Yearly Archives: 2007

Beer review — Theakston & Wychwood

Theakston Old Peculier the Legend 500ml $7.49
Peculier spelling perhaps, but Theakston’s idiosyncratic brew clicks all the right winter hyperlinks. An alcohol of 5.6 underpins an inviting warmth that’s matched by the rich but subtle malt flavour. The use of wheat malt as well as barley in the blend gives the palate zest and dries out the pleasantly tart finish.

Wychwood Hobgoblin Strong Dark Ale 500ml $6.89
At 5.2 per cent the alcohol’s modest for a strong ale. But the opulent, creamy-textured palate adds to its warmth. The flavours lean towards the chocolate, mocha and caramel typical of dark malt beers – and this is nicely balanced with a tweak of hops bitterness. It’s a distinctive, delicious winter beer.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Fosters to close Matilda Bay Fremantle brewery

All hell’s likely to break loose in the west with Foster’s decision to shut down Matilda Bay’s Fremantle brewery.

As I write this column Foster’s has just broken the news to the Australian stock exchange and to Fremantle staff affected by the decision.

Matilda Bay’s Melbourne-based Chief Brewer, Brad Rogers, tells me that Matilda Bay’s bigger brands, including Redback Wheat Beer and Bohemian Pilsner, will now be brewed at the Foster’s-owned Cascade Brewery, Tasmania.

Brad says that Matilda Bay’s Beez Neez has been brewed by Cascade for just over three years.

It seems the decision is an economic one of bringing production closer to the big east coast markets. But the west will miss its modern beer icon.

Will the beer style change? Probably not. But if they do it’ll be for reasons other than a change of location.

Brad says that Matilda Bay’s small brewery at Dandenong will continue to operate.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Press release — Penfolds 2007 recorking clinics announced

This is great after-sales service for collectors of Penfolds red wines. The winemaking team, led by Peter Gago, opens, samples, tops up and recorks your 15+ year old Penfolds reds. If it’s thumbs up on quality, they top the wine up with the current vintage, recork, re-capsule and attach a signed certificate to the bottle. If it’s thumbs down? You get a new cork and advice to drink it now.

This is Penfolds press release: 

2007 PENFOLDS REGIONAL RECORKING CLINICS

The 2007 Penfolds Re-corking Clinics are confirmed:

Newcastle — Tuesday 31 July 2007
Crowne Plaza, Corner Merewether Street & Wharf Road, Newcastle NSW

Cairns – Tuesday 14 August 2007
Cairns International Hotel 17 Abbott Street Cairns QLD

Canberra – Thursday 2 August 2007
Hyatt Hotel Commonwealth Avenue Yarralumla ACT

Launceston – Friday 17 August 2007
Country Club Tasmania, Tasman Room, Country Club Ave, Prospect TAS

Over the last 15 years over 50,000 bottles of Penfolds wines have been inspected, opened, tasted and topped up by Penfolds Winemakers to ensure their prolonged cellar development. It is an amazing after hours service. The Clinics give our wine friends confidence in their wine investment and encourages further interest in wine.

*Please note for Penfolds Recorking Clinics you must supply your own bottle of Penfolds wine 15 years or older, no other wine labels may be tested at these clinics. Registrations will close two weeks before each clinic. To register please visit www.penfolds.com.au <http://www.penfolds.com.au>

Wine review — Redbank The Long Paddock, Mount Majura, Cloudy Bay & Giant Steps

Redbank The Long Paddock Shiraz 2005 & Chardonnay 2006 $12.95
The Redbank brand originated in Victoria’s Pyrenees region. However, ownership of its ‘Long Paddock’ budget range shifted to Robert Hill-Smith’s Yalumba some years back. Quality is exceptional for the price and fruit sourcing generally from the King Valley, although the current shiraz contains some Pyrenees material as well. The shiraz has lovely, ripe plummy flavours with a cool-climate peppery note and a dry, food-friendly savouriness. The chardonnay is generous, but not fat, with attractive melon-like varietal flavour and an attractive, apple-fresh finish. The smooth texture suggests a touch of malo-lactic fermentation and some maturation on yeast lees. This makes it all the more interesting.

