Category Archives: Wine review

Wine review — Brother in Arms, Wirra Wirra & Pizzini

Brothers in Arms Langhorne Creek No. 6 Shiraz Cabernet 2004 $22
In 1932 Jack Kilgour made Stonyfell Private Bin Claret, a shiraz cabernet blend from the Metala vineyard, Langhorne Creek. In 1959 the wine, Jack’s last, adopted the vineyard name and is still sold today as Stonyfell Metala Shiraz Cabernet. While Foster’s owns the Stonyfell brand, the vineyard, with vines dating from 1891, belongs to the Adams family. As well as selling fruit from the 280-hectare vineyard, the family produces two excellent reds – the bright, smooth and plush 2004 No. 6 Shiraz and a mellow, satisfying 2002 Shiraz ($45). Historically, much of Langhorne Creek’s output provided a smooth richness to multi-region blends. The Adams family is intent on displaying the regional character undiluted. See www.brothersinarms.com.au

Wirra Wirra Woodhenge McLaren Vale Shiraz 2005 $30 & Adelaide Hills 12th Man Chardonnay 2006 $24.50
This is a very smart double act from winemaker Samantha Connew – silk-smooth, opulent shiraz from warm McLaren Vale and citrusy, complex chardonnay from the cool heights of Lenswood in the Adelaide Hills. The shiraz comes from ‘some of Wirra Wirra’s oldest vineyards’, the press release tells us. And it shows the flavour concentration and smooth, fine tannins of top grapes and gentle winemaking. The chardonnay has the fruit intensity to handle Burgundian winemaking tricks like high-solids, indigenous yeast ferments in oak barrels. These add texture and a tasty patina of flavours that enhance the delicious fruit. See www.wirra.com.au

Pizzini King Valley Sangiovese 2005 $24
This is surely one of Australia’s best-value red wines. Over an excellent meal at Mezzalira recently, it impressed once again (yes, I know I’ve reviewed it before), especially as it held its own against a couple of $70 reds. Fred Pizzini has been making it for decades now and the maturity of the vineyards and winemaking show in the wine’s depth and polish. It starts bright and fruity. But a few sips reveal a more complex, savoury dimension as well as the firm, fine tannin backbone of the variety. I suspect that this will be a vintage to age well for five or six years, though there’s no need to wait. Our bottle disappeared rapidly enough. See www.pizzini.com.au

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — De Bortoli, Stoneleigh, Kahurangi

De Bortoli Windy Peak Sauvignon Blanc Semillon 2007 $11–$15
The press release says of the 2007 vintage, ‘The King Valley where De Bortoli has over 200ha of vineyards and where we source a lot of Sauvignon Blanc and Semillon, was hardest hit reducing our crop of useable fruit to less than ten per cent’. The huge crop loss forced De Bortoli to wider sourcing for this delicious blend: to the Yarra, King, Murray and Hunter Valleys, Mornington, Orange, Canberra and the Riverina. The result is a zesty wine showing the lightness and passionfruit-like character of sauvignon blanc supported by the length and structure of semillon. It’s made for current drinking.

Stoneleigh Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc 2006 $16 to $19
Stoneleigh, part of New Zealand’s Montana Group, belongs now to French owned Pernod Ricard Pacific – proprietors, as well, of Australia’s Orlando Wines. Stoneleigh’s sauvignon blanc, sourced from the warmer Rapaura sub-region of Marlborough, is distinct from the more herbaceous Montana style, produced from the cooler Brancott area. Stoneleigh presents the passionfruit and tropical character of ripe sauvignon cut with bracing minerally acidity – reminding us that Marlborough really is a cool area even in its warmer sites. What makes Marlborough really special, though, is that the bracing acidity becomes a refreshing foil to the amazingly juicy, luscious fruit flavour.

