Category Archives: Wine review

Wine review — Toi Toi, Yalumba and Pikes

Toi Toi Central Otago Clutha Pinot Noir 2012 $15.90–$18
Central Otago’s reputation for pinot noir stems largely from higher priced classics like those made by Felton Road. But the growing production of this cool region at 45 degrees south means not every drop wins a place on the top shelf. Toi Toi, made intentionally for this modest (for pinot) price, offers terrific value. The colour’s pale (not unusual for pinot) but the palate presents convincing, and delicious, red-berry varietal flavour, supported by fine, firm tannins and brisk acidity. It’s a drink-now style. Like sauvignon blanc before it, New Zealand pinot noir is now drives the rapid growth of pinot noir consumption in Australia.

Yalumba Old Bush Vine Barossa Grenache 2012 $17.09–$21.95
Spain and Sardinia both have plausible historic claims to being home of grenache (known as garnacha in Spain; cannonau in Sardinia), writes Jancis Robinson in Wine Grapes – A Complete Guide to 1368 vine varieties, including their origins and flavours (Allen Lane, 2012). However, writes Robinson, genetic evidence points to Spain as the birthplace. Grenache was documented in Spain in 1513 and Sardinia in 1549. It arrived in France in the late eighteenth century and in Australia in the first half of the nineteenth. Yalumba’s fine example, made from old vines pruned as individual bushes, gives a delicious, earthy, savoury expression of the variety built on pure, fruity varietal flavour.

Pikes Clare Valley Traditionale Riesling 2013 $16.85–$23
Judges at Canberra’s International Riesling Challenge 2013 rated Pikes Traditionale Riesling 2013 as the best of 371 Australian rieslings in the competition. The wine outscored rieslings, some of them far pricier, from more than 35 Australian regions. Pike’s victory underlines the tremendous value and drinking pleasure provided by Australia’s best dry rieslings. A blend of fruit from three Clare Valley sub-regions – Polish Hill River, Watervale and Sevenhill – the 2013 is highly aromatic with juicy, mouth-filling citrusy varietal flavours and thrilling, crisp acidity. It’s dry and weighs in at just 11.5 per cent alcohol.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 24 November 2013 in the Canberra Times

 

Wine review — Oakridge, Wilson, Soumah, Larry Cherubino Ad Hoc, Penny’s Hill and Tahbilk

Oakridge Local Vineyard Series Lusatia Park Chardonnay 2012 $38
Lusatia Park vineyard, Woori Yallock, Yarra Valley, Victoria
David Bicknell makes a number of Oakridge chardonnays reflecting the fruit qualities of various individual Yarra Valley vineyards. Bicknell’s Lusatia Park wine, from a Shelmerdine family vineyard at Woori Yallock, reveals the intense but elegant character derived from their elevated, cool site. Bicknell says the fruit was handpicked and whole-bunch pressed direct to 500-litre French oak barrels for spontaneous fermentation. This method retains the delicacy of the fruit, but also contributes to the aroma, flavour and texture of the wine. The excellent vintage delivered a delightful wine – tightly structured and restrained, but mouth wateringly delicious, featuring grapefruit- and white-peach-like varietal flavours.

Wilson DJW Riesling 2013 $24
DJW vineyard, Polish Hill River, Clare Valley, South Australia
Daniel Wilson established the DJW vineyard in 1997 and made the first wine from it in 1997. He says it’s on a higher, more fertile site than the original Wilson vineyard his father planted decades earlier and makes a softer, earlier drinking style. In 2013 that means a pure, loveable riesling of a very high calibre. The colour’s pale and the aroma, while a little coy, offers hints of lime-like varietal character. The lime comes through irresistibly on the fine-textured, dazzling fresh palate.

