Yearly Archives: 2009

Wine review — Best’s Great Western, Jeir Creek and Clonakilla

Best’s Great Western Riesling 2009 $22, Bin 1 Shiraz 2008 $25, Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 $25
Best’s, founded by Henry Best in 1866, was acquired by Frederick Thomson in 1913 and is today run by Ben Thomson, the family’s fifth generation in the business. It’s a must visit for its wonderful old vineyards, dating to 1868, cellars from the same era and first-class regional wines – like this reasonably priced trio.  The fresh, crisp, riesling separates itself from the Clare classics by its taut acidity – a real plus for an aperitif style. The shiraz in the juicy pepper and spice, savoury cool-climate style and ready to enjoy now; and the cabernet surprising ripe and full with reassuring firm tannins.

Jeir Creek Canberra District Botrytris Semillon Sauvignon Blanc 2008 375ml $25
Tim Kirk built Canberra’s shiraz reputation. Ken Helm blazed the riesling trail. And at Jeir Creek, Murrumbateman, Rob and Kay Howell developed as their flagship a luscious, oak matured, botrytised semillon sauvignon blanc. Originally it contained grapes from Canberra and Bredbo. But now it’s all from Canberra, principally Jeir Creek, but with some material from nearby vineyards. The new release shows the vibrance and fruitiness of the outstanding 2008 vintage, albeit in a finely structured style with plenty of acid to offset the plush, fruity sweetness. It’s just the thing with stinky, runny cheeses. I’m already thinking of the Silo cheese room and next truffle season.

Clonakilla Canberra District O’Riada Shiraz 2008 $35, Shiraz Viognier 2008 $75
Clonakilla’s Tim Kirk recently hosted a dinner at Senso, pairing Jan Gundlach’s food with five pairs of Canberra shiraz: Lerida Estate Shiraz Viognier and Long Rail Gully Shiraz 2008; Ravensworth Shiraz Viognier 2007 and Kyeema Estate Reserve Shiraz 2007; Nick O’Leary Shiraz 2008 and Clonakilla O’Riada Shiraz 2008; Collector Reserve Shiraz 2008 and Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier 2008; and the 2006 and 2008 vintages of Clonakilla Syrah. My favourite of the Clonakillas to drink on the night was the elegant, ethereal O’Riada; but the best is yet to come from the opulent, savoury shiraz viognier. The other wines performed well, too. I’ll review them here soon.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Beer review — Wig & Pen and Rogue

Wig & Pen Kembery Regional Ale 330ml 6-pack $19
It’s the Wig’s first bottled beer, brewed and packaged at De Bortoli’s Red Angus brewery, Griffith, under supervision of Richard Watkins, the Wig’s brewer. It’s similar to the on-tap Kolsch style – pale in colour with piquant hoppy aroma and sensationally fresh, subtle flavours, finishing with a lingering, balanced hops bitterness. Available at the Wig.

Rogue Morimoto Black Obi Soba Ale 660ml $16.90
Rogue, of Oregon USA, offers two versions of Soba Ale, made from a variety of barley malts plus roasted soba (buckwheat). This is the deep tan, turbo version, featuring a greater number of malts and hops varieties than the standard brew. It features subtle, rich, roasted malt flavours and a delicious, ash-dry tartness.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Rogue’s idiosyncratic brews

Have the Rogue Brewery guys visited our Ettamogah pub? Or is the pick up truck on their tin roof in Oregon, USA, a parallel invention? We may never know. But at least we know the crows there don’t fly backward – because they’d be headed straight to the beautifully made, idiosyncratic beers.

I’ve been working my way through some of the range, including the Hazelnut Brown Nectar reviewed a few weeks back, and the delicious Morimoto Black Obi Soba Ale below. My only quibble is that they’re a little pricey here in Australia. But that, the guys at Plonk tell me, is because it wanders the world a little before arriving here.

