Yearly Archives: 2007

Beer review — Duvel & Grimburgen

Duvel 330ml $7.99
Duvel, one of Belgium’s best known brews, is a love-it or hate-it high alcohol (8.5 per cent) wheat ale. It has a pale lemon colour, luxurious foam and subtle, lightly fruity aroma. The high alcohol kicks in on the palate, adding body and warmth to offset the typical wheat beer acid and astringency.

Grimburgen Dubbel Abbey Beer 330m $7.99
Grimburgen is a dark brown, mahogany-tinted barley malt and wheat beer with a lightly malty, fruity, seductive aroma. The palate’s soft and buoyant with delicious, fine molasses/malt flavours that meld seamlessly with the 6.5 per cent alcohol. It’s a big but tender beer to sip and savour after dinner.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Origins of lager

The emergence of lager is often linked to the history of Urquell – the golden, bitter beer from Pilzen, Czech Republic.

But it seems that lager brewing developed in Bavaria, Germany, centuries before the technique (of low-temperature, bottom fermenting) transformed the beers of Pilzen, from 1842, into global style models.

In concise timeline of beer history Professor Linda Raley, of Texas Tech University, dates German lager brewing from 1420.

Lager brewing seems to have improved during the 1820s and 1830s, to have spread over Europe and to have reached Pilzen in 1842.

There, in combination with the soft water, pale malts and aromatic Saaz hops, Urquell developed the pale-golden, rich, aromatic and refreshingly bitter beer style that was ultimately imitated around the world.

These derivatives often sell as ‘Pilsen’ or ‘Pilsener’. Amongst craft brewers the name usually signals a lager of greater richness, aroma and lingering bitterness than we find in popular commercial lagers.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan

The power of a regional specialty

The emergence of shiraz as Canberra’s strongest wine variety is fortuitous for the region’s vignerons. Why? Because it plugs in neatly to a growing global view that Australia is the world’s shiraz specialist. And, arguably, the greater the diversity of styles we deliver the wider the interest that we’ll generate.

Phil Laffer, one of Australia’s most internationally renowned winemakers, puts it succinctly, ‘We’ve adopted shiraz as our own because we’re one of the few countries that makes it really well’.

Shiraz enjoys the added advantage of being mainstream. Australia crushes and drinks more shiraz than it does of any other wine variety, opening a tremendous opportunity for Canberra vignerons.

Clonakilla was the first Canberra winery to succeed with shiraz. But when John Kirk planted it in 1972 it wasn’t the darling grape that it is now. Back then shiraz didn’t rate alongside the so-called ‘noble’ varieties – riesling, chardonnay, cabernet sauvignon and pinot noir.

Like other district pioneers Kirk planted a range of varieties and through decades of trial and error learned how each performed. Ultimately, shiraz, blended with viognier, triumphed spectacularly.

But there’s a salient lesson in its slow climb to fame. Just look at this sequence in the Clonakilla shiraz viognier history:

  • 1972 – Dr John Kirk plants shiraz at Clonakilla, Murrumbateman.
  • Mid 1970s to 1989 – shiraz is blended with cabernet sauvignon.
  • 1986 John Kirk and son Jeremy plant the white variety, viognier.
  • 1990 – Clonakilla’s first straight shiraz wins silver and gold medals and trophies.
  • 1991 – John’s son, Tim, visits legendary Rhône Valley maker, Marcel Guigal, and is ‘transfixed and delighted’ by Guigal’s shiraz–viognier blends from the Côte-Rôtie’s impossibly steep slopes.
  • 1992 – Tim and John add viognier to shiraz for the first time.
  • 1997 – Tim Kirk moves from Melbourne to Canberra and becomes full time winemaker.
  • 1999 – The 1998 vintage receives a 92/100 rating from American critic Robert M. Parker and is nominated as NSW wine of the year.
  • 2001 – Influential UK wine critic, Jancis Robinson, rates Clonakilla as one of her two favourite Aussie shirazes.

The first thing we learn from this is that if a grape variety suits a site it’ll show in the quality of the wine – as it did in that first Clonakilla Shiraz in 1990, almost twenty years after the vines had been planted.

Secondly, we know that if a variety suits one site in a region, then there’s a good chance – climate being the biggest single determinant – that it’ll be generally well suited to the region. And so it’s proven to be.

