Gerald Asher’s fine wine writing

THE ENGLISH have probably thrown up more good wine writers than anyone else. Not surprising, given that London has for so long been the centre of the world’s wine trade. Thumb through the major English wine publications and you’ll find a level of commentary and judgment we don’t enjoy here. But even so, it’s not always riveting stuff. And a good deal of it, naturally enough, is pitched at the already well-informed reader.

But every now and then there emerges a wine writer of greater stature – someone who not only exercises good judgment on the topic but also has the literary skill to enthuse as well as inform the reader. In Australia, probably only Len Evans ever achieved that, and these days he’s too busy telling jokes to bother with the enthusiastic wine-writing of old.

Some of the most easily digested essays on wine that I’ve read flow from the pen of Gerald Asher. I’m not a regular reader of American Gourmet magazine, but Asher’s wine column illuminated the occasional issues to come my way. During the week an old friend handed me a book, Gerald Asher on Wine, a collection of his essays, many adapted from Gourmet articles. It was compulsive reading after the turgid fare served up in our glossies.

Asher began his career in the wine trade in London shortly after the World War II. In Asher’s words, ‘The wine trade was regarded as a convenient refuge for those of good family who were ill-equipped for the intellectual challenge of law or medicine, yet insufficiently rich to be placed in private banking in the city. He who had every right to be modest in his expectations was thus kept from the shame of idleness but, in the process, depressed the expectations of the rest of us. For nearly five years my salary had remained unchanged. Proud of my accomplishments, I asked the managing director if he would review it. He was taken aback. “Young man”, he said, turning me down, “if I were to grant an increase, it would merely encourage you to ask again another time. There’d be no holding you.'”

Perhaps there’s a message in there for Mr Hawke and the airline pilots. But for Gerald Asher it was the spur to setting up in the wine trade on his own. He set about building a prosperous business, quite different from the traditional London wine merchants.

Instead of concentrating on the great classic wines of Bordeaux and Burgundy, he went in search of the distinctive country wines of France, discovering cheaper wines of high quality.

Thus detached from conventional thinking, he was forced to search diligently to arrive at his own definitions of which wines represented both quality and value. His judgment must have been good, because the business prospered. Presumably this was the period in which he learned to pen his enthusiasm for the lesser wines of France. How else would sales have been so good.

The experience he gained in visiting the cellars of hundreds of producers all over France, combined with his earlier classical training, gave Asher a unique perspective on wine and how it meshed with the soils, climates, foods, and people of the regions from which they are produced. His independence of experience and thought also led to another breakthrough in business. He began exporting both the lesser and classic wine of France direct to the United States, and not through London as was traditionally the case.

The market there was attractive enough to win him as a permanent resident in 1971, to New York initially, but now in San Francisco close to the Napa Valley.

Trade in the United States he finds far removed from the gentlemanly pastime it was in Britain: ‘I had to supply mug shot, finger prints, and personal history to the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, whose representatives visited friends and acquaintances in the course of their inquiries. It was clear that I was to consider myself henceforth a potential criminal, at very least. Indeed, I was soon to realise that the laws relating to the sale of wine – irrational, demeaning, and absurdly varied from state to state – make certain that everyone involved with the wine and spirit trade of this country will at some time, knowingly or unknowingly, commit an offence …’

Undeterred by the bureaucratic monkeys on his back, Asher’s wine knowledge and judgment was further enriched by the incredible vigour of the then rapidly emerging Californian wine industry.

Working in the trade, and most importantly selling to the public, Asher managed to keep his feet firmly planted to the ground. His essays breathe an enthusiasm for wine.

And though a magazine like American Gourmet is read by well-healed people with, probably, an above average interest and knowledge in wine, his words are never purely didactic, and never pretentious, condescending, or intimidating to those uninitiated in wine lore.

His essays are packed with information, cleverly woven with anecdote, and stitched together with a rare judgment as to where a particular wine style stands in relation to other Wines. It is this judgment and style of presentation which separates Gerald Asher from his peers.

The little volume I was handed during the week made compulsive reading – the sort of thing you hide under the bedcovers and read by torchlight long after your spouse has demanded the light be turned off. It may be hard to find, but it was published by Vintage Books, a division of Random House, New York, in 1986.

First published 22 October 1989 in The Canberra Times
Copyright © Chris Shanahan 1989 and 2026