That caveat aside, the range is exciting and worth a premium, even if we explore it by the bottle, not the six-pack. I’ve yet to discover Rogue’s signature brew, Dead Guy Ale and it’s companion, Double Dead Guy.

Dead Guy is based on Germany’s opulent, alcoholic maibock style and Double Dead Guy, on spec, looks to be a revved up version, higher in alcohol, with malt in overdrive.

Plonk, Fyshwick, carries some of the range and www.internationalbeershop.com.au offers delivery (it’s a site worth visiting in any event).

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Passing the taste test and the paradox of tasting

I’ve heard it called the paradox of tasting – the situation where professional tasters elect a champion wine and then drink anything but the champ during the following discussion.

I don’t why it is, but sometimes a wine that seems terrific at first sip, loses interest while an apparently plainer wine grows in interest with every mouthful. I’ve heard of one tasting group that rates the wines in the order in which they disappear over a meal. Sensible folks.

As a lapsed retailer and veteran of dozens of public tastings, I’ve seen over and again how individual perceptions vary enormously, sometimes fundamentally, and how any number of visual or spoken cues profoundly affect how we perceive and rate wine.

Organised tastings, whether they’re on the sterile white benches of wine shows, in the scramble of a crowded retail store or in a relaxed cellar door atmosphere seem far removed from how we actually drink and enjoy wine – with food in the company of friends.

One of our wine shows, the Sydney International Top 100 acknowledges this by bringing food into the equation during judging. And one of the tasting groups that supplies many of my own recommendations enjoys small flights of masked wines over a meal – yes, actually swallowing the wine and enjoying its affects as well as flavour.

On a larger scale, an event that started as a yearly extended-family holiday now includes broad-ranging tastings during the evening meals. This year, across eight evenings, about 25 adults ranging from 21 to 65 tasted (to be polite) about 150 wines served with everything from snags to scallops.

We had no intention of drawing a list of favourites or rating wines by points or stars. But the diverse opinions flowed – sometimes eloquently, sometimes with a quiet grin or a second glass (politeness again) or a glass untouched.

Surprisingly we couldn’t see any age or gender related preferences. But we did see a couple of broad trends – a very strong bias towards red wine; a notable preference for soft, fleshy reds (shiraz, pinot, grenache, tempranillo) as stand alone drinks; a more catholic appreciation of red styles as the food flowed – including very firm cabernet and savoury sangiovese and nebbiolo; delight in riesling at any time; a preference for sauvignon blanc with petanque; and a mix of surprise and delight at the oak-fermented chardonnays, especially served with local fresh seafood.

From the 150 wines an eclectic and small list of standouts emerged.

Holm Oak Tasmania Sauvignon Blanc 2009 $25
A lovely, pure and understated expression of the style from Tassie’s Tamar Valley. It’ll never be better than it is now – exquisitely fresh.

Scarborough Hunter Valley Chardonnay 2008 $25
Full and juicy with seafood chowder – in the soft but fine and complex Hunter style.

Shelmerdine Heathcote Riesling 2009 $29
An absolute knockout from the Victorian region more renowned for its shiraz.

Shelmerdine Heathcote Viognier 2009 $29
Another winner from the Shelmerdine family – complex, subtle viognier without the fat oiliness generally associated with viognier.

Essenze Waipara Pinot Gris 2009 $21
From Waipara, a little to the north of Christchurch New Zealand – a full-bodied, richly textured pinot gris with matching crisp acidity.

Oyster Bay Marlborough Pinot Noir 2008 $23
An easy drinking pinot showing many of the key good characteristics of this difficult variety – fragrant and fruity with sufficient tannic grip to be a real red – if not the magic of the best.

Stone Dwellers Strathbogie Ranges Pinot Noir 2008 $25
A lovely surprise from the Plunkett and Fowles families – this has the aroma, flavour, elegance and grippy structure of good pinot. Very good at this price. One to watch.

