Plastic set to take a slice of the glass wine bottle market

About half of the wine consumed in Australia reaches our dinner tables via a plastic container – the flexible bladder crammed inside chateau cardboard. But will we embrace the polyethylene terephthalate, or PET, plastic bottle so readily?

Not since the cask appeared more than thirty years ago have we embraced any non-glass packaging so enthusiastically.

During the late 1970s and early 1980s, the four-litre cask (known more aptly in other markets as bag-in-box) drove the humble two-litre glass flagon from our shelves. Today only cheap fortified wines come in flagons, although the diminutive ‘goon’ lives on as the twenty-something’s jargon for cheap wine.

Various cheap, strong, light and appealing alternatives to glass and casks have enjoyed niche but not mainstream success.

In the eighties we saw wine coolers packed in lunchbox-sized tetra packs boycotted by sections of the trade. Some retailers feared that the fruit-juice-like appearance might appeal to underage drinkers, or that children might even confuse it for juice.

We’ve since seen some attempts at packing wine in one-litre tetra packs. And several makers have enjoyed success with wine in cans – most notably Italy’s Rich Prosecco, touted by Paris Hilton.

But the successes are isolated and to date haven’t appealed to mainstream wine drinkers. However, environmental concerns about glass – particularly regarding its weight, high handling and transport costs and safety – mean that alternatives have to found.

As environmental concerns, backed by public policy, now dovetail with commercial cost-cutting needs, the number of alternatives is sure to grow. And PET plastic looks to be a strong favourite.

Like glass it’s strong, can be moulded into bottle shape, enjoys a long history as a drink container and is recyclable.

Unlike glass it’s comparatively light and won’t break into dangerous shards – which is good – but it’s not completely airtight, which is not so good.

Lightness is it’s overwhelming advantage over glass. Troy Hey of Foster’s says that a 750ml PET bottle weighs around 54 grams, compared to a glass bottle’s 400–700 grams.

That means a significant energy saving for every inch of a wine’s journey. The forklift carries 266–496 kilograms less in every pallet; each 1000-case shipping container weighs 4.1–7.7 tonnes less; and your car carries 4.1–7.7 kilograms less weight for every case taken home.

And the bottle even looks less bulky. On a visit to Foster’s Wolf Blass Barossa Winery in April, PET bottles on display looked small – 500ml I wondered? But no, said winemaker Chris Hatcher, these were 750ml bottles currently being exported to Canada.

At this stage, he said, they were being used for early-drinking wines only as slight air permeability meant a shorter shelf life than for the same wine in glass. Since most wine is drunk shortly after purchase, this perhaps makes the majority of wine a candidate for a PET bottle.

And will we wine drinkers accept the new packaging? A fair bit of evidence says that we will.

Indirectly, we’ve seen the dramatic take up of screw caps in the past decade. This can be viewed largely as a triumph of convenience over tradition – even if winemakers originally drove the change on quality grounds. The screw cap acceptance suggests that wine drinkers are not all that conservative.

More directly this decade PET bottles have rapidly replaced glass in the fast-growing single-serve market, dominated by those little 187ml bottles we drink on aircraft.

These have been particularly successful in the US where they were introduced under Fetzer’s Valley Oaks brand early in 2005 and followed in August the same year by Foster’s California based Stone Cellars by Beringer brand.

At the Australian Wine Industry Technical Conference early this month, Jamie O’Dell, Foster’s Managing Director Australia, Asia and Pacific, announced plans to launch the Wolf Blass Green Label wine range in PET bottles in the UK this month.

O’Dell said that the launch follows development work in Canada and that the key advantages of the bottles were lightness and quietness in transport, reduced potential to break and their safety for outside events.

Consumer research, he reported, suggests that people find the environmental message relevant (provided it’s backed by useful facts) and that they like the look of the packaging.

On a more practical level, Foster’s offered its popular Seppelt Fleur de Lys bubbly in PET bottles at Flemington during last year’s spring carnival. Its success means that punters at this year’s carnival will be offered Wolf Blass reds and whites from PET bottles.

While it’s a long shot to project retail success from crowd behaviour at the races, the forces driving the move to lighter, stronger packaging won’t go away. If anything, they’ll intensify.