Kahurangi Estate Nelson Pinot Noir 2004 $25
Many years ago Neudorf of Nelson (a few hours drive west of Marlborough at the top of New Zealand’s South Island) demonstrated the chardonnay and pinot noir potential of this cool, sunny region. At a tasting late last year, and again recently, Neudorf’s neighbour, Kahurangi, started slowly with its pale, slightly aged hue. But the perfume and fine, intense palate continued to seduce for several days after opening the bottle – a very positive sign. Where many pinots fade rapidly, this one shows the durability characteristic of the best. It really is a subtle, delicious expression of pinot noir with the ability to offer something new with every sip.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Cumulus, Fox Creek & Eileen Hardy

Cumulus Wine Climbing Orange Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 $19.99
At last year’s Orange District wine show judges James Halliday, Celine Rousseau and I pushed this wine to the top of the cabernet class – meaning a trophy as well as a gold medal. Away from the sip-and-spit pressure of a wine show and six months on, the wine still looks good. It has well-defined varietal aroma and flavour with typically firm, drying tannins. And there’s a richness to the mid palate that’s often lacking in cabernets from inland regions. My only quibble is that the tannins are a wee bit tough – something you won’t notice over a good steak. Great value.

Fox Creek McLaren Vale Short Row Shiraz 2004 $28
As the 2004 vintage approached, one winemaker told me of the ‘wall of fruit’ awaiting harvest. He had misgivings because big crops sometimes mean lower quality. There was much crop thinning in an effort to concentrate flavour. But even then most areas enjoyed a big harvest. With the dust long settled on what is now generally seen as a terrific vintage, we can enjoy wines like this generous, soft, Fox Creek Shiraz. It’s sourced mainly from the ‘Short Row’ block near the winery, they say, and expresses the Vale’s generous flavours, soft tannins and appealing, savoury edge. See www.foxcreekwines.com

Eileen Hardy Chardonnay 2005 $50 to $55
Hardy’s flagship white parallels Australia’s chardonnay history. It began in 1986 as a fairly big, short-lived, oaky white sourced from Padthaway, at the time probably the coolest region growing appreciable volumes of chardonnay. It was typical of wines of the time and one of the leading examples, too. Eileen’s sourcing followed the best chardonnay plantings, heading further south and to higher altitudes in the ensuing years to mature as a fine, potentially long-lived style this decade. The current release, a Tumbarumba-Tasmania blend, has — in its intense, delicious fruit flavours, complex barrel-related complexities and taut structure – more than an echo of the great French white Burgundies on which it is modelled.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Grant Burge, Ravensworth & Lillydale

Grant Burge Barossa Valley Meshach Shiraz 2002 $100
Grant Burge’s flagship red comes from several southern Barossa vineyards — including a section of Grant’s Filsell vineyard, planted in the 1920s. Although finessed in recent years – partly through the use of finer French oak in conjunction with more assertive American oak – it remains an extraordinarily concentrated red, built for the long haul. It’s certainly earned its stripes amongst the country’s elite wines, even if writer opinion currently favours cooler climate styles. At the release tasting Burge previewed his sensational Shadrach Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 – a blend from Coryton Park in the Eden Valley and Barossa floor. It’s a sensational wine due for release in few years.

Ravensworth Canberra District Sangiovese 2006 about $22
This is an incredibly good follow up to Bryan and Jocelyn Martin’s 2005 vintage – winner of a gold medal and trophy at last year’s regional show. Bryan says he fermented both vintages on viognier skins — a little trick, he believes, that helps to brighten and stabilise colour and smooth the texture. But this is mere seasoning to a delicious wine that captures the spirit of Italy’s ubiquitous sangiovese grape. There’s a Aussie-style bright, inviting and fruity dimension to Ravensworth. But the medium body and savoury, persistent tannins that follow are Italian, and the real point of difference in a wine that ought to blossom over the never next five or six years. See www.ravensworthwines.com.au

Lillydale Estate Yarra Valley Chardonnay 2005 $16 to $20
Judges voted this mid-priced chardonnay as best chardonnay, best white wine and best table wine of Canberra’s 2006 National Wine Show of Australia. Encountered again recently it remains in the fine-boned, oak-fermented, oak-matured style that’ve now pretty well replaced the fat and overtly oak styles that dominated the market two decades ago. Delicious, melon-like varietal chardonnay flavour is the key to the wine’s great appeal. But a matrix of aromas and flavours derived from barrel fermentation and maturation on yeast lees adds subtly to the drinking pleasure. And that’s further enhanced by its silky texture and great freshness.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Penfolds Bin 128, Bin 28, Bin 389 & Bin 407