Soumah Savarro 2013 $26
Yarra Valley, Victoria
The Butcher family owns vineyards in the Gruyere-Coldstream sub-region of the Yarra Valley and created the acronym Soumah (from “south of Maroondah Highway”) as its brand name. Like many other Australian vignerons, the Butchers planted Spain’s albarino only to find the vine had been misidentified and was, in fact, savagnin (aka traminer, and several other names). The Butchers, however, opted for “savarro”. They hand pick the fruit, handle it gently and ferment it in stainless steel to preserve its purity. The 2013 appeals strongly for its lively, savoury, citrusy, tangy, melon-rind-like vitality.

Larry Cherubino Ad Hoc Middle of Everywhere Shiraz 2012 $19–21
Frankland River, Great Southern, Western Australia
Larry Cherubino sourced fruit for Ad Hoc from various sites in Western Australia’s Frankland River region – a distinct part of the much larger Great Southern wine zone. Vines endure heat pushing down from the continent, then benefit from cool afternoon and evening air flowing up from the cold oceans to the south. The unique conditions produce generously flavoured, medium bodied red wines. In Ad Hoc we enjoy ripe, juicy, blueberry-like flavours, cut with an attractive savouriness, on a soft, smooth seductive palate.

Penny’s Hill The Experiment Grenache 2011 $22–$30
Penny’s Hill vineyard, McLaren Vale, South Australia
Back in 1996, the folks at Penny’s Hill trained 18 rows of century-old, previously bush-pruned grenache vines to trellises. The venerable old vines clearly survived their retraining and subsequently made this distinctive dry red. Australian grenache varies enormously in style from floral and confection-like to earthy–savoury. This is more in the latter style. It’s underpinned by very ripe black-cherry-like fruit flavour, interwoven with earthy and savoury characters, partly derived from oak maturation. The savouriness and grippy, rustic tannin make a good match for tart and savoury food – tappas, pizza, olives, anchovy and the like.

Tahbilk Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 $17–$24
Tahbilk vineyard, Nagambie Lakes, Victoria
Tahbilk’s long-lived, medium bodied cabernet comes with a mother load of tannins – sturdy, grippy tannins that permeate the underlying fruit flavours, giving a satisfying, chewy texture. In the 2010 vintage, those tannins seem even more prominent than usual. Though the underlying fruit flavour provides an offsetting sweetness, tannin defines Tahbilk cabernet and account in large part for its great longevity. Serve the wine with juicy, pink lamb or beef, though, and the protein strips away the tannin to reveal the ripe, blackcurrant-like varietal flavour.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 20 November 2013 in the Canberra Times

 

Wine review — The Winesmiths, Mad Fish and Dopff au Moulin

The Winesmiths South Australia Chardonnay 2-litre cask $18.99
In July, Samuel Smith and Son, an arm of Robert Hill Smith’s Yalumba group, launched this new upmarket range of wine casks – pinot grigio, chardonnay, tempranillo and shiraz. The cask, made from a claimed 75 per cent recyclable goods and 13 per cent the carbon footprint of wine bottle, has a decidedly wholesome, wholemeal appearance. The tempranillo appealed for its rich fruit and rustic tannins. The chardonnay, too, slips down pleasantly. It’s full-bodied and richly textured with clean, fresh, peachy varietal flavour.

Mad Fish Western Australia Shiraz 2010 $14–$18
Mad Fish is the entry-level brand of Western Australia’s Burch Family Wines. The family owns wineries in Margaret River and Denmark in the state’s south, where it produces wines under the Howard Park and Mad Fish labels, and the Australian wines in its Australian–French joint venture, Marchand and Burch. As we so often see with Australian top-end producers, quality trickles all the way down the line – meaning very high quality in Mad Fish shiraz. Sourced from Great Southern and Margaret River, it offers bright, fresh fruity flavours, medium body and gentle, soft tannins for current drinking.