Even before Hardy’s moved here in the late 1990s they’d been sourcing shiraz for top shelf blends, including the $100 Eileen Hardy. They’d been particularly impressed by fruit from Andrew McEwin’s Murrumbateman vineyard, planted by Ron McKenzie in 1982.

Former Hardy winemaker, Alex McKay, rated this fruit second only to Clonakilla in the district. He also identified several other promising shiraz vineyards.

Clonakilla’s success and the Hardy presence encouraged wider planting of shiraz in the district. And, over time, we’ve seen it dominate the local wine show, taking out top honours every year since 1998, and outnumbering all other varieties in the medal tallies.

The compelling argument for shiraz doesn’t rule out other varieties. Rather, it presents a powerful opportunity for Canberra to cut through in the crowded domestic and global wine markets.

A stunningly good wine like Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier has the potential to stamp a whole district with class. And as local peers emerge over time – and that’s already begun to happen – the reputation can gain depth.

A single, powerful regional specialty makes a dramatic impact on drinkers. Think of Marlborough and Sauvignon Blanc, Coonawarra and cabernet sauvignon or Burgundy and chardonnay and pinot noir.

An important difference between these French and Australasian examples is that in Burgundy, vignerons can’t diversify into other varieties. Their Aussie and Kiwi counterparts can plant what they like where they like.

For Canberra that means we can seize our overwhelmingly obvious shiraz advantage while continuing to work with other promising grapes.

Unquestionably our second major opportunity lies with riesling. It’s one of the great grape varieties. It drinks beautifully when young, but also ages beautifully. And it shows flashes of brilliance across the region. What Canberra hasn’t seen yet, though, is a riesling of a stature to match that of our best shiraz. But that will almost certainly come.

Riesling’s draw back is that despite being talked up for the last thirty years, volumes remain static. This limits opportunities for local makers. But, like shiraz, it has the potential to build our regional identity and reward those who excel at it. Full marks to Ken Helm for his huge efforts with riesling.

Viognier, the white variety now being blended in with shiraz around the district could be our third string, albeit occupying an even smaller niche than riesling. As with shiraz, Clonakilla led the way – and still does. But Hardys made a few crackers in their brief stint in Canberra. And we’ve seen several other lovely examples. It’s clearly suited to the district and has a long-term future here.

The pinot noir story has moved on since first being planted in a cooler Canberra in the seventies. The cutting edge stuff – and that’s what builds regional reputations – now comes from southerly locations including New Zealand, Tasmania, Mornington Peninsula and Gippsland. Show me the great Canberra examples and I’ll change my mind. But, by all means, if makers believe in it and customers like it, persevere.

Cabernet, too, to my palate, is an also ran for Canberra. It has a following and we make decent wine from it, but it’s not in the reputation-building league as far as I can see.

Ubiquitous chardonnay makes appealing wine across the district. As with pinot noir, however, the best now emerge from much cooler regions and I suspect that it will never be a Canberra hallmark. We could continue to see some exceptions, though, from Lark Hill high up on the Lake George escarpment.

Where I do see wonderful opportunities, though, and potential rewards for growers and drinkers is in largely untested Italian, Spanish and French varieties.

Tim and John Kirk, for example, are about to plant grenache on an elevated, warm site in Murrumbateman; Frank van de Loo makes exciting reds from tempranillo and graciano at Mount Majura (and a lovely white pinot gris); Bryan Martin’s Murrumbateman red sangiovese and white marsanne click the right hyperlinks; and out at Lake George Winery, Alex McKay has an impressive 2007 tempranillo in barrel.

Not everything that’s tried will work. But as the Kirk’s have shown, it’s what we trial today that makes tomorrow’s winners, provided we recognise quality and work hard to perfect and promote it.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Aussie beer emulates German classic Bock style

The strong, dark beer style we know today as Bock originated centuries ago in Einbeck, northern Germany.

Over time, the Bock family proliferated in Germany before emigrating. Today it’s made throughout the world in a diversity of styles – within a generally dark, high-alcohol, malty, low-bitterness framework.

These are generally nourishing, winter warming beers packed full of malt sweetness, with interesting variants like the more concentrated Dopplebocks and highly alcoholic Eisbocks.

And in the USA, Samuel Adams brews a viscous ‘triple Bock’ that smells and tastes like vegemite and weighs in at a port-like eighteen per cent alcohol. to my palate it’s more curio than drink.