If the PET bottle’s not much in our minds at present – nor even on retail shelves – my bet is that it’s poised to take a good slice of the market from glass bottles.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Yalumba, Thomas & Chrismont

Yalumba Y Series Pinot Grigio 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 $11.95; Galway Vintage Shiraz 2005 $13.95
Yalumba’s on a roll with these mid-priced wines. They offer outstanding value and will almost certainly be discounted below the recommended prices given above. Pinot Grigio is a strong, distinctive expression of the variety with pear-like flavour, crispness and rich texture. Y Series Cabernet is a very youthful and solid varietal sourced from the Barossa Valley, Eden Valley and Langhorne Creek.  It’s made for early drinking but still captures the soul of cabernet. And Galway is simply a great bargain. It’s a beautifully fragrant, juicy shiraz with typically tender Barossa tannins. The depth of this wine reflects the outstanding vintage.

Thomas Hunter Valley The O.C. Semillon 2007 $20, Braemore Semillon 2007 $25
Former Tyrrell winemaker, Andrew Thomas, specialises in the Hunter’s two distinctive wine styles, shiraz and semillon. Thommo’s new releases express the character of two individual vineyards in the lower Hunter. The O.C. from a vineyard planted near Oakey Creek Road in 1999 is the riper, more forward style of the two. But at a still modest twelve per cent alcohol it has a delicious, fine, delicate, lemony freshness. Braemore, from the sandy flats of Hermitage Road, is even more taut with a lovely lemony/grassy edge. It’s an absolutely stunning, classic of the style. Screw-cap sealed it ought to age for decades. See www.thomaswines.com.au

Chrismont King Valley Petit Manseng 2006 $22
Petit manseng, a white variety grown in Jurancon, southern France, makes what Jancis Robinson calls ‘one of France’s unusually underrated treasures, Jurancon Moelleux’ – a seductively juicy, sweet, long-lived white. This dry King Valley version shows the yeast-lees influence and vanilla-like character of oak fermentation and maturation. But the full, vaguely pineapple-like fruit flavour carries these winemaker inputs comfortably. The result is a rich, fresh, oak-influenced dry white with a flavour all its own and worth trying. Arnold Pizzini’s Chrismont vineyard is located at Cheshunt in Victoria’s upper King Valley, opposite Pizzini Wines, belonging to Arnie’s cousin, Fred Pizzini.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Vineyards underpin McKay’s new Collector label

Despite Hardy’s sudden departure from Canberra, its ten-year presence leaves a valuable legacy that’s bound to express itself in unsuspected ways.

Short of a miracle, the legacy probably won’t be the Kamberra or Meeting Place brands – the small volume face of Hardy’s Canberra involvement.

It’s more likely to come from the know-how of the staff that stayed behind – Alex McKay and Nick O’Leary — and the ingenuity of a score or so independent, former Hardy grape growers.

We’ll almost certainly see an increase in the numbers of wine brands, including this month the release of Alex McKay’s Collector label.

In a big statement for Canberra’s acknowledged specialty, McKay offers two gold-medal-winning shirazes from the Murrumbateman area – Collector The Marked Tree Road Shiraz 2005 (about $27) and Collector Reserve Shiraz 2006 (about $45).

This extraordinary debut is to a large extent a Hardy legacy – revealing the depth of Alex’s experience in the district and the quality of the grapes available.

But there’s a fair bit more to the story, much of it predating Hardy and going back to a time when Alex McKay, an undergraduate art history student, was whetting his taste for winemaking at Lake George Vineyard, under Dr Edgar Riek.

As Riek entered his second decade as a grape grower in the early eighties, Ron McKenzie established a vineyard on his property Mamre at Murrumbateman. Over a couple of seasons McKenzie planted a little under four hectares of chardonnay, cabernet sauvignon, shiraz and what he thought was merlot (in fact it was cabernet franc).

In 1999 McKenzie sold the vineyard to Andrew McEwin, owner of the well-regarded Kyeema Estate label, and a buyer of part of McKenzie’s fruit crop since 1987.

McEwin recalls that when bought the vineyard, Hardy’s were already buying fruit from it. He recalls ‘Steve Pannell [chief winemaker] in raptures over the shiraz’ and believes that this may have been a key to their interest in the region.

As Andrew’s Kyeema shiraz from the vineyard was a regular gold-medal winner, Hardy’s excitement really just confirmed how good the fruit was – and put a price on it.

McEwin says that in every year but one Hardy’s paid a quality bonus when wine from the vineyard made the cut for the company’s top-shelf products. He believes that both chardonnay and shiraz reached the flagship ‘Eileen Hardy’ blends on at least one occasion.

Encouraged by the vineyard’s quality, Andrew recently expanded it by about 1.6 hectares – about half of that being struck from cuttings of the existing old shiraz vines and the other half planted to merlot and tempranillo.

At the same time he replaced the cabernet sauvignon with shiraz and retrellised the whole vineyard. What was ‘grow and sprawl’, said Andrew, is now the more controlled, and quality orientated, vertical shoot positioning system.