Wyndham Estate George Wyndham Shiraz Grenache McLaren Vale Barossa Valley Shiraz Grenache 2007 $21.59
Probably a lot cheaper on special. A juicy mouthful of ripe, grapey flavours and soft tannins. George Wyndham died a century and a half ago, but they dug him up to sign the label.

Tahbilk Nagambie Lakes Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 $21.50
There’s fabulous value here from the Purbrick family estate – elegant but rich and quite firm in the house style, and oh so good with protein rich food.

Tahbilk Eric Stevens Purbrick Nagambie Lakes Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 $69.95
Savoured alongside the cheaper Tahbilk wine and significantly more concentrated in flavour – a superior wine for long cellaring. Not three times as good, but discernibly better and with quite a pedigree.

Tahbilk Nagambie Lakes Shiraz 2006 $21.50
A tight, savoury, quite tannic shiraz that disappeared very quickly.

Zema Estate Coonawarra Shiraz 2006 $25.95
A contrast to the Tahbilk wine, still in the medium bodied, cool-climate style with Coonawarra’s bright berry flavours and soft tannins.

Domaine Chandon Barrel Selection Shiraz 2006 $49.95
Of unknown origin, but clearly from a cool climate with its medium body, elegance, concentrated flavour and silky, plush texture. A class act.

Turkey Flat Vineyards Barossa Valley Shiraz 2007 $47
A deep and generous, soft and savoury shiraz sourced in part from vines planted in 1847. From Peter and Christie Schulz’s Turkey Flat Vineyard.

Turkey Flat Vineyards Barossa Valley Mourvedre 2007 $35
A wine that divided the crowd – comments ranged from ‘the best wine all week’, to ‘that’s nice’ to ‘yuk, don’t like that one at all’. To my taste it was wonderful – full and savoury with mourvedre’s distinctive, firm tannins.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Wine review — McWilliams Mount Pleasant, Oyster Bay, Stone Dwellers and Holm Oak

McWilliams ‘Elizabeth’ Hunter Semillon 2004 $12-$17
Crème de Cassis de Dijon 500ml $15

Why risk the run of bland, sweet roses when you can render any dry white or bubbly pink – as well as tasty, fruity and bitter-sweet – with a splash of cassis?  The drier and more austere the wine the better as the tartness offsets the cassis sweetness – just as lemon juice tempers oily fish or lime juices spruces up the fruit salad. A good Aussie candidate is young Hunter semillon as it’s normally acidic, bone dry and low in alcohol. The blend is named Kir, after a former mayor of Dijon. Introduce Champagne, preferably an acidic style like Lanson NV, and you have Kir Royale.

Oyster Bay Marlborough Pinot Noir 2008 $17–$23
Stone Dwellers Strathbogie Ranges Pinot Noir 2008 $22–$25

In the mid to late nineties broad acre plantings of pinot, destined for red, not sparkling wine, began to appear in Marlborough. A decade on we’re seeing some terrific wines, some dead set serious, others, like Oyster Bay, offering pleasant, medium bodied expressions of this appealing grape variety. Pinot could become the region’s red equivalent of its globe-conquering sauvignon blanc. In Australia, too, we’re making ever better pinot, like this substantial Strathbogie Ranges version from the Plunkett and Fowles families. This is a far more serious effort – a real red, but still with the fragrance, suppleness, juicy depth and fine tannin structure of good pinot.

Holm Oak Tasmania Sauvignon Blanc 2009 $25
From a 12-hectare vineyard on the Tamar River, Holm Oak sauvignon blanc delivers stunningly fresh, herbal varietal flavours. It provides a light and subtle contrast to Marlborough’s turbo versions. And despite the lightness, there’s a juicy texture, derived from maturation on yeast lees, fleshing out the mid palate. Like the wines from Marlborough it’s a good example of how growing the variety in an appropriately cool climate delivers the right flavour and structure. The vineyard was planted in 1983 by Ian and Robyn Wilson. Their daughter Rebecca, a qualified winemaker, and her partner Tim Duffy now lease the vineyard and make the wines.  www.homoakvineyards.com.au

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Visionary Kirk sees new Rhone in Oz Capital

Gourmet Traveller Wine recently confirmed what the local wine show and every critic in the land have been telling us for years – that shiraz is Canberra’s number one variety by a country mile.