More approachable by far is Sydney’s Redoak Bock, brewed by David Hollyoak. The combination of dark Munich malts, Hallertau hops and Bavarian lager yeast creates a smooth, rich, malty beer with a refreshing hops edge. It’s available on tap at Redoak or in bottle. See www.redoak.com.au.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Tyrrell’s, d’Arenberg & Marius Wines

Tyrrell’s Brokenback Hunter Valley Shiraz 2004 $20
The best Hunter shiraz has a fine-ness that belies its warm-climate origins. In the old days these were often called ‘Hunter Burgundy’ – partly in keeping with generic labelling of the time and partly because of structural, if not flavour, similarities to Burgundy (i.e. pinot noir from France’s Burgundy region). Good Hunter shiraz can be comparatively pale coloured, velvety smooth, surprisingly fine boned and extremely long lived. This modestly priced version from Tyrrell’s is sensational at the price. It delivers the flavour and finesse of the regional style and uses a subtle touch of French oak (in a generally old, large oak vat maturation regime) to add an attractive spicy bite to the flavour and finish.

d’Arenberg The Custodian McLaren Vale Grenache 2005 $19.95
Wrattonbully Vineyards Wrattonbully Tempranillo 2006 $18.55

I offer this combined tasting note because in Spain these two varieties are often blended together — and the Chateau Shanahan team tasted the wines side-by-side at a Spanish restaurant. Five tasters expressed a preference for the grenache, a particularly solid version of this style. It’s earthy, rich and sweet fruited with a savoury dryness that goes well with food – a particularly good example that avoids the tendency to confection-like flavours that can be a turn off.  The more fine-boned tempranillo is an impressive first release, after years of trials, from the Hill-Smith family’s vineyards at Wrattonbully, on the Limestone Coast, abutting Coonawarra on the northeast.

Marius Wines McLaren Vale:

  • Simpatico Single Vineyard Shiraz 2005 $24
  • Symphony Single Vineyard Shiraz 2005 $34
  • The Symposium Shiraz Mourvedre 2006 $29

These silky, delicious wines paint subtly different shades of shiraz, McLaren Vale’s dominant red variety. Crimson-rimmed Symposium shows the red-currant-like, aromatic lift of mourvedre melding seamlessly with the ripe shiraz – a fine, soft, seductive introduction to the trio. Simpatico is pure McLaren Vale shiraz – sweet, ripe and savoury with a tight and assertive-but-smooth tannic grip. Symphony, too, is pure shiraz but with a greater volume of seductive, ripe-cherry varietal aroma – characters that flow through in a luxurious, plush, irresistible palate. Made in the same way by the same winemaker (Roger Pike), Simpatico and Symphony simply reflect variations on the shiraz theme from different vineyards. See www.mariuswines.com.au

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Beer review — Debowe Mocne & Mongozo

Debowe Mocne 500ml $5.99
Feel like a brew that claims to be ‘an excellent proposal for real men who expect from beer truly beer-like sensations’? What it offers is dark colour, high alcohol (seven per cent) and a burly, malty flavour with alcohol astringency and a bitter, verging on acrid, finish.

Mongozo Banana 330ml $4.99
Yuk. Let’s give a star for being fresh and beer. But not even ‘fair trade organic bananas’ save Mongozo from the compost bin. Better there than consumed. It’s bright, fresh and beer-like. But it’s oh, so cloyingly sweet and confection like. Perhaps I’m missing something. But I’ll be glad when I’ve enough.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Wine review — Madfish, Cape Mentelle, Jacob’s Creek, Chandon, Tyrrell’s & La Chablisienne

Madfish Western Australia Sauvignon Blanc Semillon 2007 $15–$19
Cape Mentelle Margaret River Sauvignon Blanc Semillon 2007 $25

Today’s summer-drinking selections feature three pairs of proven regional varietal specialties. The first pair are brilliant, contrasting examples of one of Australia’s most popular blends – sauvignon blanc and semillon from southwestern Western Australia. Madfish is all about zingy, fresh, tropical fruit flavours – a pure, all-fruit wine to wash away the day’s cares. Cape Mentelle’s blend hits the senses a bit harder, starting with the intense herbal, pungent aroma that both varieties seem to deliver in Margaret River. These intense flavours drive the palate, too. But there’s an oak-fermentation and-maturation richness to the texture making the wine all the more interesting.