Mount Majura Canberra Chardonnay 2005 $20
Cloudy Bay Marlborough Chardonnay 2005 $42

These are the Yin and Yang of chardonnay, even if both are made in a broadly similar way: fermented and matured in oak barrels. Frank van de Loo’s, from the Mount Majura Vineyard Canberra is minerally, racy and dry. There’s a brightness to it and though some of the winemaker inputs stand out, there’s a lovely cool-climate, grape-fruit-like varietal flavour that maintains the lean, taut style. Cloudy Bay, from even cooler Marlborough, shows extraordinary fruit opulence and accompanying viscous texture. Despite the sheer flavour volume, this is a balanced wine of great freshness and seductive slipperiness. Cloudy Bay you’ll find in stores; for Frank’s wine see www.mountmajura.com.au

Giant Steps Yarra Valley Sexton Vineyard Pinot Noir 2005 $29.95
Giant Steps Yarra Valley Tarraford Vineyard Pinot Noir 2005 $39.95

By the law of diminishing returns the $40 pinot ought to be maybe ten per cent better – not 33 per cent better — than the $30 one, right? Not with this two from Phil Sexton, though: the $40 Tarraford Vineyard wine delivered, to may taste, almost double the drinking pleasure. But I wouldn’t say no to either. These are elegant but substantial pinots, well removed from the lighter, simpler styles. They share a savouriness and strong structure. In the Sexton that fruit versus tannin arm wrestle seems to lean a little towards tannin. In the Tarraford, however, the beautiful fruit aroma carries through into a glorious, supple palate.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Lake George renaissance

Lake George’s two oldest wine estates – Lake George Vineyard and Madew Wines – seem to have fallen off the radar in recent years, leaving relative newcomer, Lerida Estate, to keep the flame burning.

But there’s a renaissance in the making. Madew is on the market. And Lake George owner, Theo Karelas, recently engaged former Kamberra winemaker, Alex McKay, to reinvigorate the vineyard and winemaking – with help from Dr Edgar Riek, the vineyard’s founder.

A revitalised Lake George Vineyard and Madews, operating alongside Lerida, could make this little strip the most-visited part of Canberra’s scattered wine scene. Being at a peaceful remove from the busy Federal Highway is no disadvantage – as the success of nearby Lynwood Café demonstrates.

This really is a very charming location. Search ‘Lake George, Australia’ on Google Earth for a bird’s-eye view of what travellers see when travelling by road between Canberra and Sydney. Heading north from Canberra, the Federal Highway climbs then traverses the Lake George Escarpment before plunging down to the lake at Geary’s Gap.

Continuing north along the western shore of the lake, the escarpment literally crumbles steeply downwards, occasionally spewing rock debris onto the road.

Approaching the northern end of the lake, the slope from the escarpment eases before opening out onto the plains around the village of Collector.

The Lerida, Lake George and Madew vineyards form a contiguous line along these comparatively gentle slopes of the Lake George escarpment and are accessed from the old Federal Highway, now a quiet backwater next to the freeway.

The vineyards lie between the escarpment to the west and Lake George to the east. For those not familiar with the area, ‘Lake’ might be seen as an ironic term. As locals know the lake, vast as it is, comes and goes over time.

After a run of wet seasons it laps the side of the road, mystifying new visitors with its fence posts jutting above the water. In prolonged dry spells, sheep graze the grassy landscape and visitors might glimpse a puddle in the far south towards Bungendore.

When Edgar Riek established Lake George Vineyard in 1971 the lake was there and filling. It has come and gone several time since. And it makes me wonder what influence the presence or absence of such a large body of water – or land – makes on the grape-growing environment along the foreshore. The changes must have an impact.

The Lake George vineyards share other unique grape-growing conditions, too: soil that includes both rubble from erosion of the escarpment as well as deep gravels from old shorelines; the late afternoon shade provided by the escarpment towering above; an elevation of around 700 metres above sea level; and considerable variation in ripening times over short distances – Jim Lumbers, for example, cites a three week gap within Lerida Estate’s 7.5 hectares.

Two years after Riek established ‘Cullarin’ – the original name of Lake George Vineyard – naval captain Geoff Hood planted Westering Vineyard immediately to the north. David and Romily Madew acquired Westering in 1994, expanding the vineyard and building a winery, restaurant (grapefoodwine), cellar door complex.