Seizing the publicity opportunity, Clonakilla’s Tim Kirk, local shiraz trailblazer, took ten of our best on a road trip to Sydney’s Marque Restaurant, Jan Gundlach’s Senso, at Fyshwick Markets, and Attica Restaurant, Melbourne.

At the Canberra event Tim turned on his hot-gospel best. “Canberra is one of the world’s great shiraz regions”, he declared. “Shiraz is a collection of the savoury; a symphony of spice. Pinot, at its best, can be pure seduction, but shiraz [of the style made in Canberra] is like embracing someone you love”.

Turning from hot gospel to the inner Jesuit, Tim drew parallels between Canberra and France’s northern Rhone Valley, home of the shiraz grape. In both places the granite soils, altitude and continental climate (warm days, cool nights) produce medium bodied, elegant shiraz. The wines feature red currant, spice, pepper and herb flavours, soft, silky tannins and high natural acidity.

Jesuits, of course, frown on heretics. So Tim sunk the slipper (gently) into shiraz not grown in the one true climate. For example, the Barossa’s hot days and warm nights don’t preserve acids, don’t produce red currant flavours and don’t produce elegant, silky shiraz in the Canberra mould; these conditions produce altogether bigger, bolder wines.

Then the visionary hot gospeller returned. In fifty years time people around the world will talk about Canberra and its sub-regions as they do now of the Rhone. We’re their equals. We have a similar ancient landscape. They have only a few hundred years start on us and we’re catching up. Canberra is already among the world’s greatest shiraz producing regions.

In Tim’s case that’s a fair enough claim. Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier stands tall around the planet. But we’ve seen other fine examples emerge in the last decade. Magnanimously, since this was a Clonakilla event, Tim included some of these at the dinner – five pairs of shiraz, each pair matched with a sensational dish.

This was a confident, polished act – the real showcase of Canberra’s best, something the local vignerons had attempted, and failed at, just a few weeks earlier at Old Parliament House.

The wines we enjoyed were: Lerida Estate Shiraz Viognier 2008 and Long Rail Gully Shiraz 2008; Ravensworth Shiraz Viognier 2007 and Kyeema Reserve Shiraz 2007; Nick O’Leary Shiraz 2008 and Clonakilla O’Riada Shiraz 2008; Collector Reserve Shiraz 2008 and Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier 2008; Clonakilla Syrah 2006 and Clonakilla Syrah 2008 barrel sample.

I’ll be reviewing those that are still available in my Sunday column. But if you’ve not yet discovered Canberra shiraz, now is the time. The 2008s now coming onto the market are just delightful.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Wine review — Majella, Helm, Brindabella Hills, Lake George Vineyard and Shaw Vineyard Estate

Majella Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 $33
Like Canberra, Coonawarra suffered severe crop losses in the frosts of late 2006. As a result, says Majella’s Brian Lynn, there’s only a tiny quantity of the 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon – one of the most appealing cabernets you’ll ever taste. It has an extraordinary high-toned fragrance and a buoyant fleshy-but-firm, elegant palate to match. I’ve been cellaring Majella cabernets for more than a decade now and, young and old, they provide exciting drinking, never losing their varietal flavour and structure – just changing subtly as they age. This is one of the best. It’s made by Bruce Gregory in Brian and Tony Lynn’s winery alongside the vines.

Ken Helm Premium Riesling 2009 $45
Majella Coonawarra Riesling 2009 $16

What a contrast there is between riesling prices. And the amazing thing is that the quality gap is less than the price suggests. Especially when they’re young, rieslings can be hard to differentiate between – show judges regularly stuff it up. But you can bet your last bottle of Grange that as time goes by the intense, taut Helm Premium will pull ahead of the juicy and delicious Majella. It’s estate-grown-and-made by the Lynn family in Coonawarra. And Ken Helm’s wine is made from the best grapes off Al Lustenburger’s Murrumbateman vineyard.