Penfolds Bin 128 Coonawarra Shiraz 2004 & 2005 $15.75-$27
With prices spiralling to new lows – as little as $15.75 for Bins 128, 138 and 28 — the new-vintage Penfolds reds present a great buying opportunity. A personal favourite from the release is the 2004 Bin 128, a French-oak-matured shiraz from the Coonawarra region. The sample bottle blossomed for days after opening – revealing rich, delicious cool-climate berry flavours with typical Penfolds’ layered texture, of which fine, grippy tannins are a major component. The wine has an elegance, too, and I suspect that this will become more apparent as the years roll by. The co-released plumper, more tannic 2005 needs time and is upstaged by the better 2004 wine.

Penfolds Bin 28 Kalimna Shiraz 2004 $15.75-$27
Penfolds’ decision to screw cap seal Bin 28 2004 but not all of the other Bin reds sends a confusing message to drinkers. If, as we’re told, it’s the best seal for sturdy reds with long cellaring potential, why pussy foot around with a gradual roll out, culminating, one of the winemakers tells me, with Grange from the 2006 vintage? Fortunately Bin 28 2004 rises above the equivocal marketing stance and delivers big on traditional Penfolds’ values: flavour, harmony, cellarability and complexity. It offers the bigger flavour and structure of warm-grown shiraz with the unique Penfolds tannin thumbprint. This is a very good vintage.

Penfolds Bin 389 Cabernet Shiraz 2004 $32.45-$45, Bin 407 Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 $22.45-$35
Since the first vintage in 1990 Bin 407 has been textbook cabernet sauvignon – a wine that smells, tastes and feels (in its assertive, slightly austere, tannic structure) like nothing but cabernet. The 2004 maintains this variety-defining style. It’s the ideal steak wine. Bin 389, too, leads with cabernet aroma and structure – a wine of immense power and depth. Tasted alongside the pure-cabernet Bin 407, the role of shiraz in the Bin 389 blend becomes apparent, providing an earthy note to the nose and fullness to the palate. The combination is striking in a wine built, unequivocally, for the cellar.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Nigl, Madfish & Penfolds

Nigl Senstenberger Piri Grüner Veltliner 2005 $30.50
It’s aromatic and finely structured like riesling and has a slight musky note like gewürztraminer – but not the oiliness. But, in the end, grüner veltliner is its own beast. And grown in cool Austria (Piri vineyard, village of Senstensberg) that means a racy acid backbone as well as delicacy and attractive floral aroma. It’s a delight to drink now and is probably best as an aperitif or with delicate food. Nigl is available by making advance orders through Winewise magazine proprietor, Lester Jesberg, phone 0412 148 577. The late ripening grüner veltliner seems particularly well adapted to Austria.

Madfish Margaret River Carnelian 2005 $24
Carnelian, says Jancis Robinson, emerged ‘from professor Olmo’s California nursery only in 1972′. She writes that Professor Olmo crossed an earlier crossing of cabernet sauvignon and carignan with grenache, seeking to produce ‘a hot-climate variety with some cabernet class’. While professor Olmo’s aspirations are not entirely fulfilled, the Madfish wine (a second label of Howard Park) is interesting and tasty. The colour is a stunning purple and the aroma and flavour based on rich blueberry-like character. We can probably attribute the vibrancy and perfume to grenache, the colour to carignan and grippy, assertive tannins to both cabernet and carignan.

Penfolds Bin 138 Barossa Valley Grenache Shiraz Mourvedre 2005 $15.80 to $26
The extraordinary competitiveness of the wine retail market – driven by oversupply, big-retailer aggression and, perhaps, by Fosters (Penfolds’ parent company) alarming loss of market share – shows in a price tag that’s dollars below that of last year’s release. I’ll offer a fuller commentary on this and the Penfolds release in next Wednesday’s column. In the meantime, if you can find Bin 138 at $15.80 — as offered by both Kemeny’s of Sydney and Dan Murphy in recent weeks — grab a case or two. If the 2005 lacks the aromatic grenache highlights of the 2004, it makes up with deep, savoury flavours that’ll only grow in appeal as the wine ages.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Lustau, d’Arenberg & Richmond Grove