Dopff au Moulin Alsace Pinot Blanc 2011 $12.35–$13
Pinot blanc is the little-known, third face of the pinot vine – the other two being pinot noir and pinot gris (or grigio). It’s an important white variety in Alsace, though on a lesser scale than pinot gris (formerly known there as tokay d’Alsace). They’re hardly recognisable, though, as expressions of the same variety. Alsace pinot gris tends to be unctuous and often a little sweet. Pinot blanc, on the other hand, is leaner, lighter, tighter and made as an aperitif style – with a nice little bite of tannin emphasising the dry finish. Dopff, a good example of pinot blanc, is imported by Woolworths and available in their Dan Murphy outlets.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 17 November 2013 in the Canberra Times

Wine review — Moppity Vineyards, Oakridge, The Winesmiths, Yalumba and Hahndord Hill

Moppity Vineyards Lock and Key Chardonnay 2012 $17
Coppabella Vineyard, Tumbarumba, NSW
At the 2013 regional show, Lock and Key topped a line up of 24 chardonnays, ultimately winning the trophy as best chardonnay of the show. Wines from Tumbarumba dominated the class, winning all five gold medals. Moppity entered four chardonnays and won four medals – two gold, one silver and one bronze. That humble Lock and Key, the cheapest of the four, topped the class underlines the inherent quality of Tumbarumba chardonnay – and the wine’s greater drink-now appeal when compared to its more austere, slow-evolving cellar mates. Moppity’s Jason Brown says it’s a blend from several blocks on his 70-hectare Coppabella vineyard. He selected fruity components for the blend and fermented 70 per cent of it in stainless steel tanks to preserve freshness. A barrel fermented component added texture and complexity. Nevertheless, it’s a lean, taut, delicious style, reminiscent of ripe, fresh nectarine, liberally doused with grapefruit juice – a thrilling combination.

Moppity Vineyards Chardonnay 2012 $25
Coppabella Vineyard, Tumbarumba, NSW
Judges at the regional show awarded gold medal scores (55.5 and 57 respectively out of 60) to this and its cellar mate, Lock and Key. Both come from Jason and Alicia Brown’s Coppabella vineyards, but offer different expressions of the variety. This one uses fruit selected for its power and intensity – characteristics emphasised by fermentation and maturation of 70 per cent of the blend in oak barrels. Tasting the two side by side, the judges’ preference for the drink-now style of the cheaper wine seems understandable. But the Moppity, I suspect, will blossom after another year or two in bottle.

Oakridge Local Vineyard Series Guerin Vineyard Pinot Noir 2012 $38
Guerin vineyard, Gladysdale, Yarra Valley, Victoria
Winemaker David Bicknell offers two 2012 pinot noirs from the Guerin vineyard. The flagship 864 Block 4 sells for $75. But for half that price this cheaper wine delivers 90 per cent of the quality. That’s the law of diminishing returns for you. Bicknell’s pinots rate among the best in Australia. And he makes quite a pile of them – each fine-tuned to express fruit from various Yarra Valley sites. Of the current single-vineyard releases, Guerin appeals strongly. It brings the pure ripe-berry flavours of pinot, deeply meshed with mouth-watering savouriness, a twist of stalkiness and the great weight and textural richness of really good pinot. A firm tannin backbone completes the picture.

The Winesmiths Tempranillo 2012 $18.99 2-litre wine cask
South Australia

In July, Samuel Smith and Son, an arm of Robert Hill Smith’s Yalumba group, launched this new upmarket range of wine casks – pinot grigio, chardonnay, tempranillo and shiraz. The cask, made from a claimed 75 per cent recyclable goods and 13 per cent the carbon footprint of wine bottle, has a decidedly wholesome, wholemeal appearance. It looks like recycled cardboard. But the wine inside certainly doesn’t taste like it’s been drunk before. This is rich, fresh, fruity tempranillo with a healthy load of mouth-puckering tannin.

