Category Archives: People

Penfolds releases Grange, St Henri, Magill Estate, RWT, Bin 707 and Bin 169

I tasted Penfolds’ blue-chip reds ahead of the 3 May release date – missing the “mine’s smaller than yours” retail price scrum invariably accompanying the release. Therefore, by the time you read this, prices at major retail outlets will likely have tumbled below the recommended prices I give below.

Yet again under winemaker Peter Gago, we see a magnificent suite of reds built for long-term cellaring. Each shows its own distinctive character. And all, except St Henri, bear the deep purple thumbprint of Max Schubert, genius Grange creator.

Retailer discounting notwithstanding, prices have moved up steadily in recent years, marking the internationalisation of the Penfolds brand – underpinned increasingly, like Bordeaux and Burgundy, by the rising wealthy classes in China.

With the exception of Grange, the wines come both cork and screwcap sealed. I recommend the screw cap in all instances. Grange comes only with cork at this stage, though Penfolds’ trials with other seals for very long-term cellaring will result ultimately in a cork alternative.

Penfolds St Henri Shiraz 2008
Price:
$95
Grapes:
Shiraz 91 per cent; cabernet sauvignon 9 per cent
Regions: Barossa Valley, McLaren Vale, Langhorne Creek and Adelaide Hills
Maturation: 1,460 oak vats, more than 50 years old
History: Developed by John Davoren in the early 1950s; first commercial vintage 1957.
Style: Elegant, medium-bodied shiraz without the input of new oak, a thumbprint of most Penfolds reds
Tasting note

Deep red colour with a vivid purple hue at the rim; pure, ripe, and youthful mulberry-like varietal aroma; the beautiful, pure fruitiness flows through to a supple, juicy palate – the fruit layered with fine-boned, drying, savoury tannins. This is big but typical St Henri – elegant, understated, no oak in sight and built for long-term cellaring. Can be enjoyed now, but from experience should drink best from 15 years of age and continue to evolve for decades (reliably under screw cap).

Penfolds Magill Estate Shiraz 2009
Price:
$130
Grapes:
Shiraz
Regions: Penfolds Magill Estate vineyard, Magill, South Australia
Maturation: 12 months in 67 per cent new French and 25 per cent new American oak hogsheads; balance in one-year-old French hogsheads.
History: Initiated by retired Grange creator, Max Schubert, with support of Penfolds executives, following mooted redevelopment of the suburban Magill site. First vintage 1983.
Style: Medium bodied, finely textured shiraz reflecting seasonal conditions in the 5.2-hectare vineyard.
Tasting note

Deep red/black colour with youthful crimson and purple tones at the rim; the aroma combines ripe varietal fruit and spice meshed with oak (an effect produced by barrel fermentation says Peter Gago); has quite an acid attack after the St Henri – accentuating both the vibrant berry flavours and the well-integrated oak characters. Layers of assertive but velvety fruit and oak tannins add texture and carry through the finish with the fruit. A particularly good Magill with good cellaring potential – best drinking after another two or three years in the cellar.

Penfolds RWT Barossa Valley Shiraz 2009
Price:
$175
Grapes:
Shiraz
Regions: Barossa Valley, usually northern and western areas.
Maturation: 14 months in 60 per cent new, 40 per cent one-year-old French oak hogsheads
History: Trialled from 1995 by John Duval. First vintage 1997, released in May 2000. Winemaker Peter Gago says RWT helps protects Grange from periodic suggestions to lighten it up.
Style: An aromatic, opulent and fleshy expression of Barossa shiraz, contrasting with the power and intensity of Grange. Matured in French, not American oak.
Tasting note
Deep, dense red/black colour with purple rim; the nose delivery highly aromatic plummy fruit mixed with sweet, spicy French oak, promising a wine of opulence; the palate delivers the promise – big but graceful, combing ripe Barossa shiraz flavours with sweet oak and layers of juicy tannin. There’s a meaty note too, reminiscent of the browned outside of char-grilled steak, adding a umami dimension to the fruit/oak amalgam. RWT 2009 should drink very well after another few years of maturation and evolve well for a decade or two if well cellared.

Penfolds Grange Shiraz 2007
Price:
$625
Grapes:
Shiraz 97 per cent; cabernet sauvignon three per cent
Regions: Barossa Valley, McLaren Vale and Magill Estate
Maturation: 21 months in new American oak hogsheads
History: Developed by Max Schubert from the 1951 vintage.
Style: Powerful and unique expression of warm-climate shiraz capable of very long term cellaring. Becomes finer and more elegant with prolonged bottle ageing
Tasting note
Dense red/black colour all the way to the rim; an all-Grange aroma – ripe, penetrating and idiosyncratic; enormously powerful, mouth-puckering palate; an exquisite, exotic lump of flavour and texture, all in one piece, the many components inseparable from one another. Somewhat firmer and without the particularly buoyant fruit of the 2006 vintage – a typical Grange expression of the vintage. Are there any other Australian wines as good as this? Yes. Are there any others that taste like this? No. This is unique. Best drinking should be from 15 years and beyond – for many decades if well cellared.

Penfolds Bin 707 Cabernet Sauvignon 2009
Price:
$250
Grapes:
Cabernet sauvignon
Regions: Coonawarra, Barossa, Wrattonbully, Padthway
Maturation: 13 months in new American oak hogsheads
History: First made in 1964 from cabernet grown in Penfolds Kalimna vineyard, Barossa Valley. Discontinued between 1970 and 1975 because of cabernet shortages. Relaunched 1976 and not released in 1981, 1995, 2000 or 2003.
Style: A powerful style in the mould of Grange. Know affectionately within Penfolds as “Grange cabernet”.
Tasting note
Dense red/black colour with brilliant purple rim; a beautifully aromatic Bin 707, led by sweet, ripe, dark berries, typical of Coonawarra cabernet, seasoned by sweet oak; beautiful, sweet, dense, ripe fruit pushes through the firm, griping tannins on the palate. The overall impression is of power with elegance in a wine we know from experience retains its clear varietal character for decades, becoming finer and more elegant with age. This is a classy Bin 707, at home with lamb or beef now, but likely to be at its best in fifteen years or more. Chateau Shanahan’s 1986 still drinks perfectly, so no rush with the 2009.

