Yearly Archives: 1987

Dom Perignon 1976 reminds us to be guarded in our wine judgments

DURING the week, Canberra has been host to some of the world’s leading wine judges. Australia’s top palates (Len Evans, Brian Croser, Ian Mackenzie, and others) were joined, courtesy of Qantas, by British wine merchants John Avery of Bristol and Anthony Hanson of London, and Peter Sichel (of Blue Nun fame) from New York.

Now, Dr Edgar Riek is keeping the results of the Australian Wine Show under lock and key until next week, but I am allowed to report that the annual procession of wine judges to Canberra has been accompanied by a fair bit of whooping it up by anyone even remotely connected to the wine trade.

The social highlight of the week is on Monday night when the judges are welcomed to town in great style at a humble little cottage in Forrest. The food alone is worthy of a column but fearing retribution from above (directly above, sorry Michael) I’ll move straight on to the wine. [A reference to food writer Michael Boddy. His column appeared above mine].

This is the one occasion of the year when, despite the feeble Australian dollar, we feel justified in opening some of the great wines of the world. There were some beautiful wines sampled last Monday, including the magnificent 1959 Chateau Latour.

But for me the highlight, and the purpose of this column today, was the 1976 Dom Perignon Champagne.

I first drank this wine back in 1984 when the dollar fetched more than eight francs and the price of Dom Perignon was $45 a bottle and not $100. During that year many Australian wine commentators had written off French Champagnes of the 1976 vintage. Because the year was exceptionally hot, the wines were far richer and more alcoholic than normal.

English wine critics were more cautious in their appraisal of the 1976 champagnes. Having considerably more experience in these matters than their Australian colleagues of the period, the British gave many of the 76s cautious praise with just a little hesitant question mark over the ability of such atypical Champagnes to stand the test of time.

Even then the extraordinary qualities of the 1976 Dom Perignon were hard to deny. In fact, David Farmer was so taken by it that he and brother Richard gathered every bottle available in Australia and squirreled it away under their shop in Manuka. Suddenly virtually every bottle of Dom Perignon in Australia lay in Canberra.

In 1985 (I think) Michael Broadbent, the most respected palate in the world, went on record as saying the 1976 Dom Perignon and 1976 Heidsieck Monopole Diamant Bleau were two of the greatest champagnes he’d ever tried. Meanwhile Canberra’s restaurants were awash with ’76 Dom while the rest of Australia scratched its head wondering where the stuff had all gone.

The lesson in all this as far as wine is concerned is that we should be a little guarded in our criticism of the unfamiliar and that, more often than not, French wines with high reputations built over many years live up to their names. In fact, Dom Perignon and other deluxe Champagnes from reputable houses are the unofficial Grand Cru wines of the Champagne region.

There’s no official classification of individual wines in Champagne, but there is a well-founded grading of vineyards. The grading has been formed over many generations and is so closely followed by the champenoise that grape prices directly reflect the status of the vineyard from which they come. Dom Perignon and other top champagnes are made entirely from grapes from the very highest ranking vineyards. Which is why, over time, they hold their reputations.

Unfortunately, after last Monday night, 1976 Dom Perignon is unprocurable. But if you’re after something really outstanding to drink this Christmas, and money is no object, buy any vintage of Dom Perignon (provided it’s not too old). Just as good, but even harder to find, are Krug, Bollinger Tradition RD 1976, and Veuve Clicquot La Grande Dame 1979. Quite simply, they are amongst the best wines in the world.

But at $100 and more a bottle they begin to lose their appeal. Is any wine, no matter how good or how rare, really worth that sort of money?

First published 15 November 1987 in The Canberra Times
Copyright © Chris Shanahan 1987 and 2026

More government pressure likely as issues divide Australia’s liquor industry

Events surrounding Lindemans’ release of a 250ml [tetra pack fruit-juice-like] wine cooler have proven that Australia’s alcoholic beverage industry, and especially the wine industry, is hopelessly divided on the most fundamental of issues and, in some cases, blissfully unaware of the strong forces aligned against it.