Lustau Manzanilla Papirusa Sherry 375ml $14.99
Manzanilla, the palest, most delicate of the flor fino sherry family, comes from the Spanish seaside town of Sanlucar de Barameda. The humid environment encourages an extra thickness in the film of yeast cells (flor) on the surface of the sherry maturing in barrels. While this layer contributes distinctive ‘sherry’ character, the extra thickness protects the wine from air and accounts for the dazzling freshness of good Manzanilla – like this one. There’s a slight salty tang, a subtle, pungent ‘sherry’ note and a bone-dry, delicate, mouth-watering finish. At just 15.5 per cent alcohol it’s a superb aperitif and pairs well with savoury food.

d’Arenberg McLaren Vale The Hermit Crab Viognier Marsanne 2006 $20, The Money Spider Roussanne 2006 $20
d’Arenberg, The Vale’s master of the Rhône Valley red varieties grenache, shiraz and mourvedre, some years back turned its hand, with equal panache, to the white varieties, marsanne, viognier and roussanne. The novel (in Australia) addition of marsanne to viognier seems to mollify the overt apricot-like character of viognier – though it remains the dominant flavour – to produce a distinctive vibrant, full and silky dry white style. The shyer Roussanne, too, is silky smooth but delivers less in-your-face fruitiness. The stone-fruit-like flavour is subtle and more-ish and deliciously crisp and refreshing. There’s a wealth of info on these unique styles at www.darenberg.com.au

Richmond Grove Watervale Riesling 2005 $14 to $18
In recent Chateau Shanahan tastings the 1997, 1998, 1999, 2002 and 2005 vintages of this extraordinary wine have impressed for delicious lime-like varietal flavour. And the older wines – under screw cap from 1998 – show that wonderful honeyed overlay of age. The 2005, already with four gold medals, shows all the class of this distinguished Watervale (southern Clare Valley) line and is surely one of Australia’s great wine bargains. Orlando Group White Winemaker, Rebekah Richardson, tells me it’s a blend of the best Watervale material of each vintage, as assessed by the Orlando team. That team, incidentally, includes veteran John Vickery, a key figure in the development of modern Australian riesling.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Holm Oak, Wyndham Estate & Coriole

Holm Oak Vineyards Tasmania Riesling 2006 $20
Holm Oak is a seven-hectare vineyard at Rowella on the Tamar River, Northern Tasmania. Ian and Robyn Wilson own the vineyard but leased but lease it to their winemaker daughter, Rebecca and partner Stuart Catlin. They arrived in mid-2006 in time to launch this very fine aperitif-style riesling. As you’d expect from such a cool site, there’s a backbone of racy acidity giving it life and freshness and driving the attractive lime-like varietal flavour across the palate. Like all good riesling it should provide interesting drinking over time as it moves from bright and zesty youth to the honeyed, toasty mellowness of age. Cellar door phone is 03 6394 7577.

Wyndham Estate Bin 777 Semillon Sauvignon Blanc 2006 $11-$14
Wyndham Estate, along with Jacob’s Creek, has long been part of the French-owned Pernod Pacific Group. The winemaking team, though, is Australian and includes luminaries like Phil Laffer, John Vickery, Bernard Hickin and Sam Kurtz. They are masters with this sort of commercial blend. And they love to surprise critics who actually taste them with what can be done in a judicious blend that includes material from top-ranked regions and bulk regions – the combination delivering the right flavour and the right price. They’ve done it with this gold-medal and trophy-winner from the 2006 National Wine Show. Watch for the specials and stock up.

Coriole McLaren Vale Redstone Shiraz 2004 $18-$20
This entry-level shiraz from Mark Lloyd’s Coriole Winery starts with bright, fresh, generous fruit flavour. A few sips in, though, and it still holds interest, revealing distinctive McLaren Vale savouriness and soft, drying tannins. Mark sources fruit for Redstone (named after the red-coloured ironstone common in McLaren Vale) partly from the Coriole Vineyard and partly from other growers in the Vale. It’s a comparatively low-acid, soft style made specifically for early drinking. And the combination of fruitiness, savouriness and softness makes it versatile with food. No need for cellar, drink up. See www.coriole.com.au

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Top-shelf Aussie gewürtztraminer — it’s there if you look

Those who say that too much gewürztraminer (aka traminer) is too much of a good thing are probably right. It’s one of the most instantly recognisable of wines and a joy to drink in small doses.