Penfolds Bin 169 Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon 2008
Price:
$250 but available only at the cellar door.
Regions: Coonawarra
Maturation: Fine-grained French oak hogsheads
History: New under this label, but Penfolds made a Bin 169 Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon in 1973 – the best parcel from the vintage.
Style: Winemaker Peter Gago says Bin 169 is to Bin 707 Cabernet Sauvignon what RWT Shiraz is to Grange – a fragrant, elegant expression of a regional specialty, matured in French rather than American oak. Gago believes Bin 169 will protect the unique Bin 707 style just as RWT protects Grange.
Tasting note

Not tasted this year, but sampled previously on a couple of occasions with Peter Gago, Bin 169 easily sits with Australia’s finest cabernets – a pure, vibrant, luxuriously textured expression of Coonawarra. Bound to sit near the top of any masked tasting of cabernets from anywhere in the world.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published, in part, 9 May 2102 in The Canberra Times

Canberra’s vintage of a lifetime

Canberra’s vintage from hell, or vintage of a lifetime, turned out to be both, and bit in between as well. Canberra vignerons wrote off swathes of diseased fruit, adding to shiraz crop losses caused by poor fruit set early in the season. But by carefully handpicking healthy fruit, and in some cases weeding out diseased berries in the winery, the district now has its generally sound, albeit much reduced, 2012 vintage in the vat.

Riesling specialist Ken Helm, hopeful but apprehensive during February’s pre-vintage rain, emailed triumphantly on 16 March, “We are finishing our Riesling today. The fruit is outstanding and it is the vintage of my lifetime.”

A month later, the voice at the other end of the phone says, “It’s still the vintage of a lifetime. The wines are finished [fermenting] and they’re incredible. We will have a reserve riesling this year, but the crop’s down 50 per cent”.

Helm attributes the crop losses to berry splitting, caused by rain, followed by outbreaks of the mould, botrytis cinerea. However, the cool season, recording just four days over 30 degrees, encouraged steady flavour development and good acid retention in riesling grapes.

Helm says riesling achieved flavour ripeness at low sugar levels and exceptionally high acidity of 10.5 to 11 grams per litre. During fermentation and subsequent cold stabilisation, however, acidity dropped to a more palate friendly 7.5 to eight grams a litre – ideal numbers in dry wines of 10.3 to 10.5 per cent alcohol.

Helm expects to release his 2012 Classic Dry and Premium rieslings in August or September. And for only the second time in 40 years, he made a botrytis-infected sweet riesling. He says the 3.5 tonnes of fruit yielded just 800 luscious litres.

Helm’s other specialty, cabernet sauvignon, suffered less than shiraz in the adverse conditions. Nevertheless, he anticipated a 30 per cent drop in the coming crop from neighbour Al Lustenburger’s vineyard.

Clonakilla’s Tim Kirk says he’s “astonished at how it’s turned out. The fortunes of Clonakilla, and Canberra in general, hang on shiraz. We were worried botrytis would explode and lead to big crop losses. We saw this in some vineyards, which were unpickable. Not so in Clonakilla vineyard”.

Kirk recalls in the comparably cool, wet 2011 season leaving half his shiraz on the vine. The fruit had set with thin skins, making it vulnerable to disease. In 2012, however, the vines produced a small crop of disease resistant, thick-skinned berries – all successfully harvested.

Kirk believes the shiraz “may prove to be extraordinary, but we’ll wait and see”. Pressing the wine after three weeks post-ferment maceration on skins, Kirk observed, “very dark colour and fantastic flavours”. It’s high in acid, he says, but malolactic fermentation (a secondary fermentation that reduces total acidity) is yet to occur. Kirk believes cool seasons like 2012, where fruit struggles to ripeness but gets there, are potentially the greatest.

Kirk picked riesling early, ahead of the rain, looks to be “a very fine, bony style along the lines of 2011 – acid driven, fresh and appley, but delicious”. He held back unfermented juice which can be added back after ferment should the wine need rounding out.

Cabernet and merlot ripened fully but nevertheless show the herbaceous character of the cool year. Viognier developed good flavours at low sugar levels. There’s not much of it, says Kirk, and it’s definitely suited to Clonakilla’s elegant style – far removed from the syrupy versions made in warmer climates.

Sauvignon blanc and semillon, picked early to avoid disease, look a little on the green side, says Kirk, but a tiny pinot noir crop produced good looking wine, driven buy its tannin structure.

At Lerida Estate, Lake George, Jim Lumbers reports big drops in quantity. Merlot yielded better than last year and despite botrytis infections, “we have some very good fruit”, he says. “The whites are great, especially pinot grigio”.

Pinot noir looks glorious. We’re pressing it, it looks fantastic, and so does the 2011. But we never would’ve dreamt it”. Lumbers say he picked pinot very early, hoping to beat diseases, but feared green, unripe flavours in the wine.

His team used sorting tables to eliminate diseased berries. The juice appeared very pale at first, but after fermentation the wines show good, if not deep colours, delicate violet-like aromas and amazing ripe fruit flavours.

The much-reduced shiraz crop, says Lumbers, looks very good and should make the cut for Lerida’s flagship shiraz viognier blend.

Up on the Lake George escarpment, Lark Hill’s Chris Carpenter reports a reduced but healthy crop with no losses to disease. The family’s Murrumbateman vineyard, however, suffered extensive hail damage. The Carpenter’s lost all of the shiraz from the vineyard, but harvested sangiovese and small amounts of the Rhone Valley white varieties marsanne, roussanne and viognier.

From the slopes of Mount Majura, Frank van der Loo reports that after a long wait for reds to ripen, they did, showing “fantastic deep colours but very low quantities”. Crop losses resulted from a combination of disease and weather-related poor fruit set.

The whites, says van der Loo are “good to excellent, showing the vintage raciness – long, steely acid, even in pinot grigio [a notably low-acid variety]”. He says the reds will be lighter bodied but deeper coloured than usual.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 2 May 2012 in The Canberra Times

Natural wine is the buzzword — but what does it really mean?