Yalumba The Strapper Grenache Shiraz Mataro 2012 $17–$22
Barossa, South Australia
After the leaner, lighter 2011 vintage reviewed in July, The Strapper 2012 returns to its opulent Barossa best. The floral, sweet, enticing aroma of grenache leads to a full, round, juicy palate with the body of shiraz and spicy, tannic character of mataro. It’s a blend of 40 per cent grenache, 35 per cent shiraz and 25 per cent mataro, matured for nine months in a variety of Hungarian and French oak vessels, new and old. The oak built the texture of the wine with inserting oaky flavours.

Hahndorf Hill Winery Gruner Veltliner 2013 $28
Hahndorf Hill vineyard, Adelaide Hills, South Australia
Hahndorf Hill owners Larry Jacobs and Marc Dobson identified a fit between Austria’s late-ripening gruner veltliner and their elevated, continental-climate vineyard site in the Adelaide Hills. Jacobs says the 2013 season provided ideal, slow, ripening conditions. He picked fruit at various ripeness levels, allowed a portion of juice contact with skins (encouraging uptake of tannin), then fermented the juice in various parcels – some in stainless steel with cultured yeast, some in old oak barriques using ambient yeasts. The combination captures the freshness of the fruit but builds in a rich texture, from the barrel-fermented component, and a little tannic tweak to the finish, courtesy of the skin contact. It’s a unique, full-bodied, bright, spicy, savoury dry white of great appeal.

Copright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 13 November 2013 in the Canberra Times and goodfood.com.au

Wine review — Jacob’s Creek, Cherubino Ad Hoc and Wyndham Estate

Jacob’s Creek Riesling 2012 $6.90–$12
In 2012 this wine won silver medals in the Melbourne and Hobart wine shows, then golds in Adelaide and Canberra National Wine Show. In October this year, it won the trophy as best riesling at the Royal Melbourne Wine Show. Winemaker Bernard Hickin says the fruit comes from the Barossa, Eden and Clare Valleys and Langhorne Creek. The combination gives the wine well-defined lime and lemon varietal flavours and a delicious fruit sweetness – though the wine remains crisp and dry with only about three grams a litre of residual sugar (below our taste threshold). This is an extraordinarily good wine at the price.

Cherubino Ad Hoc Middle of Everywhere
Frankland River Shiraz 2012 $19–$21

Larry Cherubino sourced fruit for this wine from various sites in Western Australia’s Frankland River region – a distinct part of the much larger Great Southern wine zone. Vines endure some of the heat pushing down from the continent, but also benefit from cool afternoon and evening air flowing up from the cold oceans to the south. The unique conditions produce generously flavoured, medium bodied red wines. In Ad Hoc we enjoy ripe, jui, blueberry-like flavours, cut with an attractive savouriness, on a soft, smooth seductive palate.

Wyndham Estate Bin 555 Langhorne Creek Shiraz 2012 $10.45–$15
Like Jacob’s Creek reviewed above, Wyndham Estate is a brand of France’s Pernod-Ricard. The company’s vast vineyard at Langhorne, established principally for the global Jacob’s Creek brand, provides the fruit for this delicious shiraz. Winemaker Steve Meyer, says he blended Bin 555 Shiraz 2012 using fruit from six different blocks on the vineyard. It shows the ripe, even, generous flavours of the vintage and the full, rich character of Langhorne Creek shiraz. This is one of Australia’s outstanding wine regions and the consumer’s friend when it makes reds of this quality at such a modest price.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 10 November 2013 in the Canberra Times

Wine review – Tim Smith, Clonakilla, Mad Fish, Coldstream Hills, Wilson and Taittinger

Tim Smith Wines Shiraz 2012 $36
Barossa Valley, South Australia
Wine judges and critics appear to have moved well ahead of wider public tasted in their support of leaner, elegant cool-climate shirazes. Time and again at tastings I see people opting for the riper, fleshier styles from warm areas – particularly the Barossa and McLaren Vale. Tim Smith’s is a succulent example of the latter style. It’s irresistibly, ripe and fleshy – so easy to drink now, yet with years of cellaring ahead. Tim Smith writes, “I source my shiraz grapes from about six vineyards… Vine age is +100 years for the oldest parcel, with the youngest parcel being about 20 years of age”.