In a fortnight of publicity, not a single person from the industry has stepped forward to present the broader issues symbolised by the now infamous cooler. Journalists, too, have failed to expand on the important issues of selling and marketing alcohol and the certainty that governments will exert even more influence in this area in the very near future.

The small pack itself is doomed to failure. Even if Lindemans wins its battle in Adelaide Supreme Court there won’t be any retailers willing to stock it. Interestingly, the forces against the pack have won not so much through public support as through the glare of publicity. Politicians and retailers alike wilted in the strong light.

Whatever the reasons for the rejection of its new product, Lindemans’ management must now seriously examine its own judgment. At a time when the government had clearly announced its intention of tightening control of alcohol advertising directed at the young, the introduction of such a pack was surely inviting government attention.

For it was only last November that health ministers of the federal and state governments were presented with the Draft National Health Policy on Alcohol, a document I mentioned in this column recently. The document reflects not only a changing community attitude to alcohol but will almost certainly lead to even greater government regulation of the distribution, marketing, advertising, and sale of alcoholic drinks.

The report covers the topics of public education, health promotion, and treatment of alcohol-induced ailments. But its significance for responsible consumers and the industry lies in its assumptions regarding alcohol and public health and the means it sees as necessary to reduce alcohol consumption.

Perhaps the broadest assumption of the report is that if you reduce per-capita consumption of alcohol, problems associated with alcohol will automatically decrease. This argument takes no account of other demographic factors. Whatever its validity, it is surely now measurable, given an apparent decline in per-capita consumption from a peak of 9.8 litres in 1981–82 to 8.9 litres in 1985–86, with the decline expected to continue.

The cause of this decline is hard to find, given the historically low price and intense advertising of alcohol in this period. Undoubtedly, increased public awareness of health issues evidenced by the jogging and aerobic exercise phenomena have played their part. Government intervention to hasten this tendency towards lower alcohol consumption must surely fill the hearts of the majority of responsible drinkers with horror.

For the one sure thing we know about legislation aimed at curbing the behaviour of human beings is that it never works. Proposals to further limit the number of licensed premises are absurd. That will simply increase the value of existing businesses and reduce competition and all the benefits that go with it.

The report also suggests that higher prices will help to reduce alcohol consumption. Perhaps it will also reduce the money left for food for the families of the afflicted. Suggestions that prices can be manipulated through progressively taxing alcoholic beverages on their alcoholic content will be greeted warmly by the anti-alcohol lobby. For this will further divide a fragmented industry deferring for even longer the day when a united and responsible stance is taken.

All those brewers, distillers, and winemakers who thought government intervention too great already will shudder at the report’s strategy No 3. It proposes the formation of a statutory body to oversee the advertising of alcohol. Particularly slated for attention are ads which associate alcohol with sport, lifestyle and cultural sponsorship, as well as those targeted at young people and women. Why women need special protection is not stated.

Despite the barriers which divide the liquor industry and make it vulnerable to government intervention, it has contributed significantly towards the trend to drink less alcohol, albeit because of community demand. Low alcohol beers now account for more than 11 per cent of all beer consumed. Coolers, despite the rejection of one form of packaging, are far lower in alcohol than wine and are premixed so that drinkers know exactly how strong their drink is. It now appears that sales of coolers are at the expense of stronger beverages. The tendency with spirits and liqueurs is also towards lower alcohol content. Gone are the days of heady cocktails containing 40 per cent or so of alcohol, and in are spirits diluted to 10 per cent or less with soft drinks. Even the new liqueurs like Malibu and Bailey’s Irish Cream are about half the strength of the ones people drank 10 years ago.

The industry may be too late to regulate itself but it will be a sorry day when Australians need yet another government agency to control what should be a joyous aspect of our lifestyle.

First published 18 January 1987 in The Canberra Times
Copyright © Chris Shanahan 1987 and 2026