-grown cider from Orange

The rapidly growing cider market includes a proliferation of niche brands and an increased demand for products made from fresh apples and pears – not juice and sugar.

At nearby Orange, Gail and James Kendell, adopted a winery-like approach, growing and making all of their product on site.

James Kendell says they’ve planted a wide range of English heritage cider apple varieties, including Kingston Blacks. The special varieties, he says, produce better cider than eating varieties partly because of their distinctive flavours but also because they contain skin tannins and high natural acidity – important components in cider’s flavour and structure.

The diversity, he says, allows him to produce a range of ciders (see www.smallacrescyder.com.au) based on traditional English styles. The still Somerset style reviewed today, for example, combines 13 apple varieties in the full and delicious west-country style.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011

Wine review – John Duval and Yellowtail

John Duval Plexus
Barossa Valley Marsanne Roussanne Viognier 2010 $30

Barossa vignerons face a challenge making whites to compete with popular varieties, like sauvignon blanc and chardonnay from much cooler regions. The Barossa succeeds on a limited scale with semillon, and the slightly cooler Eden Valley, to the east, makes wonderful riesling. Rather than trying to emulate cool area wines, John Duval sets out “to build structure and texture, rather than just acid crispness”. His new blend, partly matured and aged in mainly old oak, achieves that deliciously. Its pleasant, citrusy aroma leads to a soft, tasty, savoury, medium-bodied palate with a gentle texture and fresh but not acidic finish.

John Duval Plexus
Barossa Valley Shiraz Grenache Mourvedre 2009 $37–$39

Former Penfolds Grange maker, John Duval, shows his great mastery of fruit selection, winemaking and blending in this beautiful red. It’s a blend of old-vine shiraz (48 per cent) from Krondorf and Marananga, grenache (31 per cent) from old bush vines in Stockwell and Krondorf and mourvedre (21 per cent), some vines more than 100 years old, in Light Pass and Krondorf. It’s appealingly aromatic – led by the grenache – and vibrantly fruity, savoury and spicy on the palate, finishing with delicious ripe berry flavours and soft, fine tannins. It’s a wonderful, harmonious, satisfying drink – with the structure and depth to age well.

Yellow Tail  2010 vintage reds $8.55–$10

  • Pinot Noir
  • Merlot
  • Shiraz 2010
  • Cabernet Sauvignon

The Casella family’s legendary Yellow Tail took America by storm some time back, selling millions of cases there every year. It started as an adventure, using an off-the-shelf label from Barbara Harkness design, Adelaide, then succeeded beyond anyone’s maddest guess. Amazingly, the Casella’s funded the massive expansion and retained control of a business that focuses squarely on the business end of wine. The winemaking aims at capturing flawless, ripe, friendly, fruity wines on a very large scale, and succeeds – particularly with the full, soft shiraz and cabernet sauvignon. They’re decent wines at a fair price.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2011