Jacob’s Creek Reserve Chardonnay Pinot Noir 2004 $15–$19
Chandon Tasmanian Cuvée 2004 $39

To make top-shelf sparkling wine, the classic varieties pinot noir and chardonnay must be grown in very cool to cold regions where grape flavour develops while acidity remains high. And that’s led our leading makers to Tassie and high-altitude, southerly mainland sites over the last twenty years. Jacob’s Creek Reserve is a chardonnay dominant blend from cool sites, including Tasmania. Chardonnay drives the aroma and flavour, while pinot gives the wonderful taut structure that stamps it with class. This is serious bubbly at a bargain price.  Chandon, from Tasmania’s Coal River Valley, is a bronze tinted pinot dominant blend of extraordinary intensity and lovely complex, nutty aftertaste.

Tyrrell’s Moon Mountain Hunter Valley Chardonnay 2006 $17 to $20
Chablis (La Chablisienne) 2005 $24–$29.99

Chardonnay shows it’s extraordinary versatility in this pair from the warm Hunter Valley and cold Chablis, France – the former a maritime environment at latitude thirty-three degrees south; the latter a continental site at forty-seven degrees north. They’re from regional masters Tyrrell’s and the La Chablisienne cooperative. Moon Mountain sits at the finer, leaner (but texturally rich) end of the regional style spectrum. There’s a beautiful buoyancy, finesse and lightness to it. La Chablisienne, imported by Coles Group (Vintage Cellars and 1st Choice), presents the unique, teasingly succulent, finesse and dryness of Chablis. No drink on earth goes better with a platter of fresh, briny south-coast oysters.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Beer review — Erdinger Weissbier & Brok Sambor

Erdinger Weissbier Mit Feiner Hefe 500ml $5.99
This is a first-class, bottle-conditioned Bavarian wheat beer. The spontaneous head hints of quality – a promise fulfilled by the pure, delicate, fruity aroma and vibrant, fresh palate. It’s round and sweet — but delicate at the same time — and balanced by a refreshing, crisp acidity.

Brok Sambor Export 500ml $3.79
From Poland, Brok Sambor, at 5.7 per cent alcohol, sits at the sturdier end of the lager spectrum. It has a fragrant and appealing hops-led aroma, supported by sweet malt. The malt richness comes through on a smooth, full-bodied palate. But the malt’s held in check by delicious, moderately bitter hops.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

A judge’s drinking guide from the 2007 Canberra Regional Wine Show

Last week I presented the industry perspective on the Canberra Regional Wine Show, but what’s in it for consumers? Well, read on and for a guide to dozens of delicious wines coming from Canberra and surrounding regions – Tumbarumba, Gundagai, Southern Highlands, South Coast and Hilltops (Young).

You can troll through the catalogue of results at www.rncas.org.au. And if you do don’t limit the shopping list to the gold medal and trophy winners, because there’s great drinking among the silver and bronze medallists, too.

This applies especially to some of the emerging or niche varieties. Semillon, for example, while unlikely to achieve much in Canberra, is the star variety at Coolangatta Estate, Nowra. These Tyrrell-made wines are unique and lovely. The stand out in this year’s show was their mature-but-fresh silver-medal winning 1998 vintage.

Closer to home at Gundaroo, pure, rich, apricot-like silver medallist Tallagandra Hill Viognier 2006 came within a sniff of gold and showed, yet again, how well suited Canberra is to this variety. Clonakilla blazed the way, Hardy’s encouraged wider planting of it amongst independent growers and established a significant plot at Holt. We’ll be hearing a lot more of viognier in Canberra, despite Hardy’s exit from the region.

We judged several promising whites made from pinot gris but to this judge, anyway, silver medallist Mount Majura Pinot Gris 2007 soared above the others. It’s a particularly vibrant and pure white wine made by Frank van de Loo.

Bryan and Jocelyn Martin’s Ravensworth Murrumbateman Sangiovese 2006, another silver medal winner, presents a bright, fresh, modern face of this classic Italian variety without losing the slightly rustic, savoury tannin structure. This is another significant, trail-blazing local wine.

In the past, Hardy’s tended to dominate the sparkling wine class with its Tumbarumba-based pinot noir chardonnay blends made by Ed Carr. However, Kosciusko Wines of Tumbarumba and Gallagher Wines of Murrumbateman, plugged the gap created by their exit, this year.