Clonakilla Hilltops Shiraz 2012 $28–$32
Hilltops, NSW
Heavy rain towards the end of February 2012 destroyed large volumes of ripe, or near ripe grapes in Canberra and surrounding districts. Clonakilla lost much of its Canberra fruit in the event. But, says Tim Kirk, they harvested most of their fruit from the Hilltops region (around Young, NSW), the day before the 200mm deluge arrived. The result is a delightfully rich red combining ripe, dark-cherry flavours with the spice and touch of black pepper we see from cooler areas. The wine’s medium bodied and shows the Clonakilla signature of great harmony and silky, juicy mid palate. Judges awarded it a bronze medal regional show, but I rate it more highly.

Mad Fish Gold Turtle Chardonnay 2012 $14.25–$15
Margaret River, Western Australia
A mad fish and a gold turtle seem unlikely companions in a wine name. But the wine, from Jeff and Amy Burch’s Howard Park Winery, Margaret River, offers extraordinarily good drinking at a bargain price. Sourced from the Wilyabrup and Karridale sub-regions, Gold Turtle Chardonnay offers bright, fresh nectarine-like varietal flavour with lively acidity and a rich texture derived from a natural fermentation in barrel and extended maturation on yeast lees. The screw cap on wines of this calibre enables reliable cellaring for perhaps five years from vintage.

Coldstream Hills Rising Vineyard Chardonnay 2012 $42–$45
Rising vineyard, Yarra Valley, Victoria
Coldstream Hills, now part of Treasury Wine Estates, produces several Yarra Valley chardonnays – a general blend, a “reserve” version and, in 2012, two single-vineyard wines, “Deer Farm Vineyard” and “Rising Vineyard”. The latter demonstrates the symbiotic relationship between top-notch chardonnay and oak. Winemaker Andrew Fleming fermented then matured the wine win in French oak – 60 per cent of it new. That’s a high proportion and works only if the fruit is up to it and the oak exactly right. It’s a beautiful wine, seamlessly integrating intense, vibrant nectarine-like varietal flavours with spicy oak and all the subtle textural and flavour nuances derived from contact with the barrels and yeast lees.

Wilson Watervale Riesling 2013 $19
Wilson vineyard, Watervale, Clare Valley, South Australia
John Wilson made wines originally from the Clare Valley’s Polish Hill River sub-region. He later sourced fruit, as well, from Watervale, towards the valley’s southern end. Wilson’s son Daniel now makes several Clare rieslings, including this full-flavoured, finely textured version. The mid-lemon colour and full, upfront flavour make attractive current drinking, though the wine should evolve well for three or four years.

Champagne Taittinger Brut Reserve NV $50–$60
Champagne, France
With a little more chardonnay in the blend than most NV’s (40 per cent versus about 33 – the remainder pinot noir and pinot meunier), good old Taitts giggles on the light and cheery side of Champagne, with seemingly little lees-aged character. Nevertheless, it’s a lovely, delicate aperitif style with the lightness of chardonnay and yummy brioche-like nuances of pinot meunier, the lesser of the two pinots, but indispensable nevertheless. Pinot meunier tends to fill the frost-prone dips in the Champagne region and is more fruitful than pinot noir in this situation as it buds later, giving it better odds of missing the chill. As wine, it matures earlier than pinot noir, thus fleshing out the mid palate of younger Champagnes.