When is a wine natural? The concept of “natural” wine stuck its head into our letterbox twice last month. The first, a note from Clare Valley winemaker Jeffrey Grosset, accompanied a sample of the magnificent Grosset Gaia 2009 (five-star review 28 March).

Grosset’s note sparked our curiosity. It read, “The Gaia vineyard is named after James Lovelock’s original book Gaia: a new look at life on Earth. Lovelock proposed the Gaia hypothesis, now Gaia theory, that the Earth is a single organism, reliant on the complexity and diversity of its species to maintain ecological health.

While there is an international ‘natural’ wine movement, many great winemakers who believe they are already making natural wine have chosen not to jump on the ‘natural’ bandwagon. Jeffrey Grosset remains a firm believer in being guided by the producer’s name, rather than by a loosely defined term.

For decades now, every Grosset wine has been made with such precision and attention to detail, that the need for fining has been avoided and the wine’s integrity maintained. So in the absence of any chemical additives or finings, is it possible to refer to Grosset wines as anything but natural?”

The second arrival in our letterbox – Alice Feiring’s new book, Naked wine: letting grapes do what comes naturally – plunged directly into the natural wine movement, the object of Grosset’s comments.

Feiring traces the rise of today’s natural wine movement to Jules Chauvet, French scientist, his assistant, Jacques Neauport, and a winemaker in the Beaujolais village of Morgon, Marcel Lapierre.

In 1978”, writes Feiring, “Marcel Lapierre came to terms with the reality that he couldn’t stand to drink his own wine”. Independently of Lapierre, Chauvet had noted with despair the degradation of Beaujolais wines.

In a 1984 interview with American writer Kermit Lynch, reports Feiring, Chauvet recounted the unwelcome transformation of Beaujolais, between the late 1940s and mid 1970s, from fruity low-alcohol red, to hollow, alcoholic wine – often over-sulphured and smelling of banana, courtesy of “the industrial yeast 71B”.

Excessive yields made the wines ever more insipid and over use of chemicals in vineyards resulted in degraded soils, devoid of life and nutrients, Chauvet told Lynch. Ultimately, writes Feiring, “The region, capable of such greatness, became the vinous equivalent of candy corn, consumed only once a year [thanks to the rise of Beaujolais nouveau]”.

Lapierre, and a few other Morgon producers influenced by him, altered their grape growing and winemaking practices. Lynch imported the wines to the United States and began the difficult task of selling these wines, made without the addition of sugar (to boost alcohol content), sulphur or yeast.

Forty years on, the natural wine movement enjoys a global following – with dedicated wine bars in some countries. But as far as I can ascertain, there’s no formal definition of “natural wine”. At the core lies a notion we can all relate to – that wine should be a clean, wholesome product from sustainable vineyards. At a practical level, for the naturalists, this means adding and taking away as little possible from wine – no or low sulphur additions, no additions of cultured yeast, sugar, acid, tannin or yeast nutrients, no use of fining agents and no filtration.

But the proponents seem to share plenty of common ground with winemakers not sailing under the “natural” banner. And this brings us back to Jeffrey Grosset.

He says, “I was at a restaurant and their list had a whole section on natural wines. I was shocked and asked where are we? It’s a shame the naturals feel they have to put a wedge between themselves and other winemakers. It’s flawed logic to think that to show that I’m better I must show that others are wrong”.

He sees flawed logic, too, in insisting on wild yeast ferments and avoiding sulphur additions. The latter, he likens to throwing away personal hygiene – opening the door to oxidation in delicate juice like riesling and microbial spoilage in finished wine.

Grosset sees the term “natural yeast” as a misnomer, believing that yeast populations in wineries, and perhaps in the vineyard, as most likely including strains previously introduced. “Wild yeast” is therefore a better descriptor.

He says that if you’ve gone to the trouble to choose the right vineyard sites, use organic practices, balance every vine and get every bunch, every berry ripe and eliminate damaged fruit, “then using wild yeast doesn’t align with all this control. The results might be great or not so great”. He prefers to use a range of known yeasts in every ferment, emulating successful wild-yeast ferments.

Every bunch is precious and we make the best wine we can. We can’t leave it to fate”, he concludes.

Grosset speaks only for himself. But hundreds of Australian winemakers have been striving for decades to create healthy soils in their vineyards, gradually bringing their fruit to perfection and adding, or taking away, only what they need to make natural wines. They’ve simply not jumped on the “natural” bandwagon.

And as Feiring points out in her book, so-called “natural” winemakers embrace a spectrum of views. These range from strict no-sulphur regimes, to a minimum intervention approach strikingly similar to what Grosset and many other Australian makers employ.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 4 April 2012  in The Canberra Times

Gypsy brewing in Beechworth

On Friday 9 March, the Rostrevor Hop Garden, Ovens Valley, provided fresh-picked hops to Ben Kraus at Bridge Road Brewers, Beechworth. Until the wee hours, Kraus, with visiting Danish brewer, Mikkel Bjergso, worked on their one-off Dark Harvest Ale, designed to showcase the hops.

Kraus says the collaborative brew will be “an imperial dark ale/porter brewed with freshly picked ‘wet’ hops, used in copious amounts, weighing in at around 7.5 per cent alcohol”.

Bjergso runs Mikkeller Brewery, globally famed, says Kraus, “for their unique take on established brewing styles”. Kraus calls Bjergso “a self-proclaimed gypsy brewer”, as he travels the world, making beer collaboratively with other brewers. He released 76 beers in 2010 alone.

Kraus intends to offer the beer on tap at his Beechworth brewery and distribute it to craft beer venues throughout Australia from early April.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 28 March 2012 in The Canberra Times

Eileen Hardy goes south for quality

Paul Lapsley, chief winemaker of Accolade Wines, owner of Hardy's

Eileen Hardy shiraz and Eileen Hardy chardonnay date from 1970 and 1986 respectively. The wines released under the labels since then mirror Australia’s winemaking history. And, like time capsules, each vintage reveals something of the winemaking and viticulture of its time. Collectively they carry a rich history.

Eileen Hardy Shiraz 1970 reflected the red wine boom of the time, the dominance of warm South Australian regions in this phenomenon and the unquestioned status of shiraz in McLaren Vale – home of the then family-owned Thomas Hardy and Sons. Eileen Hardy shiraz later wandered from its origins, parallel to similar moves across the industry, only to return to its McLaren Vale roots years later.