Brindabella Hills Canberra Sauvignon Blanc 2008 $16
Lake George Vineyard Canberra Semillon Sauvignon Blanc 2008 $16
Shaw Vineyard Estate Canberra Semillon Sauvignon Blanc 2008 $20

These three appealing whites all featured in James Halliday’s rating of NSW’s top 100 wines and at a subsequent dinner at old parliament house. They offer easy drinking, good value in a spectrum of styles. My favourite is the Brindabella Hills (from Hall), a subtle, pure, ripe sauvignon blanc. It’s just about sold out, but the 2009 is about to be released. The Lake George wine shows more of the lemon-like varietal flavour of Semillon and that variety’s backbone and structure, too. The Shaw wine (Murrumbateman) expresses more of the herbal, greener notes of the two varieties.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Beer review — Shepherd Neame and Morland

Shepherd Neame Whitstable Bay Organic Ale 500ml $8.90
It’s billed as ‘a modern ale from Britain’s oldest brewer’, presumably a reference to its zesty, easy-drinking freshness – achieved without losing ale’s hallmark fruitiness and complexity. It’s moderately alcoholic at 4.5 per cent and a refreshing, drying thread of hops bitterness. Brewed using organic ingredients in Kent, England.

Morland Hen’s Tooth Strong Ale $8.70
There’s an appealing, sweet, fruity richness to Morland’s gold-amber, bottle-conditioned ale, boosted and made even headier by its 6.5 per cent alcohol content. However, it’s well balanced, the malt and alcohol sweetness being tempered by a lingering hops bitterness. It’s made in Suffolk, England.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Riggers and growlers

Kilderkins and firkins sound like something out of Diagon Alley and the Leakey Cauldron. But they’re really muggle’s inventions for something readers of this column love passionately – beer kegs. Just for the record, in case you didn’t pay attention at school, two firkins (careful how you say that) equal one kilderkin, the good old 18-gallon keg.

But the peculiar beer names don’t stop there. If you’ve visited new Zealand you’ve possibly enjoyed a rigger – but most likely only with a local. As an outsider, how would you know that you can fill your own two-litre bottle with draft ale at the local bottle-o?

Apparently, it’s done in parts of the USA, too, where they call it a growler. But it’s not something I’ve seen in Australia. The idea conjures images of foam all over – as surely self-filled riggers suit New Zealand’s low-gas ales better than our vigorous lagers.

So it’ll be a first for Canberra when the Wig & Pen begins filling take-away two-litre bottles from its ale taps in the near future – probably early in the new year.

Brewer Richard Watkins says it’s all planned, except for the name. Can’t be pinching from the New Zealanders or Americans, can we? Now what might J. K. Rowling call the Aussie growler?

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009

Albarino update

In 1989 the CSIRO bought a woolly pup from Galacia, Spain. But it learned this only twenty years later. What the CSIRO believed to be the white variety, albarino, turned out to be savagnin. By then Australian vignerons had about 150-hectares of ‘albarino’ in the ground, all of it sourced ultimately from the original CSIRO holdings, and some of it well on the way to commercial success.

The news broke around vintage time, posing the dilemma of what to call the coming crop. Out came the viticulture books and makers listed the many synonyms – savagnin blanc, uvernat blanc, bon blanc, forment, formentin blanc, fraentsch, fromenteau, gentil blanc, gringet, gruenedel, grumin, princ bily, heida, païen, printsch grau, ryvola bila, schleitheimer, servoyen blanc, traminer, traminer d’Ore, traminer weiss – as obscure and motley a crew as you’d ever assemble on a tasting bench.