Copyright Chris Shanahan 2013
First published  November 2013 in the Canberra Times and goodfood.com.au

 

Wine review — Redbank, Turkey Flat and Brookland Valley

Redbank The Long Paddock Victoria Shiraz 2012 $9.50–$13
Redbank won’t reveal exactly which parts of Victoria this attractive blend comes from. But even at the price, there’s no doubting it includes very good material from high-quality producing regions. Its fragrant, ripe and supple, with medium body and spicy, peppery notes derived from cool climate components of the wine. The winemakers added sangiovese to the blend (six per cent of the total) – injecting savour and grip to the otherwise soft tannins. The wine is made for current drinking, not cellaring. Redbank is a Victorian based brand belonging to the Hill-Smith family’s Yalumba group.

Turkey Flat Butchers Block Barossa Valley White 2012 $19.5–$22
This white style seems well suited to the warm, dry Barossa Valley. Made from three Rhone Valley varieties, marsanne, roussanne and viognier, Butcher’s Block offers texture and savouriness rather than the aromatics and fruitiness cooler regions do better. Christie Schulz polished the style over the years, treating each of the components separately, including skin contact for the viognier, early picking for the marsanne and later picking and whole bunch pressing for the roussanne – with 50 per cent of the blend matured in oak. It’s a full-bodied, richly textured dry white with subtle, underlying nectarine and apricot-like flavours.

Brookland Valley Unison Margaret River Cabernet Sauvignon 2011 $17–$20
I tasted Brookland Valley alongside Chateau Semeillan Mazeau, a cabernet blend from Bordeaux, selling at double the price. The difference seems partly a question of style and not just one of quality. The French red offered good fruit, tightly bound up in tannin – thus putting texture and structure on an equal footing with that fruit. Brookland Valley, on the other hand puts varietal fruit to the fore – both in the sweet aroma and juicy vibrance of the palate. Tannin supports the fruit but without adding depth or length. It offers simple, fruity drink-now pleasure at a fair price

Copyright Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 3 November 2013 in the Canberra Times

Wine review – Ravensworth, Forbes and Forbes, Majella, Printhie, West Cape Howe and Wynns Coonawarra Estate

Ravensworth Riesling 2013 $20
Murrumbateman, Canberra District, NSW
Bryan and Jocelyn Martin’s 2013 riesling swept all competitors aside at the recent Canberra and region show. It won the top gold medal in the 2013 riesling class, then cleaned up in the taste offs, winning trophies as the show’s best riesling, best white wine and best wine. A few weeks later it won another gold medal plus a trophy as best Canberra riesling at the Canberra International Riesling Challenge. Ravensworth shows the tight structure and acidic backbone of Canberra riesling, with pure, intense, fresh citrus varietal flavour and sufficient mid-palate flesh to offset the gripping acidity. Should drink well for the next decade.

Forbes and Forbes Riesling 2012 $20
Woodman vineyard, Springton, Eden Valley, South Australia
A year older and a shade darker in colour, Forbes and Forbes 2012 offers an interesting style contrast to Ravensworth 2013. They’re both gold medallists from their respective regional shows and national events. They’re of a similar alcohol content. Both contain three grams per litre of residual sugar – undetectable by the average palate. And both deliver pure fruit flavour, albeit on different parts of the varietal spectrum. Where Ravensworth offers Canberra’s solid acid backbone and the unevolved flavour of a new wine, Forbes and Forbes sits more delicately on the palate, delivering a pristine, lime-like flavour, carried by soft, fresh acidity.

Majella The Musician Cabernet Sauvignon Shiraz $18–$20
Majella vineyard, Coonawarra South Australia
The Musician is the Lynn family’s song of fruit ¬– a floral, juicy expression of the cabernet sauvignon and shiraz grapes grown on their eastern Coonawarra vineyard. The wine delivers Coonawarra’s deep, ripe, berry flavours, medium body and elegant structure, without the overlay of oak or other winemaker inputs seen in wines made for cellaring. It’s made to drink right now – move onto the next vintage as soon as it’s released next year.