Sixteen years after the first Eileen shiraz, as white wine boomed, Eileen Hardy chardonnay arrived – based on grapes from Padthaway, South Australia. Over time grape sourcing followed quality southwards – settling principally in the Yarra Valley and Tasmania by the turn of the century.

During the journey, the style changed dramatically – from the big, fat, oaky, buttery style of the eighties (based on warm-climate fruit) to the more fine-boned, intense, Burgundy-like versions we enjoy today.

While Australians embraced chardonnay en masse in the eighties, popular discovery of pinot noir remained decades away. But in recent times it’s become the fastest growing red variety (driven largely by New Zealand wines) – and even now that’s off a very small base.

Once a footnote in Australian red-wine sales figures, pinot accounted for six per cent by value of retail red wine sales in the year to September 2011, according to Nielsen data.

Vintage Cellars liquor executive, Grant Ramage, says the figures also reveal pinot as “the fastest growing of the major varieties” at 21 per cent for the year, compared to nine per cent for shiraz (which accounts for 26 per cent of red wine sales) and five per cent for cabernet sauvignon.

The figures also reveal that we pay more, on average, for pinot than for shiraz or red in general – $17.50 retail a bottle for pinot, $12.50 for shiraz and $8.49 for red wine overall.

Where interest in chardonnay grew on a wide popular front, driven by cheaper wines from high-yielding, warm-climate vineyards, pinot started at the top, made in tiny quantities by dedicated producers in cool regions.

Hardy’s move into serious pinot noir began with its acquisition of Yarra Burn winery and vineyards, in Victoria’s Yarra Valley, a couple of decades back.

Then in the nineties, the search for high quality pinot and chardonnay for sparkling wine led Hardys to Tasmania. But they quickly embraced table wine, too. By the turn of the century, grape sourcing for Eileen Hardy chardonnay had shifted mainly to Tasmania and the Yarra Valley.

From 2002 their Bay of Fires winery at Pipers River processed all of the company’s Tasmanian fruit – for both table and sparkling wines. By 2009, under Fran Austin, Bay of Fires Pinot Noir had emerged as one of the state’s finest.

By this time, Hardy’s also held two held two vintages of its new Eileen Hardy Pinot Noir in its cellars. They’ve since been released quietly into the market – wines of exceptional quality, yet little known outside the wine industry.

The first release, from the hot 2008 vintage, comes from two mature vineyards in Tasmania’s Coal River Valley and the Yarra Burn vineyard in the upper Yarra Valley. It’s a full-bodied pinot noir, reflecting the hot season.

The currently available 2009 vintage ($85 at cellar door), and the not-yet-released 2010, are both 100 per cent Tasmanian, says chief winemaker Paul Lapsley.

But it’s not always a lay down misere for Tasmania”, he says. It can be a blend or a single vineyard”. He explains that in 2009 the blend appeared likely to included fruit from Yarra Burn. But February bushfires, and subsequent smoke taint ruled out this possibility.

Fortunately a single parcel for fruit from the Tollpuddle vineyard, in Tasmania’s Coal River Valley, rose to the occasion. Lapsley says they made the 2009 from a half-hectare section on the middle slopes of the 2.5-hectare vineyard. It’s a finer, more elegant style than the 2009, reflecting benign growing conditions.

The 2010 also appeared set to be a Tasmania-Yarra blend. But untimely heavy rain in the upper Yarra led to flavour dilution – ruling the fruit out of contention for the flagship blend.

In the end, says Lapsley, the wine includes material from on Coal River vineyard and Derwent Estate, at Granton, on the Derwent River.

Lapsley says the greatest sites in Tasmania at present tend to in the Coal River Valley and at Derwent Estate, but may expand to the East Coast as vineyards there mature as “the textural component is lacking at present.

There’ll be no 2011 Eileen Hardy Pinot Noir and the 2012 remains in the future – although Tasmania appears particularly attractive several weeks out from vintage, says Lapsley.

Looking further ahead Lapsley sees continuing “synergies between Tasmania and the upper Yarra. But we won’t stop looking in Mornington, Gippsland and Beechworth. If it fits the bill, we’ll use it”.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 21 January 2012 in The Canberra Times, Sydney Morning Herald

Beechworth-Nogne brewing collaboration

Before heading off to Europe last year, Australian brewer Ben Kraus contacted Nogne Brewery, Norway, and organised a joint brewing session.

Kraus airfreighted fresh Australian galaxy and stella hops to Nogne, and with brewer Kjetil Jikiun made 5,000 litres of India Saison. Nogne marketed the co-branded beer in Europe and shipped some in 500ml bottles to Australia.

Returning to Australia, Kraus made a batch to the same recipe at Bridge Road Brewers, Beechworth. So successful was it that he brewed a second batch and has a third in the making.

His Norwegian mate enjoyed similar same success, and is now into his seventh batch, says Kraus.

Kraus says Jikian’s visiting Melbourne for good beer week in May and will visit Beechworth to collaborate on another brew. Kraus also plans to work with a visiting Danish brewer.

Nogne and Bridge Road Brewery India Saison 330ml $5.50
Hops, hops, hops and more hops – glorious, fresh, pungent and resiny – drive this collaboration between Norway’s Nogne brewery and Bridge Road Brewers, Beechworth. They’re Australian galaxy and stella varieties, says brewer Ben Kraus. They dominate the aroma, push through the full, malty palate and linger, bitter and tart on the palate.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 21 March 2012 in The Canberra Times

Canberra 2012 – vintage of a lifetime, or a washout?

As I write in the opening days of autumn, a potentially great Canberra vintage hangs in the balance – threatened by a massive band of rain moving across southeastern Australia. If it hangs around too long, mildew and botrytis could threaten the crop; if too much rain falls, berries might split, increasing disease risks and reducing yields. Should mild, clear weather follow the big wet, however, the district may yet produce some of its best wines ever, say several producers. By the time you read this, we’ll have some idea of the outcome.

Never short of enthusiasm, Murrumbateman’s Ken Helm sees beyond the steady rain and drenched vineyards. “It’s a once in a lifetime season”, he declares, “and we still have a chance. I’ve seen nothing like in 40 years. We’ve had only four days over 30 degrees”.