There was some talk of coining a name – an idea that’s stirred repeatedly in varying contexts during our three-decade withdrawal from European wine names. Remember all those misguided shots at a single name for Australia’s hundreds of sparkling wines? Who can remember of any them now? The reasoning went along the lines, we can’t call it champagne any more, so let’s come up with something new.

While the blinkered few chalked up their bright ideas, makers of premium bubblies pushed on with sensible varietal labels, sometimes regionally badged, sometimes coupled with registered proprietary names like Salinger, Croser and Pirie; and purveyors of mass bubblies like Minchinbury and Great Western simply dropped the word ‘champagne’ – the packaging and established branding said all that needed to be said.

More recently we saw an industry committee inflict ‘topaque’ and ‘apera’ on our tokay and sherry makers after the Europeans reclaimed those names. I’m told Spike Milligan sat on the committee posthumously. While some makers adopted topaque and apera, how the names cut with wine drinkers has yet to be gauged. But it could be some time before the laughter subsides.

At least the venerable old Rutherglen winery, Chambers, for one, saw it as a crock, crossed out ‘tokay’ and replaced it with ‘muscadelle’ – a sensible, serious and easily explained name for a wine made in Rutherglen from the muscadelle grape. Perhaps more will follow suit.

If our diverse albarino-turned-savagnin makers (I found 35 growers in the Australian Wine Industry Directory, but the number of labels would be greater) wanted a single alternative name they could’ve followed Kraft and appealed to the public. But then we’d have iDrink2.0, eHAAA! and any number of alternatives floating around on Facebook.

As I write, we albarino drinkers watch anxiously for the 2009s and wonder what they’ll be called. We don’t care all that much, as long as it’s not silly, because we’ve developed a tasted for these aromatic but deliciously savoury dry whites. What we can predict with some certainty, though, is a pragmatic approach from most makers.

So far I’ve tasted but one, Chapel Hill’s excellent il Vescovo 2009, from the company’s vineyard at Kangarilla, a sub-region of McLaren. Winemaker Michael Fragos says it’s one of the few whites that really thrives in this warm dry region, producing terrific aroma and savoury fruit flavour at a comparatively low alcohol level – a refreshing 12.5 per cent for the new release. Replacing ‘albarino’ with ‘savagnin’ was the only change Michael made to the label. At $20 a bottle it offers intriguing new flavours. See www.chapelhillwine.com.au

And I’m looking forward to trying Crittenden’s 2009 Mornington Peninsula version. Until 2009 it sold under the “Los Hermanos” label, especially created for the company’s Spanish varieties.

I predicted that founder Garry Crittenden’s children, Zoe Rollo might keep it under the Los Hermanos name giving continuity to the wine’s identity, if not its varietal name.
But, no, they’ve just released it as a savagnin called “Tributo A Galacia”. Now, albarino is the signature white variety of Galacia, Spain. But savagnin is not. So the name’s possibly ironic, given the origin of Australian savagnin, though it possibly translates as “up yours”.

While that’s two out of two makers, so far, opting for ‘savagnin’ it’ll be interesting to see if any makers adopt other synonyms. Of these ‘traminer’ is widely known but almost certainly too tainted with a fruity, sweet image.

Interestingly, traminer and gewürztraminer share identical DNA. The difference is that the gewürztraminer clone, an old Australian workhorse, displays characteristics of the ancient muscat grape. It’s intensely aromatic, grapey and once tasted never forgotten. Traminer, the ‘non-musque’ clone, shows none of this muscat character and, though aromatic in a vinous sort of way, is more savoury.

Before we identified our albarino as savagnin earlier this year, visiting Spanish albarino makers had considered our vines and wines to be albarino in appearance and taste.
What we have, according to Chris Bourke of Sons & Brothers Vineyard, Orange, is the first plantings of non-musque traminer since James Busby’s importation in 1832. Bourke and others see this clone as a valuable addition to Australia’s vine stock.

Whatever you call it, the vine suits our warm dry climate and produces wine distinct different from chardonnay, sauvignon blanc, semillon or riesling.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2009