Printhie MCC Shiraz 2012 $36
Printhie Phalaris block, Orange, NSW
Printhie shiraz comes from the company’s Phalaris block towards the lowest, warmest point of the Orange district. Even so, MCC 2012 sits at the cooler end of cool-climate shiraz styles. It’s highly aromatic – combining bright, strawberry-like character, overlaid with the spice and white pepper indicative of very cool growing conditions. The latter often points to green, unripe flavours in shiraz. But Printhie just makes it over the line – the white pepper, acidity and fine, firm tannins balancing delicately with the vibrant fruit flavour.

West Cape Howe Tempranillo 2012 $13–$20
Frankland and Perth Hills, Western Australia
Gavin Berry’s tempranillo presents the fruity side of Spain’s great red variety. It’s adapting well across a diversity of Australian climates – in this instance Frankland and the Perth Hills, Western Australia. The colour’s limpid and crimson-rimmed and the aroma is all about fresh, dark berries. Fresh berry flavours fill the palate, too, ahead of a pleasing earthy note and then the fine, firm tannins of the variety.

Wynns Coonawarra Estate Michael Shiraz 2010 $100–$145
Eastern Coonawarra, South Australia
The Riddoch Highway dissects Coonawarra from north to south. The sea of vines on the flat land either side of the highway gives a deceptive impression of homogeneity – of a landscape where all sites are created equal. In fact, various plots across Coonawarra produce a wide diversity of wines, albeit in the elegant regional style. Shiraz, for examples, struggles to ripen in the south and fares best, in Wynns’ long experience, in the sandy soils towards the eastern edge of northern Coonawarra. This is the source of the sublime Michael Shiraz 2010, a powerful but fine-boned, gentle and elegant shiraz with long-term cellaring potential. Expect wide variation in pricing.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 30 October 2013 in the Canberra Times and goodfood.com.au

Wine review — St Erth, Mount Horrocks and De Bortoli Sacred Hill

St Erth Geelong Pinot Noir 2011 $14.25–$15
The privately owned Ballande Group, based in New Caledonia, owns the Tisdall Winery, established in 1971 in Echuca, Victoria. The company exports under a number of labels and also owns the St Erth brand, which it sells exclusively to the Woolworths-owned Dan Murphy chain. A Geelong-based winemaker sources fruit and makes St Erth in Geelong for Ballande. In the cool 2011 the wine’s on the lighter side, but nevertheless offers a true pinot experience at a very good price. It combines bright, varietal fruit character with fine tannins and a savoury, earthy finish.

Mount Horrocks Watervale Semillon 2012 $25–$33
Stephanie Toole’s oak-fermented semillon offers better drinking than ever in the outstanding 2012 vintage. Fuller bodied than riesling, but lighter than chardonnay, it offers rich flavours but also delicacy and the unique lemon- and lemongrass-like character of the variety. Though fermented and matured entirely in oak barrels, the oak influence is subtle – perhaps adding a vanilla-like flavour – and perceived more in the silky texture the process adds to the wine. O’Toole makes her wines from 10-hectares of vines in the Clare Valley. The semillon comes from the Watervale sub-region at the southern end of the valley.

De Bortoli Sacred Hill Chardonnay 2013 $4.75–$7
De Bortoli Windy Peak Yarra Valley Chardonnay 2012 $9.80–$15
De Bortoli makes chardonnays at many prices, from the humble Sacred Hill ($4.75–$7) to the lofty PHI and Yarra Valley Reserve ($50). The latter rate among the best in Australia. And, as so often happens when wineries strive to be the best, the cheaper wines benefit from what the winemakers learn in their quest for the best. The bright and fresh Sacred Hill offers generous, peachy varietal flavour on a medium bodied, smooth-textured palate. The year older Windy Peak shows the greater flavour intensity and complexity, and stronger acid backbone of the cool Yarra Valley.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 27 October 2013 in the Canberra Times