Mild conditions leading up to the rain favoured flavour development at low sugar levels, report growers across the district. Helm says, “riesling in particular is outstanding. Even at nine Baume [a measure of sugar content] it tasted ripe. Normally your face would be like a chook’s bum. There’s a green tinge about riesling berries, like they have in Germany, and no sign of sunburn.”

Helm’s other specialty, cabernet sauvignon, still appears disease free and set for a normal crop. Helm says because it buds late, cabernet missed the poor weather that disrupted flowering in many shiraz vineyards around Murrumbateman.

Fellow Murrumbateman vigneron, Greg Gallagher, said rain and windstorms around flowering time resulted in “loose” shiraz benches ­– meaning less grapes to the bunch and lower yields overall. Perversely, laughs Gallagher, those loose bunches make the weather-hardy shiraz even more disease resistant.

A couple of days before the rain, Gallagher’s chardonnay, destined for sparkling wine, looked in beautiful condition. But he now waits anxiously for the rain to end. He says pinot noir for bubbly, harvested from Pankhurst vineyard, Hall, before the rain was spectacular.

At Long Rail Gully, Murrumbateman, Garry Parker, described a wait-and-see, edgy situation. Until the rain, everything appeared perfect, with good yields expected for all varieties – except shiraz, because of its small bunches. “Richard [Garry’s son and winemaker] said pinot gris and riesling will be the first we pick. He looked at them in fear and trepidation, but so far they’re unaffected by the rain”, says Garry.

With both white varieties close to ripening, a seven-day withholding period means no more spraying, even if disease appears, says Parker

At Jeir Creek, Murrumbateman, Rob Howell reports a savage hailstorm two weeks before the rain arrived ripping through several vineyards. It wiped out a quarter of Jeir Creek’s grapes and damaged the neighbouring Ravensworth (Bryan and Jocelyn Martin), Dark Horse (Carpenter family, Lark Hill) and Nanima (Wayne and Jennie Fischer) vineyards.

After the hail, Howell “went into drying-out damaged berry mode. But the rain’s not helping now”, says Howell. He expects to harvest chardonnay and pinot noir for sparkling wine immediately after the rain and says overall fruit quality appears very high. “Viogner looks superb, shiraz is down and cabernet’s looking good, because of its thick skin”, Howell says.

Winemaker Alex McKay (Collector and Bourke Street brands), owns no vineyards but sources grapes from growers across the district. He’s distinctly upbeat about the vintage, despite some similarities with last year’s cool, wet conditions.

He recalls lots of nervousness about the outcome this time last year. But despite some disease-related crop losses, Canberra enjoyed a fantastic vintage. McKay reports, “better disease control this year, with very little botrytis [botrytis cinerea, a destructive fungus] and vineyards still looking very clean”. He attributes lower expected yields across the district in 2012 to the lasting effect of last year’s wet conditions.

To date he sees, “Excellent vine health and berry size, very good flavour building, still natural acids and attractive tannins developing in the reds”. He expects to harvest Rhone Valley white varieties (the viognier looking very good) late in the first week of March and shiraz from mid March. He says Nick O’Leary’s began picking very good riesling in mid to late February.

McKay believes the healthy vines should resist disease pressures from the present rain. He believes mildew presents a greater risk earlier in the season as new foliage emerges and that botrytis outbreaks are more likely.

Heavy rain followed by warm weather also presents a risk of berry split as vines suck up water and grapes swell. But McKay believes the risk to be lower this year thanks to previously well-watered vines.

Jennie Mooney, an owner of Capital Wines and its Kyeema Vineyard, Murrumbateman also sees berry split as less likely this year. She says, “In 2010 we came out of drought into a massive downpour, followed by hot sun. The vines transpired heavily, took up water and the berries split”.

But as insurance this year, says Mooney, husband Mark encouraged weed growth under the vines. When the rain stops they expect the weeds to compete with the vines, limiting water uptake and risk of berry split.

Mooney says, “The fruit’s a bit like 2011 – flavours arriving at low Baumes [sugar content] with high acidity. Merlot’s the best Mark’s ever tasted. Merlot likes having its feet wet”.

Despite the rain and risk it poses, Mooney remains, “Nervously hopeful”. She says it’s a difficult year and in the end success will get down to good vineyard management. At Kyeema, she says, “we’ve done lots of canopy work, with disease management ongoing, all season”.

At Brindabella Hills, Hall (Canberra’s lowest vineyards), winemaker Brian Sinclair reports normal crops, even of shiraz, and “incredibly good” quality across the varieties. He says, “I haven’t seen sauvignon blanc or riesling looking as good as it is. It’s ideal. The riesling has no disease, a terrific canopy and no sunburn”. Sinclair believes, “things should progress well” despite the rain.

Up on the northern slopes of Mount Majura, Frank van de Loo reports 9.5 tonnes of a projected 52-tonne harvest safely in tanks. Mainly chardonnay and pinot noir for sparkling, van de Loo describes it as, “the best yet after five years’ experience [with sparkling material]”.

He says the cool season is producing light crops with exciting flavours and aromatics, arriving at low sugar levels. He rated one batch of chardonnay, pickable at a low 10.5–11 Baume – very rare in Canberra’s climate – and ripe-tasting riesling at 10 Baume. The red varieties, however, remain some weeks off.

Van de Loo rates berry split as the main risk, saying, “I’m worried about the duration rather the quantity [of rain]. If the vines are too wet for too long the berries could split”.

Jim Lumbers of Lerida Estate, Lake George, said “It was picture perfect until today”, “and now it looks like a re-run of 2011 – a ground hog day vintage”. Nevertheless, expects the early varieties to be fine – pinot noir for rose, pinot gris and chardonnay, despite “massive acids”.

He still sees the possibility of the vintage turning out really well. But even if disease takes it toll, Lerida has sorting tables. This allows us to take the hit of lower quantity while keeping our quality”.

Vineyard high up on the Lake George escarpment, opposite Bungendore, live in a different climate than most of Canberra’s other vineyards – some 300 metres higher than Hall, 200 metres higher than Murrumbateman, and more than 100 metres above Mount Majura and Lake George.