But it’s hard to find the good ones because Australia grows so little of it – about six thousand tonnes annually compared to riesling’s thirty thousand and chardonnay’s 250 thousand. And most of what we do make goes to cheaper large volume blends.

Those deliciously grapey, sweetish blends – usually with riesling — have provided an entry point into wine drinking for millions of Australians over the last forty years, starting in the sixties with Penfolds Bin 202 Traminer Riesling and continuing today with the likes of Rosemount Estate, McGuigan and Hardys RR.

A little splash of traminer adds a lot to a wine. Its pink berries deliver heady lychee-like aromas, with matching opulence on the palate, and often, especially when grown in warm climates, a viscous to oily texture – striking characteristics but also ones that tend to limit our intake.

Although the world’s largest plantings today are in Alsace, France, Jancis Robinson writes that it was ‘first mentioned as growing in the village of Tramin, or Termeno, in the higher reaches of the Etsch Valley in what is now the Italian Tyrol, around the year 1000’.

Alsace remains, too, the model for top-end new-world producers including those in Australia and New Zealand. Most of the production is of dry versions — and these can be sublime – but in great years like 1976 exceptionally long-lived sweeter versions emerge.

In Australia, the lack of demand for top-end gewürztraminers tends to limit production, despite the existence of some wonderful old vineyards. But the sheer passion of some winemakers keeps the flame burning.

The converted need no urging. But adventurous palates can have a flavour adventure sipping the Australian gewürztraminers below. They represent pretty well the whole spectrum of dry styles from the juicy, plum warm climate versions like Olivine and Skillogalee from the Hunter and Clare respectively, to the leaner more intense versions from cool Macedon (Hanging Rock) and Coal River, Tasmania (Bay of Fires).

This is an in-your-face variety. But it’s an essential and unforgettable experience for anyone with even a passing interest in flavour.

Hanging Rock ‘The Jim Jim’ Macedon Ranges Gewürztraminer 2004 $27
If there’s such a thing as the finer face of traminer, this is it. There’s a thread of grapefruit-like zestiness cutting through the distinctive flavours. Outstanding.

Terrace Vale Hunter Vale Old Vine Gewürztraminer 2005 $18.50
This one’s lower in alcohol, meaning less astringency and lighter body. But it still has attractive, musky varietal flavour and characteristic tannin bite in the finish. Value.

Skillogalee Clare Valley Gewürztraminer 2005 $20
Clare’s warm climate shows in Skillogalee’s plump, even voluptuous style. It’s thoroughly delicious, plump and juicy with traminer’s familiar bite in the finish. Seductive.

Penfolds Cellar Reserve Woodbury Vineyard Eden Valley Gewürztraminer 2005 $30
From the old Tollana Woodbury Vineyard comes this sensational white that grows in interest with every sip and will probably age well. A classic for the cellar.

Delatite Dead Man’s Hill Mansfield Gewürztraminer 2004 $20
Something of a signature wine for the Ritchie family – beautifully balanced and smooth with attractive musk-like varietal flavour. Subtle and expressive.

Pewsey Vale Eden Valley Gewürztraminer 2006 $22
The clear value-for-money champ of the line up offers extraordinary, pure, lychee-musk varietal expression. Outstanding.

Olivine Hunter Valley Gewürztraminer 2005 $19
The aroma promises opulence — and the sleek, slippery, lychee-like palate delivers it. Sourced from old vines in the Upper Hunter. Outstanding value for money.

Bay of Fires Coal Bay Tasmania Gewürztraminer 2005 $25
Shows the zesty citrusy flavours and tight, dry palate of cool-grown fruit. Musky varietal flavours are there, too. Not entirely convincing.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

A barrel of fun — why winemakers use oak barrels

The wooden barrel, one of the most enduring of all wine vessels, was used originally for storage and transportation some 2000 years ago. Its value today, though, lies in its ability to clarify, stabilise and add complex aromas and flavours to wine and set the scene for further flavour development in bottle.