Gallagher Blanc de Blanc 2005, made from Murrumbateman chardonnay, won silver. It’s a very appealing, well-made example of this lighter aperitif style. Gold medal winner Kosciusko Scius Pinot Noir Chardonnay 2005 showed the sheer class of fruit from cold Tumbarumba – and the extra dimension and structure added by pinot noir. This is another significant regional wine.

Ever-so-fashionable sauvignon blanc shows a glimmer of hope in two attractive and contrasting silver medallists: taut, pungent and pure McWilliam’s Barwang Tumbarumba 2007 and funky, softer Brindabella Hills Canberra District 2007.

It would be fair to say that pinot noir remains a niche variety for the district, despite high ambitions for it from Lerida Estate at Lake George and Lark Hill, higher up on the Lake George Escarpment.

Lark Hill no longer enters the show, which is a pity. And Lerida topped the pinot noir classes, winning a silver medal for its fragrant, silky-textured 2006. At the exhibitors’ tasting proprietor Jim Lumbers said he’s confident of an even better performance in future vintages.

In the national wine market riesling, too, remains a niche — albeit much discussed –variety. But it’s a star of the Canberra District and will be even better when our makers eliminate faults that blemish outstanding fruit.

Frost and drought slashed the 2007 riesling harvest, hence we had just eleven rieslings to judge, of which eight won medals: gold for Wallaroo, silver for Gallagher, Mount Majura and Helm Classic Dry and bronze for Pialligo Estate, Brindabella Hills and Four Winds. These are all lovely, fresh wines and strongly recommended.

A riesling topped the white museum classes, too. Wallaroo 2002 (gold) came in ahead Coolangatta Semillon 199 (silver) and Coolangatta Alexander Berry Chardonnay 2000 and Barwang Chardonnay 1996 on bronze.

Cabernet’s thirty-three per cent medal strike rate was the lowest of the mainstream varieties that exhibited in significant numbers.

But there were several attractive silver medallists: Shaw Vineyard Estate Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 and Cabernet Shiraz 2004, Lambert 2004, McWilliams Barwang 2005 and Little Bridge 2005.

Fifteen of the twenty-four chardonnays exhibited earned medals. The only gold medallist, Bidgeebong Icon 2006 comes from Tumbarumba.  And demonstrating chardonnay’s versatility, the silver and bronze medallists came from Tumbarumba, Southern Highlands, South Coast, Hilltops, Lake George, Mount Majura and Murrumbateman.

Saving the best for last, shiraz, once again, was star of the show and certainly heads any consumer-shopping list for the region. We judged forty-five shirazes and awarded seven gold medals, six silver medals and 16 bronze medals.

The winners came in a diversity of styles – within a generally refined, medium-bodied theme – from Murrumbateman, Lake George, Hilltops and Wamboin. In the taste-off for the trophy, the beautifully fragrant, silky Lerida Estate Lake George Shiraz Viognier 2006 beat velvety, supple Chalkers Crossing Hilltops 2005 by two votes to one.

Other absolutely wonderful shirazes included gold medallists Nick O’Leary Canberra 2006, Lambert Canberra 2004, Lambert Reserve Canberra 2005 and Barwang Hilltops 2005; and silver medallists Ravensworth Canberra 2006, Chalkers Crossing Hilltops 2004, Lerida Canberra 2005, Lambert Reserve Canberra 2004 and Barwang Hilltops 2004.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007

Pop and craft brewers hop in opposite directions

As pop beers grow ever less bitter, there’s a smaller but vigorous move in the opposite direction as boutique makers crank up the hops component of their brews.

And the hops expression varies enormously thanks to the use of many different varieties added at varying stages of the brewing process.

Wonderfully named hops variants such a fuggles, amarillo, goldings and saaz each inject their own character to a wide spectrum of aromas and flavours and to the bitterness of a brew.

Before hops made its way into brewing beer was probably sweeter than it is today. And makers used a variety of botanicals, including herbs, spices and tree bark, to offset this.

However, only the flower of humulus lupulus, a rapidly growing summer climber, provides the complex mix of resins, alpha and beta acids, oils and polyphenols that profoundly influence the structure, aroma, flavour and bitterness of modern beers.

Copyright © Chris Shanahan 2007