At Lark Hill vintage is still six weeks away, with the whites just through veraison [where the berries begin to soften] and the only red, pinot noir, just half way through.

Winemaker Chris Carpenter says 2012 may end up as the coolest on record at Lark Hill, having dipped below 1989, the previous coldest – though unlikely to match 1989’s 1000mm rainfall for the growing season.

He foresees a late vintage with intense fruit flavours and high acidity across the district. He wonders aloud what makers will do with high levels of malic acid in chardonnay – as fashion, in recent years, moved away from the secondary fermentation (malo-lactic) that reduced it, to more austere, high-acid styles.

At present, he says, Lark Hill remains disease free with good crop levels. The Carpenter’s recently acquire Dark Horse vineyard at Murrumbateman, however, lost half its crop to the recent hailstorm.

It smashed fruit on the vine and defoliated one side, impairing their ability to ripen the remaining fruit”, says Carpenter. To encourage new leaves, the Carpenters have added nutrition and intend to bunch-thin if necessary. Bunch thinning matches the fruit load to the ripening ability of the foliage.

Carpenter says Lark Hill began trialling biological control of botrytis this year – spraying vines with bacteria that compete with the fungus. In theory, supported by producer trials, says Carpenter, the bacteria become established, providing long-term protection.

While that offers hope for the future, Canberra vignerons keep an anxious eye on the weather and remain hopeful of healthy crops in the weeks ahead.

It seemed like forty days and nights, but after almost a week the deluge finally ceased on Sunday 4 March. On Monday 5 March, Canberra vignerons woke to a mild, mainly sunny day.

At Four Winds Vineyard, Murrumbateman, John Collingwood harvested riesling, anxious to beat an outbreak of botrytis. “It was just starting”, he said. But in the end he cut out only about five per cent, delivering 18 healthy tonnes (a normal-sized harvest) to winemaking brother-in-law, Bill Crowe.

Crowe says the riesling’s looking pretty good, with high acidity and even lower sugar than last year’s fruit.

While the rain slowed grape development down, Collingwood remains hopeful of a good red harvest in three to four weeks. He says there’s a little botrytis in the denser bunches, so success depends on the weather. Warm, dry weather should contain the fungus; but it could get running if it rains.

Sangiovese shows a little more fruit split than shiraz, says Collingwood. But the loose, open shiraz bunches are proving resilient. Tough-skinned cabernet looks in good condition, he says, and merlot’s travelling well.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 14 March 2012 in The Canberra Times and The Sydney Morning Herald

Is it worth talking up Canberra cabernet?

Is Ken Helm pushing it up hill? Or does cabernet really have a future in Canberra? I mean not just as a nice wine – but in the sense, as Helm sees it, that it might snap at the heals of our regional top dog, shiraz?

Releasing his 2009 vintage recently, Helm wrote, “Cabernet sauvignon in the Canberra District has suffered from a myth that it is too cold to ripen” – then lists a string of accolades, some more credible than others, stretching back to 1983.

Helm cabernet’s run of gold medals and trophies at the Cowra, Sydney, Hobart and Cool Climate wine shows began in1983 but ended in 1998 – about the time as shiraz stuck its head up (though, this is probably a coincidence).

Thereafter, the third-party praise on Helm’s list comes mainly through individual critics, including Australia’s James Halliday and Nick Stock and America’s Robert M. Parker. But the praise peaks with Halliday’s 94/100 for Helm Premium Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 (the score subsequently declined to 89 for the 2006 vintage).

Putting this in perspective, Halliday gave higher scores to several Canberra shirazes from the 2008 vintage. These included 95, 96, and 97 for three different Clonakilla wines, 96 for Collector Reserve, 95s for Lerida Estate, Capital Hill Kyeema Vineyard Reserve and Collector Marked Tree, and 94 for Nick O’Leary 2008.

And if we look to the regional show, we see little support for cabernet. Between 1997 and 2011 the trophy for champion wine of show was awarded to a Canberra shiraz on 10 occasions. Indeed, in 14 years, only two non-shiraz wines won the prize – a chardonnay from Orange in 1997 and Helm Premium Riesling 2008 in 2009 (shared with a shiraz from Hilltops). Cabernet simply hasn’t had a look in at the top level.

After judging a couple of lacklustre cabernet classes in the 2011 show, the judges, led by sommelier Ben Edwards, commented, “Obviously cabernet and family represents significant viticultural challenges in the region, so sensitive management of tannin/extraction is paramount. The top wines showed this”.

They’re basically saying it’s difficult to ripen cabernet in Canberra, but the top wines show that it’s possible. That cabernet requires more heat than shiraz to ripen isn’t in dispute.

In Wine, Terroir and Climate Change, John Gladstones classifies the world’s best-known wine grape varieties into maturity groups, based on degree days (a measure of total heat received during the growing season).

Gladstones derives his classification from a number of studies published between 1857 and 1997. At 1,260 degree days, shiraz sits one classification below cabernet, which requires 1,380 degree days to ripen. However, much of Canberra achieves more than 1,380 degree days in a season.

But total heat doesn’t tell the full story. The day-night temperature range also affects grape development and flavour. And when we look at great cabernet regions and great shiraz regions we see a marked contrast. This might explain why cabernet so demonstrably underperforms shiraz in Canberra.

Bordeaux, the home of cabernet, sits on the Dordogne estuary. It’s a true maritime climate – just like those of Margaret River and Coonawarra, Australia’s leading cabernet regions. The diurnal temperature ranges in theses areas, during the ripening period, is comparatively low.

Shiraz, on the other hand, reaches its peak (in the old world) in the northern Rhone Valley’s continental climate, where the diurnal temperature range is comparatively wide – like Canberra’s.

Gladstones believes that “relatively constant, intermediate temperatures during ripening specifically favour the biochemical processes of colour/flavour/aroma development of the berries”. He concludes that “the narrower the range of variation about a given mean or average ripening temperature, the greater the great flavour, aroma and pigmentation will be at a given time of ripening”.

That view intersects nicely with the great wines of Bordeaux, Margaret River and Coonawarra – and points towards the difficulty of getting cabernet just right in Canberra’s continental client. (But it also sits at odds with the outstanding shirazes we make!).