During the growing season shiraz receives particular attention, including shoot thinning and bunch thinning to control yields and maximise flavour.

Andrew says that as a contract maker for other grape growers he regularly sees what other vineyards produce. This, he says, confirms the quality of his own shiraz.

As winemaker at the large Hardy-owned Kamberra complex, McKay enjoyed even greater exposure to Canberra’s various shiraz vineyards than McEwin. As well, he participated in Hardy’s classification tastings across all varieties at company headquarters in Reynell, South Australia.

Coming from that broad – and very demanding perspective – McKay’s decision to make only shiraz for his new Collector label and to select McEwin’s vineyard as source of the ‘Reserve’ version – could, in a sense, be seen as Hardy’s collective learning on our region.

Talking to Alex McKay it’s clear that he views Clonakilla and McEwin as Canberra’s two best shiraz vineyards. Which just goes to show that even with the same inputs, all vineyards are not equal.

There is something special about the grapes – and hence the wine — from Andrew McEwin’s tiny, quarter-century old vineyard planted on a granitic saddle between two hills near Murrumbateman.

We’ve seen glimpses of it in Andrew’s Kyeema Wines over the years. But the winemaking experience that McKay brings reveals even more. I’ll review the two new Collector wines shortly.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Beer review — Hunter Old & Schneider Weiss Hefe-Weizen

Hunter Old 375ml $2.50
I suspect this dark, almost black ale is modelled on Tooheys Old, a popular brew in the coal mining communities of both the Hunter and Illawarra regions. Though the aroma and flavour are rich in molasses and roast-malt character, it’s a zesty, low-bitterness, easy-drinking, medium-bodied style.

Schneider Weisse Hefe-Weizen 500ml $5.99
This is a distinctive, dark-amber-coloured, bottle-conditioned wheat beer from Bavaria. It’s a delight to drink with its subtle, fruity/spicy notes and wheat beer’s defining light, tangy, grippiness. Had the bottle been a little fresher – a real problem with delicate imported styles – there’s have been another star in the rating.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Berliner weisse — the working person’s Champagne

Beer offers some wacky and wonderful flavours like the sour taste of Belgian lambic or Germany’s even rarer Berliner weisse.

Any decent liquor store carries at least one lambic beer. But I’ve not seen Berliner weisse at all in Australia nor tasted any local attempts at brewing the style.  Even a search on Perth’s encyclopaedic internationalbeershop.com.au drew a blank.

I’ve come it across judging at the International Beer Awards and have tried it in several Berlin cafés. There it’s generally served with a dash of raspberry or woodruff syrup, giving an alarming red or green hue.

The sweetness of the syrup offsets the sourness of lactic acid, produced deliberately by the use of lactobacillus culture during fermentation.

As a top-fermented wheat beer it would have lighter body and higher acid than traditional beers even without the lactic element. The tart combination earned it the soubriquet arbeiter sekt – working man’s champagne.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Leo Buring, Oxford Landing & Mount Majura

Leo Buring 2007 Rieslings: Eden Valley $18.99, Clare Valley $18.99
Leonay DW K17 Eden Valley 2007 $36.99

These continue a great tradition that began under Leo Buring in the 1940s, passed to Lindemans in the 1960s and then, via Penfold Wine Group and Southcorp, to Foster’s in 2005. Components of the three rieslings looked good in the Barossa recently and hit the mark as finished wines. The Clare wine is the most rounded, generous and slightly grippy of the three – in a crisp, dry, varietal way. The Eden Valley wine is more delicate and racy – a nose ahead of the Clare version. And ‘Leonay’ simply blows its cellar mates away. This is sheer, intense, refined class with long term cellaring potential.

Oxford Landing Cabernet Shiraz 2006, Merlot 2006, Sauvignon Blanc 2006 $6–$8
This is one of the few budget-priced wine ranges with a name that relates to its origins. Oxford Landing is, indeed, a wine estate, established on South Australia’s Murray River in 1958 by Wyndham Hill-Smith, father of the current owner, Robert. Since Oxford Landing’s launch in the eighties, it’s been a budget champ, delivering rich, ripe flavours at the right price. The comparatively low alcohol sauvignon blanc (11.5 per cent) is right on the money in 2007 with fresh, crisp, passionfruit-like varietal flavours. Merlot 2006 is medium bodied with real-red tannins; and Cabernet Shiraz 2006 offers more robust flavours with, again, real red-wine structure.