In 1997 Jim Lumbers and Anne Caine, inspired by Edgar Riek’s pinot noirs, established Lerida on Riek’s southern boundary.

About a year later, Edgar Riek, by now in his seventies and concerned about succession, sold Lake George Vineyard to the Karelas family but stayed on as consultant for the 1999 and 2000 vintages.

Throughout his time at Lake George Edgar had been deeply engaged with the wine industry – partly through the role he played in establishing the National Wine Show – and his wines, despite the tiny volumes, enjoyed a high profile. These faded from view after his departure.

David Madew, on the other hand, showed flair for publicity, establishing Madew’s opera amongst the vines and the ambitious grapefoodwine complex – an enduring piece of infrastructure for the Lake George area. What becomes of Madew under new ownership remains to be seen. But the foundation is there to build on.

As Lake George Winery faded and Madew focused on events, Jim Lumbers and Anne Caine invested heavily in Lerida Estate.

From 1997 they established 7.5 hectares of vines with a strong skew toward pinot noir. This remains their passion, but they also have in the vineyard pinot gris (a white mutant of pinot noir), chardonnay, shiraz, merlot, cabernet franc, shiraz and viognier.

After a fairly rustic start to winemaking – I recall tasting wine outdoors from barrels stored in a shipping container in the early days – they built a beautiful winery, cellar door, café complex designed by Glenn Murcutt.

They’ve been moving up the grape-growing, winemaking learning curve rapidly. And now with Malcolm Burdett and skilled French ‘stagiers’ assisting at each vintage, the wines show increasing polish.

Maturing vines, careful vine management, rigorous fruit selection and competent winemaking have all contributed to a major lift in quality for Lerida. The latest offerings at cellar door (overlooking the lake and within the café) represent real value, with high points for me being the 2005 Reserve Shiraz and 2006 Pinot Noir.

Jim has some wonderful 2007 reds maturing in barrel, including shiraz, merlot and pinot. Again my favourite was the shiraz – already showing strong cool-climate peppery varietal character plus mid-palate richness – followed by a very promising merlot.

This is a winery to watch. It seems well resourced and driven by Jim and Anne’s passion – shared by Malcolm Burdett. However, it’s a little early in the journey yet to say what Lerida’s greatest wines will be. It takes many decades to see what varieties work where, especially in a climate as variable as Canberra’s.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Beer review — Outback & Schwelmer

Outback Chilli Beer 330ml $3.75
Ahhhh! Ouch! Ahhhh! Ouch! At last, the beer that creates a need for itself. It has a deep amber colour and a matching, warm opulent, malty palate. That first sweet hit seduces the palate, before a surge of chilli ripples in leaving its pleasantly bitey residue and, alas, a slightly sweet, cloying aftertaste.

Schwelmer Pils Swingtop 330ml $4.20
Imported from the Schwelm brewery, Westphalia, this lovely Pils style lacks only the freshness to earn five stars. It’s a light golden coloured lager, featuring rich malt that’s offset deliciously by assertive but balanced hops. These contribute to the aroma, flavour, and refreshing, bitter, dry finish.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Foster’s VB takes on XXXX Gold in mid-strength stakes

There’s a serious battle brewing between our giant beer makers, Foster’s and Lion Nathan. Somewhat like the cane toad, Lion’s XXXX Gold – a mid-strength beer – came from nowhere and may now spread to other states.

A year ago this column observed that Queensland’s unique and growing taste for mid-strength beer (3.3 to 3.9 per cent alcohol) was the main driver behind a 7.2 per cent national growth in a category that was all but dead elsewhere.

Sensing a new trend, perhaps, Foster’s recently launched a mid-strength extension of its VB brand, VB Midstrength Lager. Sporting a gold label, but otherwise similar in appearance to the good-old green VB, the new brew weighs in at just 3.5 per cent alcohol – well under the 4.5 to 5 of standard beers.

Should other states develop Queensland’s enthusiasm for mid-strength beer, then VB could be well positioned to capitalise on the trend.

Outback Chilli Beer 330ml $3.75
Ahhhh! Ouch! Ahhhh! Ouch! At last, the beer that creates a need for itself. It has a deep amber colour and a matching, warm opulent, malty palate. That first sweet hit seduces the palate, before a surge of chilli ripples in leaving its pleasantly bitey residue and, alas, a slightly sweet, cloying aftertaste.