My own experience from years of wine show judging, private tastings and social drinking is that Canberra’s best shirazes rate with the best in Australia. Our cabernets, on the other hand, simply don’t compare, to date, with the country’s best. As well, our average shiraz tastes better than our average cabernet.

But that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t make cabernet or, like Ken Helm, tackle the obstacles and shoot for the stars. The woods would be awfully quiet if the only birds that sang were those that sang best.

The fact is that Canberra makes many decent cabernets. And our region – ranging from 500 metres above sea level to almost 900 metres – offers a wide climatic range for anyone willing to experiment with cabernet or any other variety in the future.

Remember, too, that other revered shiraz regions – including the Barossa, McLaren Vale and the Clare Valley – make very good cabernet and have done so successfully for 150 years.

These will never be great regional specialties. But, like Canberra cabernet, they enjoy a following, they offer a different flavour and structure from shiraz and they’re here to stay.

While the odds appear stacked against Helm, he’s made notable progress in recent years, both viticulturally with grower Al Lustenberger and fine-tuning in the winery, particularly in regard to oak maturation.

There’s always an exception to a rule. And if anyone can be the exception, it’s Helm. People once pooh-poohed the idea of cabernet in Tasmania. But then along came Peter Althaus and Domaine A’s extraordinary wines. Perhaps Canberra can have a Domaine B.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 29 February 2012 in The Canberra Times

Gallagher marks ten years of Canberra shiraz

These days Canberra and shiraz is a no-brainer for aspiring vignerons. It’s our most successful grape variety thanks, initially, to Clonakilla, but now thoroughly bedded down across the district.

But when Greg and Libby Gallagher planted shiraz at Murrumbateman in 1995, Canberra’s reputation for fine wine was a fraction of what it is now – and shiraz had barely emerged as a contender for top spot.

Clonakilla founder, Dr John Kirk, included shiraz among the many varieties he planted in the early 1970s. But until 1990 it joined cabernet sauvignon in the blending vat. That impressive first vintage won two gold medals and two trophies – guaranteeing shiraz a solo role in future Clonakilla vintages. Well, almost.

Four years earlier, Kirk and his son Jeremy had planted viognier – a Rhone Valley white variety. They believed it suited the climate and would a point of difference in the market.

Then, in 1991 while the second Clonakilla shiraz lay in barrel, Melbourne-based Tim Kirk, having completed his Diploma of Education, headed off to France where I’d organised an appointment for him with Marcel Guigal, one of the Rhone’s great winemakers.

There he tasted Guigal’s stunning single vineyard Cote-Roties (blends of shiraz and viognier): the 1988 vintages of La Mouline and La Landonne from barrel and the 1987 La Turque from bottle.

Tim described the meeting and tasting as a “transforming moment”. “Transfixed and delighted” by the perfume and sheer dimension of Guigal’s wines, he decided, “I’ve got to get this shiraz-viognier thing going back home”.

From the 1992 vintage Tim and John Kirk included viognier in the blend in varying proportions: starting at one per cent each in 1992 and 1993, rising to four per cent in 1994, peaking at ten per cent in 1995 and 1996, then falling back to smaller percentages thereafter.

Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier’s reputation grew rapidly, and by early in the new century had won acclaim from leading international critics, including the USA’s Robert M. Parker and UK’s Jancis Robinson. But when the Gallaghers planted shiraz in 1995, the Kirks had barely begun the shiraz viognier journey. Indeed, it would be another two years before Tim Kirk from Melbourne to Canberra to run Clonakilla full time.

The Kirks came to shiraz through trial and error. But the Victorian based Gallaghers put Canberra and shiraz together “after doing climatic data searches for about two years, looking for the best area to grow shiraz”, says their website.

They purchased land at Murrumbateman and in 1995, with Greg still making wine for Taltarni in central Victoria, established a vineyard overlooking the Murrumbidgee Valley and Brindabellas. They believed this site would produce the elegant, multi-layered shiraz they had in mind.

As the vines grew, Greg continued with Taltarni until 1998, then from 1999 to 2004 trained young winemakers at Charles Sturt University, Wagga. During this period he also established Canberra Winemakers, in partnership with Rob and Kay Howell of Jeir Creek. The business continues to make wine at Jeir Creek for growers in and around Canberra.

As their vineyard matured, the Gallaghers launched their own label, making the wines at Jeir Creek. They established a cellar door at the vineyard, on Dog Trap Road, and offered their own delicious cheeses, made on site by Libby (a skill she learned at Charles Sturt Uni).

Greg’s expertise with sparkling wine, developed at Taltarni, opened a unique opportunity, first for Canberra Winemakers, then for the Gallaghers. Initially, Canberra Winemakers prepared base wines for others to turn into bubblies. But Gallagher, seeing the opportunity to complete the process, established a sparkling cellar adjacent to his cellar door.

The cellar, with two computerised gyro palates and bottling line, allows Gallagher to clarify bottles of sparkling wine following secondary fermentation, top them up and seal the bottles for market.

The Gallaghers currently offers two bottle-fermented sparklers under their own label – Duet Pinot Noir Chardonnay NV (pinot from Mount Majura Vineyard, chardonnay from Gallagher vineyard) and Blanc de Blanc 2007 (all from Gallagher vineyard).

These are both fine, delicate wines – the sort you can make only if all the bits line up: vineyard management, harvest timing, fruit handling, winemaking, maturation and finishing off. Clearly, it’s a valuable skill for Canberra to have. But it’s not the cutting edge stuff we see from much cooler areas like Tasmania. So, good as they are, bubblies won’t put Canberra on the wine map. That role remains principally with shiraz – which is were this story started.

The Gallaghers came to Canberra for shiraz and, indeed, it became the district hero. And just four years after establishing their shiraz vines – they finished planting on their 16th wedding anniversary – Greg made the first wine from them.

1999 was the year BRL Hardy trucked grapes from South Australia to help Canberra vignerons wiped out by the October 1998 frost. A mass of cold air had moved up from Antarctica on a wide front, nipping vines in the bud across Victoria, South Australia and southern New South Wales.