Wine review — Eden Road, Mount Horrocks, Tahbilk and Corte Carista

Eden Road Tumbarumba Chardonnay 2012 $40
Maragle and Courabyra vineyards, Tumbarumba, NSW
Canberra’s Nick Spencer made three 2012 chardonnays from Tumbarumba – this blend from the Maragle and Courabyra vineyards, plus individual wines from each site. There’s a family style in their lean, tight, pure flavours; but differences, too, based on the altitude of the sites and winemaking techniques. The barrel-fermented blend (silver medallist at the regional show) delivers generous nectarine-like varietal flavour, albeit in Spencer’s tight, smooth-textured style. Barrel-fermented Maragle 2012 (silver medallist, $50), from a comparatively warm site at 400 metres, uses notable more new oak than the blend. This influences the fuller, nectarine-and-peach flavours on the palate – though the wine remains a comparatively lean, tight style. The tank-fermented Courabyra 2012 (bronze medal, $50), shows the soaring acidity of the cool, 750-metre site. It brings grapefruit-like acerbity to a pure-fruited, distinctive unoaked style. I suspect these wines will age well, though cellaring remains an act of faith at this early stage of the brand.

Eden Road Canberra Riesling 2013 $30
Long Rail Gully vineyard, Murrumbateman, Canberra District, NSW
A bronze medal in the regional wine show matches my own rating for a clean, fresh, well made riesling. Delicious, citrus-like varietal flavour gives it some immediate drinking appeal, though I suspect the fruit flavour to assert itself over the austere acids with a little time in bottle. The difference should become apparent over the next few months. This is characteristic of many Canberra rieslings, though the 2013s, in general, seem more approachable when young than the 2012s did.

Mount Horrocks Riesling 2013 $32
Watervale, Clare Valley, South Australia
Everything appeals about Stephanie Toole’s 2013 riesling – favourite by a big margin in a trio of 2013s from Canberra, Great Southern and Watervale. The shimmering, green-tinted colour gave it a visual edge – matched by its pure, lime-like varietal aroma and fine, delicate, mouth-watering, dry palate. The wine should evolve well for several years, though it’s racy and a thrill to drink now

Tahbilk Shiraz 2010 $16–$20
Tahbilk vineyard, Nagambie Lakes, Victoria
Tahbilk, the Purbrick family property established in 1860, produces a distinctive shiraz style, with its own little slot on the variety’s very wide Australian spectrum. Like those from other cooler regions, it’s medium bodied. And there’s black pepper and spice seasoning the underlying berry flavours – both clear shiraz characteristics. But the firm, even bony, tannins separate Tahbilk from other medium bodied shirazes. The tannins bite and thrust, giving a firm, savoury finish to the dry palate.

Bests Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 $26–$30
Best’s vineyard, Great Western Victoria
Unquestionably shiraz is the standout variety on the Thomson family’s Great Western Vineyard – wines polished to an exceptional standard in the last two decades under Viv Thomson and, since 2008, his son, Ben. Cabernet performed well, too, in 2012, producing a fragrant, elegant, easy-to-drink wine. It’s built on ripe, blackcurrant flavours, with the variety’s leafy edge and firm but fine tannins. The Great Western vineyards were established by Henry Best in1867 and acquired by the Thomson family in 1920.

Chianti Classico (Corte Carista) 2009 $10
Chianti Classico zone, Tuscany, Italy
Aldi’s Tuscan important takes us well away in style from Australian wines made from the same grape variety, sangiovese. It’s light to medium bodied, taut, bone-dry, earthy and savoury with its cherry-like fruit flavour buried well inside the fine, firm tannins. Like all the Aldi wines I’ve tried to date, it fits the specification, offering very good value for money. The withered little cork snapped in half as we coaxed it from the bottle. But at least the wine emerged clean, fresh and untainted by the cork – something drinkers always risk with this outmoded seal.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2013
First published 23 October 2013 in the Canberra Times and goodfood.com.au