Schwelmer Pils Swingtop 330ml $4.20
Imported from the Schwelm brewery, Westphalia, this lovely Pils style lacks only the freshness to earn five stars. It’s a light golden coloured lager, featuring rich malt that’s offset deliciously by assertive but balanced hops. These contribute to the aroma, flavour, and refreshing, bitter, dry finish.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Lerida Estate, Henschke & Clos Pierre

Lerida Estate Lake George Reserve Shiraz 2005 $49.50, Pinot Noir 2006 $22
Jim Lumbers and Anne Caine planted the first vines at Lerida Estate – the southernmost of the three vineyards flanking Lake George – in 1997. They later added the striking Glen Murcott designed winery-cellar door-café building. I’ll be covering Lerida and its neighbours in my Wednesday column over the next few weeks. And in a brief visit recently thought these two estate-grown wines to be outstanding. The shiraz, a gold medal winner, is a generous, silky wine with lovely, peppery, cool-climate varietal character. The pinot is the best I’ve seen from the estate yet. It’s clean as a whistle and though in a lighter style, shows pure varietal perfume, flavour and layered texture.

Henschke Lenswood Croft Chardonnay 2006 $45, Lenswood Giles Pinot Noir 2005 $46, Mount Edelstone Shiraz 2004 $93, Cyril Henschke Cabernet Sauvignon 2004
These and the Abbott’s Prayer Merlot and Louis Semillon reviewed last week make up the current Henschke release – an extraordinary line up of estate-grown Eden Valley and Lenswood wines. Croft Chardonnay shows the white peach character and finesse and style of cool-grown chardonnay; Giles Pinot shows very pure, fine varietal character and depth; Mount Edelstone expresses Eden Valley shiraz from very old vines: it’s highly aromatic, has limpid colour with an elegant structure to match and delivers exceptional flavour concentration without heaviness. ‘Cyril’, too, shows great flavour concentration in its own very cabernet way – and that means heaps of firm tannin to match the powerful fruit.

Clos Pierre Yarra Valley Pinot Noir 2005 $15.90 to $20
Burgundian winemaker Pierre Naigeon met France’s trade commissioner while visiting Australia, married her and now has the perfect excuse to return with her each year. In an exchange arrangement with De Bortoli’s Steve Webber, Pierre makes Yarra Valley pinot noir at De Bortoli’s winery while Steve makes real Burgundy in the village of Gevrey-Chambertin. Woolworths buys Naigeon’s Aussie pinot and other wines, offering them under the Clos Pierre label at Dan Murphy outlets. The 2005 Pierre’s second vintage continues to drink well six months after its release and delivers much of this difficult variety’s charms at a low price.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Niche white that viognier

Viognier’s a niche variety and likely to stay that way. Why? Well, for one it has too much flavour and individuality.

How can a wine have too much flavour? Well, look, for example, at gewürztraminer. Its heady, lychee-like aroma and viscous texture might be unforgettable, and a joy to drink on occasion. But that’s the problem: a little goes a long way. It’s simply too much to drink regularly.

If viognier (a native of France’s Rhône valley) falls into that category it has, in Australia, the considerable advantage of being relatively unknown.

While gewürztraminer – of which there are some very fine examples, like Hanging Rock from Macedon, Victoria – suffers from its use in bland, sweet blends with riesling, viognier walked straight into the premium end of the market sans popular pre-conception.

Viognier’s short history in Australia, as outlined here a few weeks back, parallels its resurgence in France.

Winemaker interest in the variety seems to have begun in the late seventies. According to Yalumba, Heathcote winery, central Victoria, probably trialled viognier prior to Yalumba’s acquisition of cuttings from Montpellier, France, in 1979. Yalumba propagated these cuttings and planted 1.2 hectares on the Vaughan vineyard, Eden Valley, in 1980, and claims this as Australia’s first commercial planting.

This vineyard remains a source of Yalumba’s ‘The Virgilius’, its flagship viognier that inspired many of the outstanding wines to have emerged from eastern Australia in the past decade.

These come, broadly speaking, in two main styles: those that feature the unadorned, plump, viscous, opulent, apricot-like flavour of the variety; and those attempting to incorporate that flavour into a matrix with others derived from fermentation and maturation on yeast lees in oak barrels.