The Gallaghers lost all but three tonnes of their anticipated 20 tonne shiraz crop. But in a recent ten-year retrospective of Gallagher shirazes, the 1999 drank beautifully – to my tasted the best of the older wines, and on a par with the vibrant 2006, my pick of the younger vintages.

The 1999 stood out for its amazingly youthful colour, round, juicy, mellow, maturing fruit flavours and soft tannins – probably very much the style the Gallaghers hoped for when they came to Canberra.

The browning 2000 vintage hadn’t held up nearly so well. But the 2001, while mature, still showed maturing plummy, spicy varietal flavours, in a slightly leaner style than the 1999.

The 2002 looked good, 2003 combined both prune-like over-ripe flavours and a touch of greenness, and the 2005 seemed a touch tart in the finish. The 2004 failed to please. But the 2006, 2007 and 2008 all looked good in their own ways.

While neither completely young, nor mature, the 2006 showed a tremendous vitality and intensity of dark berry and spice flavours with a supple mid palate and lovely soft tannins.

While 2007 lacked the intensity and weight of the 2006, it remains vibrant and fresh with a delicious interplay between the fruit and spicy oak. The current release 2008 seems fuller and riper again even than the 2006 ­– a big wine in the medium-bodied Canberra style.

The 1999 and later vintages, especially 2006, show that the Gallaghers backed the right variety in shiraz and when they get it right, it’s of a very high calibre. They didn’t plant our other district specialty, riesling. But Greg makes a brilliant riesling using fruit from the Four Winds Vineyard (see a full review next week).

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 22 February 2012 in The Canberra Times

Bay of Fires — the little winery that could

This is the story of the little winery that weathered the storm of the great, shrinking, Hardy empire – and emerged as one of Australia’s leading producers of chardonnay and pinots noir and gris.

Bay of Fires, at Pipers River Tasmania, grew out of BRL Hardy’s quest for great sparkling wine. Sparkling specialist, Ed Carr, searched all the likely cool growing sites in south-eastern Australia – including nearby Tumbarumba, the Adelaide Hills, the coldest reaches of the Yarra Valley and further south, in Tasmania.

All of those places produced pinot noir and chardonnay, and even small amounts of pinot meunier, suited to delicate, flavoursome sparkling wines. But nothing equalled the fruit from Tasmania.

This was a period of great expansion for BRL Hardy, buoyed by booming exports, and, for a time, a shortage of suitable grapes. During the boom, the price of wine assets ballooned, peaking in 2003 when Constellation Brands USA bought publicly listed Hardys for $1.9 billion.

As wine assets deflated later in the decade, Constellation offloaded assets, including the historic Leasingham Winery and several vineyards in the Clare Valley and the massive Stonehaven winery on the Limestone Coast. Finally, in February 2011 it sold an 80 per cent stake in the business to Champ Private Equity for $290 million – crystallising a massive loss on its original investment.

Winemaker Fran Austin and the crew at Bay of Fires (founded 2002) kept their heads down during the crisis. They retained their 22-hectare vineyard adjacent to the winery. And under Ed Carr’s supervision they continued making table and sparkling wine components from across Tasmania.

The network of Tasmanian vineyards established by Carr, originally for sparkling wine, had pretty quickly contributed to the company’s best multi-region table wines – notably Hardy’s flagship white, Eileen Hardy Chardonnay. That Tasmania  contributed the major component to one of Australia’s finest whites remained virtually unknown.

The Bay of Fires label, however, provided a face for the Tasmanian wines. And the release of the magnificent 2009 pinot noir, a trophy winner at Canberra’s 2010 National Wine Show of Australia, left no doubt about where the state’s strength lay.

By this time, little known even in the trade, the company had developed a flagship pinot noir under the Eileen Hardy label – made at Bay of Fires but transferred to headquarters in Reynella, South Australia. It was lost in the turmoil of Constellation’s final years. But we’ll see it before too long.

Fran Austin recently left Bay of Fires, handing the winemaking over to Peter Dredge and his assistant, Karl Schultz. They work closely with Ed Carr and Carr’s boss, Paul Lapsley, chief winemaker for the Accolade group.

Accolade’s presence in Tasmania – driven by a wide search for Australia’s best chardonnay and pinot noir (whether for table or sparkling wine) – lends practical support to the contentious argument that high latitude, near sea level, delivers better wine quality than high altitude. Dr John Gladstone reaches a similar conclusion in Wine, Terroir and Climate Change (Wakefield Press, South Australia, 2011).

Whatever the merits of the argument, the current Bay of Fires wines reveal just how at home chardonnay and pinots noir and gris are in a variety of sites around Tasmania. They also reveal an emerging mastery of winemaking that brings out the best in these varieties. That these remain largely undiscovered wines is reflected in the comparatively modest prices for wines of this calibre.

Bay of Fires Pinot Gris 2011 $24.69–$36.50
Fruit source: Lower Derwent 40 per cent; Coal River Valley 39 per cent; Upper Derwent 21 per cent.
This is the best Australian pinot gris I’ve tasted – lively and fresh with intense pear-like varietal aroma and flavour, backed by a rich, silky texture. Winemaker Peter Dredge attributes the rich texture to a component of the wine undergoing wild-yeast ferment in older oak barrels.

Bay of Fires Chardonnay 2009 $29.95–$40.50
Fruit source: Pipers River 31 per cent; East Coast 29 per cent; Coal River Valley 40 per cent.
The age reflects slow sales rather than a marketing plan. But it’s a plus in this sensational wine. Succulent, racy, lemony acidity pulls the many flavour components together in this full-bodied, taut, deeply layered, richly textured, barrel-fermented dry white wine. Should develop well for many more years.

Bay of Fires Pinot Noir 2010 $29.45–$42.99
Fruit source: Derwent Valley 55 per cent; East Coast 30 per cent; Coal River Valley 15 per cent.
This fairly deeply coloured pinot reveals quite a lot of the pinot flavour and aroma spectrum. A light, “stalky” overlay suggests whole bunches, including stems, in the ferment. Behind that comes aromatic waves of varietal fruit characters, ranging from strawberry to plum – adding up to what can only be called “pinosity”. The rich, supple, elegant, tightly structured palate reflects the aroma.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2012
First published 15 February 2012 in The Canberra Times