Mount Majura Canberra District Riesling 2007 $16, Merlot 2005 $16, Shiraz 2006 $25
Tempranillo 2006 $25

Frank van de Loo’s new riesling bursts with aroma and flavour, giving it a drink-now appeal that we don’t always see in this often slow-developing variety. But it also has the fresh acidity and to develop well for several years. It’s clear from the new red releases – and a taste of the 2005 Tempranillo against the 2006 – that 2005 was a stronger year than 2006. That’s just the wines reflecting the seasons, of course. Merlot 2005 shows the chocolaty richness and firm tannin structure of the vintage; Tempranillo 2006 seems a little leaner and more acidic than the 2005; and the 2006 shiraz is just lovely – in the fine, spicy, soft cool-climate mould.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Micro makers focus on individual Barossa vineyards

We’ve all heard of Seppelt, Penfolds, Saltram, Yalumba and Orlando – great and enduring Barossa names. But what do we know of Tuesner, Tscharke, Lienert, Hentley Farm, Clos Otto, Gibson, Schild, Jenke, Haan, Kabinye, Langmeil, The Willows, Whistler, Kaesler, Kalleske, Torbreck, Three Rivers, Rockford, Veritas, Turkey Flat, Greenock Creek and Murray Street Vineyards? – to name just a few of the Valley’s smaller winemakers, many of them comparative newcomers.

There’s a revolution in the valley – perhaps insurrection is a better term – that’s at least as significant as the ‘Rhône ranger’ outbreak of the 1980s. Remember them?

As the industry expanded and consolidated in the mid to late eighties, the Barossa became increasingly a source of anonymous blending material for mass commercial brands – many of them owned by the large, old Barossa firms.

A group of Barossa winemakers, including Charlie Melton (Charles Melton Wines), Robert O’Callaghan (Rockford Wines) and Bob McLean (St Hallett) rebelled against creeping homogeneity and put the Barossa’s best foot forward.

They saw the long-term value of the region’s tried, proven and mature vineyard resources – particularly of the red Rhône Valley varieties shiraz, grenache and mourvedre (hence the sobriquet).

As the larger companies moved away from their regional roots, these small producers embraced regional specialisation and created wine-lover Barossa icons like Charles Melton Nine Popes, Rockford Basket Press Shiraz and St Hallett Old Block Shiraz. These appealed not just to local drinkers but excited a few commentators in export markets as well.

For the Rhône rangers and the others that followed, the Barossa provided rich pickings with its unique vineyard resource spread over a large and climatically and topographically diverse area.

The significant spread from north to south, the varying aspects along the eastern and western slopes and valley floor and varied soils mean significant variation in grape flavours – and hence the styles of wine produced.

These, of course, can never be expressed in multi-region blends. But this vineyard-by-vineyard flavour expression is the international language of fine wine. It’s the foundation of France’s wine appellation (name) system that grew, not from legislation describing wine regions, but from distinct wine styles defining regions.

The Barossa’s pattern of land settlement unquestionably aided the Rhône rangers back in the eighties and seems to be an important factor in the rise of a new band of Barossa sub-regional and single-vineyard specialists.

How can history affect today’s wines? Well, it can. And it’s illuminating to quote from a little booklet that I worked on last year with Phil Laffer, head of Orlando winemaking and viticulture.

In the book (The View From Our Place, Simon and Schuster, UK, 2006), Phil writes of the Barossa, ‘More than any other part of Australia that I can think of, the Barossa retained its ethnic identity for a very long time. This predominantly German influence continues to give us a unique food culture.

From the time the pioneering Germans arrived here in the 1840s until the 1970s, these communities tended to occupy mixed farms, with comparatively low incomes and a culture of growing and preserving much of their own food. They didn’t have any money to move away if they wanted to, so they stayed a very tight-knit community’.

From a modern winemaking viewpoint, the crux of this is that many of those mixed farms included grapes as part of the mix, creating an extraordinary scattering of small to medium holdings across the length and breadth of the Valley.

Many of these are extant today, some in the hands of the fifth and sixth generation of the founding family. Of course, there have been consolidations, grubbings and significant broad-acre plantings over the past decade.

But what the new wave of mostly young winemakers are doing – many without wineries or vineyards of their own – is finding those old, scattered vineyard plots and making small batches of the most extraordinary wine.

They’re mostly of old Barossa families, well qualified, and often have amazing insights into what even very small plots of old vines might deliver.

These are adding to the richness and colour of the other small and medium estate-based operations. And, ultimately, their growing success will probably create a Burgundy-like Barossa – not in wine-style, but in a growing appreciation of sub-regional and individual-vineyard differences expressed in wine.

Our bid to build on the success of ‘brand Australia’ in export markets will rely increasingly on exactly this sort of regional specialisation, where it’s warranted.