Until about the third century AD the two-handled stone amphora carried Etruscan, Greek and Roman wine across the world’s extensive trade routes. But at around about that time the flow of wine from Rome to her northern colonies reversed to be replaced by wooden barrels of Gaulish wine heading south.

These Celtic barrels, according to Hugh Johnson in ‘The Story of Wine’ (Mitchell Beazley, London, 1989) differ little from the ones we use today.

The Romans replaced iron hoops with wooden bands. But iron made a comeback in the seventeenth century. And today’s barrels, while shorter and fatter than those used by the Gauls and Romans, remain pretty much unchanged.

The wooden barrel, while lighter and easier to handle than the amphora, proved not as completely airtight, making it unsuited for long-term storage of table wine. However, its use for bulk transport lasted until after world war two.

An explosion in table wine consumption from the 1970s brought with it a growing demand for oak barrels for maturation (and sometimes fermentation) of high-quality table wines.

Australia’s icon, Penfolds Grange was perhaps the first to be matured in all-new oak, beginning with Max Schubert’s first, experimental Grange in 1951.

Max made two almost identical wines that year: the experimental Grange, partly fermented and all matured in new American oak hogsheads, and a control batch matured in a well-seasoned 4550 litre cask.

Max later wrote of the experimental wine: “… The raw wood was not so apparent but the fruit characteristics had become pronounced and defined… it was almost as if the new wood had acted as a catalyst to release previously unsuspected flavours and aromas…”

The great reds of Bordeaux had inspired Max. And French originals inspired another generation to emulate the magic of white and red Burgundy (chardonnay and pinot noir) and Bordeaux (cabernet sauvignon and related varieties). Again, oak played a crucial if challenging role.

Even the most casual wine drinker absorbed some awareness of the role oak plays in wine making — thanks largely to the explosion of chardonnay consumption and the often overt oak flavours found in our favourite tipples.

During years of rapid growth, our wine makers become incredibly good at making chardonnay of the oak-fermented-and-matured variety — even if they did over-oak it at times.

But oaked chardonnays remain in the majority today because, as Max Schubert found in making the original Grange, oak properly used acts “as a catalyst to release previously unsuspected flavours and aromas”.

With chardonnay, as with red wine, it is the oxidative environment as well as the type of oak, how it is seasoned, how it is toasted, how the wine is made, when it goes into the barrel, how long it stays there and what the ambient temperature is that influence the finished wine.

Our wine makers didn’t learn how to cope with all those variables in one vintage.

The cumulative knowledge of the last thirty years, shared amongst wine makers, means we drink ever better oak-matured reds and whites. But the quest to get it right goes on – every vintage.

Wine Reviews

Peter Lehmann Barossa Semillon 2005 $11-$14
In a former life Barossa semillon enjoyed great popularity, as Basedows White Burgundy. Over time, this fairly heavy, oak matured white declined and disappeared. R.I.P Barossa semillon. Then the Peter Lehmann gang (including Peter Lehmann, Andrew Wigan and Doug Lehmann, former Basedow winemaker) threw out the oak to make a fresh, zesty, citrusy style that’s now the company’s biggest selling white and a model for other Barossa makers. Lehmann’s yummy unwooded 2005 won silver in last year’s Barossa Show and its cellar mates, the very fine, slow maturing 2001 and 2002 Reserve Semillons, won gold medals.

De Bortoli Yarra Valley Estate Grown Pinot Noir 2005 $27
This is another barrel-matured wine that grows in interest with each glass. It’s the product of the much-changed De Bortoli approach to viticultural and winemaking reported here last year. Hand picked, hand sorted whole berries underwent indigenous yeast fermentation in open tanks with cap plunging only towards the end of the ferment. After twenty-one days in contact with the skins, the wine was settled then gravity filled to oak casks for maturation then bottled without filtration. This low-intervention regime produced a complex, fine, intensely flavoured, deeply textured pinot to savour any time over the next ten years.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007