The latter, modelled on the best of Condrieu, a village in France’s Rhône Valley, can achieve a high level of complexity. But even with this high level of winemaker artifice, ultimate quality is driven by the quality of fruit – just as it is with oak fermented chardonnay.

The divergence of the two styles is reflected in price, too. The opulent, simple, fruity wines generally come from higher cropping vineyards and don’t bear the purchasing or winemaking costs of oak. Wines like Canberra’s Meeting Place, Stepping Stone Padthaway and Yalumba Eden Valley, for example, generally deliver the variety’s plush flavour and leave change out of $20.

But as you move up to the hand crafted versions (with the high costs of lower yields, hand-picking and sorting and oak fermentation) prices step up accordingly – to $45 a bottle and more.

Regardless of which style you go for, viognier delivers a unique spectrum of flavours, whether overtly or subtly. That’s what the winemaker quest is all about – capturing the varietal character and, at the same time, expressing regional, clonal and winemaker inputs.

A tasting of eight Aussie viogniers this week showed the common and divergent traits of the variety. I describe them very briefly below in the order in which they were tasted, along with my score out 20 points.

I use the Australian wine-show scoring system in which 12 points or lower is a faulty, unpleasant wine; 13-15 is sound but unexciting; 15.5-16.5 wins a bronze medal – meaning a faultless wine that fits the class description; 17-18 point wins a silver medal – meaning an exciting drop, but not quite in the first league; and 18.5 to 20 points wins a gold medal – these are outstanding wines.

Ravensworth Canberra District Viognier 2006 17.5 points
Another classy barrel-ferment viognier from Bryan Martin. Not far behind the best.

Tahbilk Nagambie Lakes Viognier 2006 15/20
A vibrant and pleasant wine with a strong, estery/passionfruit like aroma and flavour that was a little over the top for me – and not quite ‘viognier’ enough.

Grant Burge Chaff Mill Adelaide Hills Barossa Valley Viognier 2005 17 points
Shows considerable complexity from the barrel input, quite fresh and varietal. Very easy to savour a few glasses.

d’Arenberg The Last Ditch McLaren Vale Adelaide Hills Viognier 2006 16 points
An outstanding example of the ‘let-it-rip’ varietal style – apricot-like, opulent and very fresh, but simply upstaged by the more complex company.

Fox-Gordon Barossa Valley Viognier 2006 15.5 points
From the southern Barossa, this one’s big, fat and juicy – definitely viognier but will probably fatten up quickly, so drink now.

Petaluma Adelaide Hills Viognier 2005 19.0
A simply stunning wine – seductively aromatic, tingly fresh, finely textured for viognier, yet unmistakably of that variety and with a lingering, delicious flavour.

Clonakilla Canberra District Viognier 2006 18.5 points
Not long bottled and very complex, soft and layered, with a wonderful texture. Only just pipped by the Petaluma in this tasting but it could be a different result after another six months in bottle.

Yarra Burn Yarra Valley Viognier 2004 16.0 points
This was surprisingly fresh and fine for viognier – as the variety normally fattens and fades quickly. The focus seemed to be more on texture and structure and less on overt varietal flavour, although it was definitely there.

Conclusion? Our best viogniers, like our best chardonnays, are whites to savour; the cheaper ones are more in-your-face, fade young and tend to heaviness. The flavours, however, are unique and pleasant. Be adventurous and try the best. But, like me, you might find that one or two bottles a year are enough.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Beer review — Coopers Dark & Newcastle Brown ales

Coopers Dark Ale 375ml $2.35
Cooper’s ads invite you to meet the dark side of the family – Dark Ale. While it’s dark in colour it’s comparatively low in alcohol (4.5 per cent) — meaning lighter body but not a lack of flavour. It has ale’s fruity aromas and, under that, a touch of roast-coffee-like character. The palate is rich but lively with a very fresh, crisp, dry finish.

Newcastle Brown Ale 330ml $3.25
While this is on the blander end of the ale scale, it’s only modestly alcoholic at 4.7 per cent, and offers attractive toffee and caramel like aromas and flavours. Together with the sweet, malt character this gives an attractive warming effect, while a decent tweak of hops dries the finish out nicely.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007