And it’s certainly happening in this valley that spreads twenty kilometres from north to south, widens from about 500 metres in the south to ten kilometres in the north, has gentle hills on the western boundary; the higher, cooler Eden Valley rising out of the eastern slopes; and whose south-eastern corner abuts the much cooler Adelaide Hills.

This column will look at some of the new-wave Barossa makers in the months ahead.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Beer review — Matilda Bay & Little Creatures

Matilda Bay Grayston Reserve 07 750ml $17
Brad Rogers’s second vintage ale is bottle-conditioned and built to last. It’s a wheat ale combining five different barley and wheat malts. The combination gives Grayston a rich, chocolate-like flavour. But the wheat components add a spiciness and lift to the estery, fruity aroma and a vibrance and crisp acidity to the palate.

Little Creatures Bright Ale 330ml 6 pack $18.99
This is a small brewer’s response to demand for an easy drinking beer. Made in the image of the full-bore, cloudy Pale Ale, Bright Ale leads with the lovely citrus/resiny character of new season New Zealand hops in a moderately bitter brew built on delicious, subtle pale ale, carapils crystal, Vienna and wheat malts.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Another vintage beer story

Where vintage wines reflect seasonal variations on grape flavour, a vintage date on a beer signals the brewer’s intent to give us a robust, age-worthy brew rather than seasonal flavour impact.

And the difference in flavours between vintage beers reflects the brewer’s imagination and ingredient selection rather than, say, the regional differences that we might see in wine.

The Cooper’s and Matilda Bay 2007 vintage ales reviewed this week and last illustrate the impact that brewing decisions makes on the beers we drink.

Cooper’s opts for a high-alcohol (7.5 per cent) all-barley beer. The result is an opulent, rounded beer with heady fruit-like esters. To keep these in check the brewers create countering herbal aromas, flavours and bitterness with a liberal addition of hops.

The less alcoholic Matilda Bay, by using wheat malt as well as barley, has a drier, less rounded palate, more apparent fruitiness and the distinctive acidity of wheat ales.

Matilda Bay Grayston Reserve 07 750ml $17
Brad Rogers’s second vintage ale is bottle-conditioned and built to last. It’s a wheat ale combining five different barley and wheat malts. The combination gives Grayston a rich, chocolate-like flavour. But the wheat components add a spiciness and lift to the estery, fruity aroma and a vibrance and crisp acidity to the palate.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Carlei, Majella & Wither Hills

Carlei Green Vineyards Yarra Valley Chardonnay 2005 $29, Heathcote Shiraz 2004 $27 and Upper Goulburn Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 $29
Sergio Carlei sources fruit from various Victorian vineyards, matching grape variety to region – with great individuality from what I’ve tasted to date. The new releases hit the mark again, particularly the chardonnay and shiraz. While the finely structured Yarra chardonnay shows all the complexities of barrel fermentation and maturation, it’s the pure, varietal fruit that really stars. The shiraz is sensational – full bodied, but elegant at the same time, with generous, savoury fragrance, silky, smooth tannins and high natural acidity that focuses the varietal flavour and gives the wine life and lift. The cabernet? – lovely, but upstaged by a few Coonawarras on the tasting bench.

Majella Coonawarra Shiraz 2005 $30, Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 $30 and The Malleea Cabernet Shiraz 2004 $70
These have become Coonawarra benchmarks since Brian ‘Prof’ Lynn and his brother Tony shifted from grape growing to winemaking in the early nineties. The wines are made in a distinctive ripe and robust style with generous, though sympathetic oak treatment – a style partly steered by what the vineyard produces but also carefully thought through by Prof and winemaker Bruce Gregory. The 2005’s show the great ripe, juiciness of the vintage without sacrificing Coonawarra’s deep, sweet berry flavours. The cabernet, in particular, is stunning and destined for a very long cellaring life. The flagship Malleea shows the elegance of the cooler year.

Wither Hills Marlborough Pinot Noir 2004 or 2005 $45-$50
Lion-Nathan-owned Wither Hills, on the cooler, southern side of Marlborough’s Wairau Valley, has developed what I believe are some of the best value-for-money pinots in the world under its founder, Brent Marris. Brent recently left, leaving the reins to his long serving offsider, Ben Glover. Ben had a hand in making both of these delicious wines. And although the richer, riper 2005 replaced the 2004 some time back, both can still be found on retail shelves. The 2004 now shows some sweet, gamy, bottle-age character that’s 100 per cent pinot, while the 2005 still presents more primary varietal fruitiness. Both have the silky depth of good pinot.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007